Dairy owners cry out for intervention as robberies continue video

Warwick Smith/Stuff

Dairy owner Manhar Patel and NZ Indian Central Association vice-president Paul Patel talk about the impact of robberies.

When the clock hits 3pm Jayesh Patel starts to sweat. 

The Rangiora Mini Market owner has seen robberies occur about 6pm, so as the afternoon edges toward evening the fear sets in. 

His mini mart on Rangiora Ave in Palmerston North has been robbed three times in the past seven years, with two of those occurring in the past six months. 

Rangiora Ave dairy owner Jayesh Patel is afraid of working in his store.

Rangiora Ave dairy owner Jayesh Patel is afraid of working in his store.

You can see in his eyes he doesn't want to talk about it. He fears retribution.

Criminals chased by a cat-food wielding dairy owner after armed robbery
Dannevirke BP Connect under attack from a sledgehammer
Palmerston North dairy robbed for third time in six years
Dairy robbed and shopkeeper assaulted, again

But he's been driven to speak out for change, as Patel knows this is an issue that isn't going away by itself.

Manhar Patel, the owner of Summerhays Corner Superette, wants to see harsher penalties for robbers.

Manhar Patel, the owner of Summerhays Corner Superette, wants to see harsher penalties for robbers.

A series of robberies in New Zealand has sparked debate about harsher sentences and the safety of people who sell cigarettes amid tax hikes. The Manawatu region has had a spate of robberies.

Since the latest robbery of his store, Patel said he had been too scared to let other family members work there. 

He was a victim himself once, being cut in the face by a robber in 2011, but rather than risk their lives, he takes on all the work himself.

The Pahiatua  BP was allegedly robbed at knifepoint this week.

The Pahiatua BP was allegedly robbed at knifepoint this week.

For the past four weeks Patel has started work at 7am and finished at 8pm, seven days a week. 

Ad Feedback

His only break is a quick 15-minute lunch. 

Patel said he was afraid to work in the store.

"But someone has to step up, otherwise we have no income to survive."

He said they could stop selling cigarettes but he didn't think that would solve the problem, as cash was also targeted in these robberies. 

What he thinks could solve the problem is harsher penalties for people convicted of the crimes. 

Having owned the dairy for 12 years, he said he had seen little change in government policy to help the situation, despite an increase in robberies. 

Manhar Patel owns the Summerhays Corner Superette in Palmerston North, which was robbed in 2015.

His shop has been robbed twice in the past 24 years.

The most recent robbery saw him looking down the barrel of a gun while cash was demanded.

He chased  the men involved down the street and police arrested them, with one sentenced to three years and four months' jail time.

Manhar Patel did not think this sentence was enough to deter criminals and said it was not enough to make up for the suffering those affected endured. 

He was still afraid to go to work. 

"There are so many robberies in New Zealand at the moment.

"After the robberies, we are very scared." 

BP Pahiatua was allegedly robbed at knifepoint this week and manager Valkesh Patel said the experience was a scary one. 

But reading about other stores being robbed was just as unsettling. 

Instead of feeling at ease at work, Valkesh Patel said he was always looking outside the shop to see who would be coming in. 

It was worse at night. 

"Sometimes if the person is wearing a hoodie it looks dodgy, so you feel unsafe."

Minister of Justice Amy Adams said nobody should feel unsafe at work.

"We're taking the concerns of shop owners seriously.

"It is worth noting that under the Crimes Act robbery is punishable by imprisonment for a term of up to 10 years and aggravated robbery is punishable by imprisonment for a term of up to 14 years.  This reflects the seriousness of these offences." 

Adams pointed out the Government had announced there would be 880 more frontline police officers nationally and "through Budget 2017 we're investing $13.9 million to reduce youth offending by providing rehabilitation and mentoring services to high-risk young people".

Two adults accused of robbing the Rangiora Mini Market in May appeared in court on Friday and were remanded in custody. 

A youth was also arrested and appeared in Youth Court.

Another 17-year-old male appeared in the Palmerston North District Court on Friday in relation to the robbery of the Rangiora Mini Market in December 2016.

Police opposed his bail, and he was remanded in custody until a date in June.

New Zealand Indian Central Association and Central Districts Indian Association vice-president Paul Patel said most dairy owners he talked to wanted harsher punishments for offenders.

"I don't think people think about it because I don't think the average person understands what actually happens, the feelings of the dairy owner, the shopkeepers.

"The more you talk about it, the more the community understands."

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers

The return of the Wurlitzer video

The organ has all the sound effects for a silent movie – including sirens, a car horn, train whistle and electric doorbell.

An intricate machine that wowed youth in the 1920s and 30s will again rise from the stage.

