Frustration, disappointment over health funding in Budget 2017

Health minister Jonathan Coleman said the government was committed to delivering better health services.
RICKY WILSON/FAIRFAX NZ

Health minister Jonathan Coleman said the government was committed to delivering better health services.

Patients and healthcare workers say they have been left frustrated and disappointed by "inadequate" funding for health in the 2017 Budget.

They said the Government's announcements on Thursday would not go nearly far enough in addressing concerns about overworked staff, access to new medicines, and access to mental health treatment.

The Government said total health spending would be a record $16.77 billion in 2017/18 - an increase of $879 million, with an overall increase of $3.9b over the next four years.

NZN VIDEO

Budget 2017: Finance Minister Steven Joyce gave DHBs $1.8 billion for the provision of tertiary health services over the next four years.

However, the record claim does not take inflation into account, and sidesteps the fact that almost half the spending will go toward mandated wage increases as part of the pay equity settlement.

READ MORE:
Budget 2017: Health funding to record levels with $1.7b injection to DHBs
Most people believe the government is failing in providing mental health care - survey
Mental health advocates support Mike King's stance on suicide prevention
Nine in 10 healthcare workers feel understaffed and under-resourced
Neuroendocrine cancer sufferers take on Pharmac

Here, Stuff dives behind the press releases to look at three key areas of Vote Health.

Only one in 10 Kiwis think the government is doing enough to tackle mental health in New Zealand.
LAWRENCE SMITH/FAIRFAX NZ

Only one in 10 Kiwis think the government is doing enough to tackle mental health in New Zealand.

MENTAL HEALTH

The government committed $224m in funding for mental health in this year's Budget.

That includes $100m for a new cross-government social investment fund that will "target innovative new proposals to tackle mental health issues".

A majority of healthcare workers in New Zealand feel they face an unreasonable workload.
123RF

A majority of healthcare workers in New Zealand feel they face an unreasonable workload.

A further $100m will go to District Health Boards to support local mental health and addiction services, with funding also earmarked for Maori suicide prevention.

Ad Feedback

Mental Health Foundation spokesperson Sophia Graham welcomed the funding announcement as a "really positive step in the right direction".

However, she cautioned it was too early to celebrate.

Libby Burgess says Kiwi women with breast cancer will miss out on at least four effective new medicines.
JASON OXENHAM/FAIRFAX NZ

Libby Burgess says Kiwi women with breast cancer will miss out on at least four effective new medicines.

"It seems like a lot of money, but we need to see a commitment to sustained increases in funding," she said.

"It's critically important to look at how the money is spent, and make sure we don't just keep doing the same things that don't work."

Graham said key measures for success would be a reduction in the number of suicides, and a reduction in the number of people presenting critically ill at mental health units.

Andy Colwell stands in front of 200 life-sized cut-outs of health workers, said to represent 20,000 health workers ...
Supplied

Andy Colwell stands in front of 200 life-sized cut-outs of health workers, said to represent 20,000 health workers missing due to underfunding.

Meanwhile, mental health workers and union representatives said the funding was only a fraction of what was needed to adequately respond to demand.

Social worker Andy Colwell said he expected to see the gap between demand and funding get even worse as a result of Budget 2017.

"As a mental health worker, seeing families struggling with life-threatening situations not being seen as urgent is incredibly frustrating, and knowing it will get worse is incredibly distressing," Colwell said.

Dr Graeme Jarvis estimates it would cost $200 million to clear Pharmac's backlog of drugs waiting for funding.
SUPPLIED

Dr Graeme Jarvis estimates it would cost $200 million to clear Pharmac's backlog of drugs waiting for funding.

Health Minister Jonathan Coleman acknowledged there had been an increase in demand for mental health and addiction services in recent years.

"Cabinet will soon consider a new mental health and addiction strategy, which will include our new approach to dealing with mental health issues," he said.

Erin Polaczuk, national secretary for the Public Service Association, repeated calls for an independent review following the Budget announcement.

"It's disappointing but not surprising that the Government is still refusing to have an urgent independent review, which is necessary for a new approach to mental health that values patients and staff," Polaczuk said.

Mental health was the key focus for Vote Health 2017, following a stream of negative stories about cuts within the struggling sector.

The Government faced pressure to deliver, with a recent poll by UMR Research showing that only one in 10 New Zealanders thought enough was being done to tackle mental health.

Earlier this month Mike King came out against the Government's suicide prevention strategy, while Mental Health Foundation chief executive Shaun Robinson criticised the government's 38-page strategy document for failing to set any specific targets.

Last month, the People's Mental Health Review found respondents were worried about long wait times, strain on workers, and an under-resourced system.

OVERWORKED STAFF

Healthcare workers say they have increasingly borne the brunt of New Zealand's health funding squeeze.

The Budget allowed for wage increases for 55,000 care and disability support workers as part of the recent pay equity settlement.

That will cost $1.54b - nearly half of the $3.9b spending increase scheduled for the next four years.

Additional funding will go toward disability support services and emergency ambulance services. However, Coleman made no mention of overall healthcare staffing levels on Budget day.

Earlier in May he announced the number of doctors and nurses had increased by more than 6900 since National came to power in 2008.

Despite that, critics say overall staffing has failed to keep pace with the demands of an increasing population that is also ageing.

Jane MacGeorge, acting CEO for the NZ Nurses Organisation, said the Budget was a huge disappointment for nurses who already faced declining morale and job satisfaction.

"It's not enough," she said.

"We know that nurses are a cost-effective way of delivering better healthcare to our communities, so this is a real concern. Nurses are really committed in the face of these restraints, but it's putting a real strain on health infrastructure."

A survey of almost 6000 paramedics, nurses, mental health workers and support staff earlier in 2017 found 90 per cent felt the healthcare system was understaffed and under-resourced.

Some said they feared burnout could be jeopardising patient safety, and 72 per cent said their workload was not reasonable.

In March, a slew of new mothers came forward with horror stories about their negative birthing experiences due to staffing shortages in maternity wards.

One mother said poor communication from overworked staff had made things much worse than they needed to be, and as a result she felt put off from ever having another baby.

ACCESS TO MEDICINES

Vote Health also budgeted an extra $60m over the next four years for Pharmac, the government body responsible for funding medicines.

Coleman touted the increase as benefiting more than 33,000 New Zealanders.

However, it won't go far toward clearing a backlog of more than 90 drugs that have been recommended but are yet to receive funding.

The lack of access has forced cancer sufferers such as Jess Spence to travel to Australia to receive treatment that is not available in New Zealand.

One recent study ranked New Zealand 20th out of 20 OECD countries in terms of accessing new medicines.

The Breast Cancer Aotearoa Coalition welcomed the increased in funding for Pharmac, but warned it was not enough to make a real difference.

Chair Libby Burgess said Kiwi women with breast cancer would miss out on at least four effective new medicines as a result of the restricted funding.

"Our lack of funding for new and innovative medicines is robbing New Zealanders with serious illnesses of the opportunity to live full and long lives," she said.

"We need a significant funding boost for medicines in this country to ensure we can offer first-world healthcare."

Burgess's disappointment was echoed by Sandra Kirby, the CEO of Arthritis NZ, who said New Zealand was falling well behind in treatment access compared to other countries such as Australia.

"In Australia somebody might be able to cycle through three or four different drugs to find the one that works best for them, and we just don't have that luxury," Kirby said.

"These new drugs can actually arrest the disease in its tracks, and stop irreversible damage."

Graeme Jarvis, general manager of Medicines NZ, said the long waiting list for new drugs illustrated that Pharmac's current level of funding was inadequate.

"The sad thing is that some of these have been waiting with high priority for six years," Jarvis said. "Other medicines have been waiting up to a decade for funding."

"Some of these new drugs have given people a new lease on life, and actually allowed them to be healthy and productive again."

Jarvis estimated it would cost around $200 million to clear the backlog of drugs waiting for funding, or around $40 per person.

"Let's fund Pharmac at the right level, so it can do its job correctly, and patients get the right medicines at the right time," he said.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Woman and son missing

Tina Whaitiri is 45 and was last seen wearing black pants and a black long-sleeved top.

Police have "serious concerns" for welfare of a West Auckland woman and her young son.

DHBs budget blowout

Minister of Health Jonathan Coleman insists there will be no service cuts to DHBs around the country despite forecast ...

Several district health boards around the country are under pressure to reduce budget blowouts.

Funeral for young author

Ramirez was described as an amazing wife, beloved daughter, darling sister and "crazy fun aunty".

Hundreds farewell Amy Joy Ramirez, who died after falling from a horse while on her honeymoon.

Fracture sidelines star rider

Shaun Fannin is confident he will be back in the saddle for Great Northern day on September 9.

Brave jockey rides more than five and a half km's over 22 jumps with a broken wrist.

Wellington

Disability support a 'black hole'

Nicola Parsons waited a year to get early intervention services for Sam. The Ministry of Education's target is to have ...

Preschoolers and their families waiting months for first appointment with early intervention services.

Fight for $50K ring

The woman was unsuccessful in a bid to have her $50,000 engagement ring returned from her former partner.

A Hawke's Bay woman has lost her bid to keep her $50,000 engagement ring after the relationship ended.

New notch in town belt

A map of the land acquired by the Wellington City Council to become part of the town belt.

Wellington City Council has bought 4220sqm of Aro Valley land to add to town belt.

Micra nearly turns micro

The Nissan Micra that narrowly missed being slammed by falling rocks.

Husband tells of rocks falling on wife's car in dramatic Ngaio Gorge Rd slip.

Canterbury

Blacking out and 'stuck' video

Danny Watson says he often has to give several days notice when ordering a taxi, despite companies being required to ...

Danny Watson was blacking out. Paramedics needed to get him to hospital but taking an ambulance would put his life at risk.

Builder lived high life

Former Queenstown builder Jaden Melgren on a duckshooting trip.

Jaden Melgren, who owes at least $670,000, enjoyed a flamboyant life as his business slowly collapsed.

Gangster jailed for a decade

Enoka, the former president of the Christchurch chapter of the Rebels gang, has been jailed for 10 years for his offending.

A former Rebels gang president was "paranoid and certainly irrational" when he broke into a home while armed and high on meth.

Truck crash closes SH1

A truck has jackknifed on the Rakaia River bridge (SH1), closing the road for several hours on Wednesday.

Access to Rakaia River bridge blocked after truck crashes into rail overbridge.

Waikato

Mother warns of stranger danger

Blake Crossan, 10 was selling raffle tickets at the Hillcrest shops on Sunday when a taxi driver approached him and told ...

Mother warns parents after taxi driver's reportedly odd behaviour.

Fatal crash near Waihi

Athenree Gorge runs between Waihi Beach and Waihi township, north of Tauranga.

One dead and State Highway 2 closed after collision between car and petrol tanker in Bay of Plenty.

Highway man link to fatal fire

The scene of the fatal house fire.

Man seen standing on the side of the highway near scene sparks police appeal.

Holiday death shocks family

Michelle Robertson, left, photographed with her siblings Shannon, Paul and Kerryn at Paul's wedding.

Waikato's Michelle Robertson died of kidney failure while on a holiday in Rarotonga.

Taranaki

Not looking too far forward for Taranaki No 8

19082017 News Photo ANDY JACKSON/STUFF.  Mitre 10 cup rugby, Taranaki V Waikato at Yarrow Stadium in New Plymouth.  Toa ...

"My actions need to speak for themselves."

The next generation

22082017 News GRANT MATTHEW/STUFF

Taranaki rugby training. Logan Crowley

Young halfback the next of the Crowley generation to play rugby for Taranaki.

A gender diversity rainbow

Rainbow Youth representative Morgan Butler says there is no right or wrong time to 'come out'.

What do you do if you don't think you're a he or a she?

Sports medals found in raids

Detective Constable Tony Temple with medals recovered in a raid at a Waitara home.

Person found with the medals wasn't old enough to be a veteran runner and "didn't look like an athlete", police say.

Manawatu

Block to road upgrade cleared

22082017 Photo: MURRAY WILSON/STUFF	
James Line, Kelvin Grove, Palmerston North

Palmerston North's James Line has been cleared for an urban makeover.

More homes for city

Jacinda Adern announces more state houses for Palmerston North. On her right is Labour's Rangitikei candidate Heather ...

Political parties go into battle over housing in Palmerston North.

Live: Labour on tax

Labour leader Jacinda Ardern and deputy leader Grant Robertson talk about their tax plan.

Labour says now is not the time for tax cuts, but rules out an income tax or GST hike.

Pond house problems

Jillian Sinclair is struggling to find a house suitable for her special needs children, and fears she'll have to leave ...

She won a Tenancy Tribunal case against property manager, but still lives there.

Nelson

Takahe reintroduction on hold

Wild takahe will be released in the Gouland Downs next year.

Bad weather and early breeeding have delayed the release of takahe to the Kahurangi.

Rough sleeping banned

People like Peter Wilkie, left,  will no longer be able to sleep rough overnight in the Nelson CBD.

Nelson City Council bylaw puts in place ban on rough sleeping in city centre.

Holding pattern for poison drop

A drop of brodifacoum-laced poison bait in the Brook Waimarama Sanctuary is designed to wipe out predators before native ...

Preparations for the poison drop in the Brook Waimarama Sanctuary are in a holding pattern as a last-ditch court challenge is heard.

Salisbury School gets extension

Education Minister Nikki Kaye has given Salisbury School more breathing room.

Richmond school heartened by new talks with Ministry of Education about its future.

Marlborough

Cone and the Marlburian video

Mr Whippy franchise owner Len Shaw has sold a lot of ice cream in Marlborough.

Marlborough's Mr Whippy creams the competition, scoops national award.

Crash on SH6

Accident on SH6 near Rai Valley

A woman in her 20s has been hurt in a serious crash in Marlborough

Sawmill fire could have spread

The Kaikoura Volunteer Fire Brigade put out a sawmill fire on Wednesday.

Sparks from a welding winch have set fire to sawdust at a Kaikoura sawmill.

Duck hunter's maimai meltdown

Hunters use maimais during duck shooting season. (File photo)

Enraged man caught illegally hunting tells female ranger she should be at home looking after the children.

South Canterbury

Rare kaki released into wild video

51 kaki were released in the Mackenzie Basin on Tuesday.

Fifty one of the world's rarest wading birds have been released in the Mackenzie Basin.

Truck rolls on Evans St

A police spokewoman said it was understood the driver of this truck swerved to avoid another motorist before rolling on ...

SH1 is closed after a truck rolled as it swerved to avoid a aother vehicle in Timaru.

Disease at third farm

Cows on an a farm near Oamaru look likely to have been infected with the Mycoplasma bovis disease from a Van Leeuwen ...

Cow disease Mycoplasma bovis spreads to a third farm, this one in Oamaru.

Keeping skiers safe on roads

Inspector Dave Gaskin said police would be focusing resources on truck routes through the Mackenzie Country, such as ...

A police campaign to keep drivers safe on alpine roads gets underway on Thursday.

Otago

No pool for school

Wakatipu High School principal Steve Hall says students will have to use the Queenstown Event Centre for swimming ...

Wakatipu High School principal is disappointed the new premises won't have a swimming pool.

Airport has record profit

Passenger growth and night flights behind record profit for Queenstown Airport.

Passenger growth and night flights behind record profit for Queenstown Airport.

Builder lived high life, then fled

Former Queenstown builder Jaden Melgren on a duckshooting trip.

Jaden Melgren, who owes at least $670,000, enjoyed a flamboyant Queenstown life as his business slowly collapsed.

DHBs budget blowout

Minister of Health Jonathan Coleman insists there will be no service cuts to DHBs around the country despite forecast ...

Several district health boards around the country are under pressure to reduce budget blowouts.

Southland

Polyfest hits new heights video

Members of the Otatara Kindy on stage at Polyfest 2017

''They like the sense of whanau, they feel like they are a part of something."

Hospitality at the heart of the south

Ronald McDonald Family Room supervisor Helen Walker and volunteer Susan Stenton at the Ronald McDonald House ...

Southland's inaugural Purple Work Shirt Day is raising funds for Ronald McDonald House.

'Stubbornness' gets Grieve home

Dwight Grieve from Fiordland leads Jack McNaughton and Buddy Small in the early stages of the Southland championships in ...

Stubbornness and a want to succeed have helped Dwight Grieve claim the Southland Road Championship title in Te Anau on Saturday.

Quick thinking prevents injury

Fire crews attend a house fire on Dipton street, Invercargill, on Sunday afternoon.

An Invercargill family had a close shave following a house fire in Kingswell.

Ad Feedback