Dominion Rd demo job stalls

Albert-Eden Local Board member Graeme Easte says demolition of the Dominion Rd flyover could have a big economic benefit.

Demolition of the Dominion Rd flyover has been put on hold.

Burnt face after gas leak

A quick-thinking man threw a burning heater outside, but suffered injuries in the process.

Quick-thinking man throws burning heater outside, but suffers injuries in the process.

5 of the best winter soups

The ginger in this chicken udon soup brings it to life.

What better way to warm up your day than with a hearty soup?


Win: Tickets to second Lions test

Watch the All Blacks take on the Lions in the second test in Wellington.

The July 1 game in Wellington is sold out - but we can still get you there.

Yacht found, crew safe

Roger Foley, left, confirmed Havana Coffee's Geoff Marsland, right, was on the yacht.

Air Force spots Wellingtonians missing "miles from land in the open ocean".

Widow brings accused to tears video

In 2010, Calavrias became an Officer of the New Zealand Order of Merit in the New Year honours, for services to ...

Young man weeps at sentencing for mowing down cycling Wellington businessman while doing 100kmh.

Marriage-scam victim lost $35k

Li Jun Xue, left, committed fraud after taking $35,000 from a Wellington man and saying it was a downpayment as a ...

He fell in love with "Jessica", his Singaporean bride, but the honey-trap woman was Malaysian and already married.


Communal living in the red zone?

Ecological economist Marjan van den Belt says the red zone could house the world's biggest "eco village".

The "world's largest" eco village could be established in Christchurch's residential red zone, academic says.

SI train comeback?

Timaru Mayor Damon Odey is keen to see a Southern passenger rail service return.

Christchurch to Invercargill passenger train service is a step closer to making a comeback.

'We haven't located him yet'

Christchurch builder Michael McGrath, 49, has been missing for more than a month.

Where is Michael McGrath? A "major" investigation, including a dump search, continues.

$35k marriage scam

Li Jun Xue, left, committed fraud after taking $35,000 from a Wellington man and saying it was a downpayment as a ...

He fell in love with "Jessica", but the "Singaporean" honey-trap was married.


Teen's possum fur phone cover

Maggie Gibson with her possum fur phone cover.

Maggie Gibson has made the most Kiwi smartphone accessory from a dead possum.

Teen dies at work

A man who died after a work place accident at Torpedo7 on Wednesday has been named (file).

Teenager Jacob Woods was killed while working at a Hamilton distribution centre.

Harassed man now in peace

While Niraj Bahadur still intends to build his brick fence, he says there are no longer roaming kids in the street and ...

Niraj Bahadur is no longer being harassed after his community stepped-up.

One night out helping

Jason Huang volunteers with Hamilton's Zeal street youth workers helping keep kids out of trouble.

Volunteer Jason Huang sees the good and bad of life on Hamilton's streets.


What the Hoyle?

15062017: Word on the Street. Short Lane and Hoyle Place.

Hoyle Place wasn't always Hoyle Place.

A new way forward

New Plymouth District Council  and iwi leadership have created Te Huinga Taumatua Committee.

It's a fresh body, with fresh members looking for a fresh start.

A brief comment on Mt Messenger

Mt Messenger Tunnel on SH3

OPINION: Jim Tucker wanted to know more about the Mt Messenger bypass. The official briefing may not have helped.

By-election coming for Inglewood

Phil Rowe has resigned from the Inglewood Community Board and a by-election will be held in September.

Phil Rowe has resigned from Inglewood Community Board after a decade of service.


Tunnel a training exercise

Phil Hooper, left, Jim Richards and Bridgette Murphy have started installing a living tunnel for the Esplanade Scenic ...

Esplanade Scenic Railway passengers have a new attraction to enjoy

Food or the doctor?

A visit to your doctor will cost the same whether you have a community services card or not.

Community services cards are pointless, critics say, as health costs cripple.

Fireball 'like a bomb'

Flames leaped 10m into the air as the blaze engulfed the Ngamoko Rd house, near the town of Norsewood.

There was a huge boom as flames from a house reached a nearby shed, exploding in a fireball.

Ram raid footage released video

The offenders stole cash from the store.

The vehicle smashed into the store's roller door, and four people ran in through the gap.


Meet the Kiwi helping Oracle

Boat Build Manager Tim Smyth with the saw blade used by the giant CNC Milling machine  used on America's Cup yacht Oracle.

If Oracle turn it round to beat Team NZ, it will be thanks in part to a boat builder from Nelson.

Rate rise confirmed

Rate rises

Rates are set to rise nearly three per cent as part of the NCC's annual plan.

Poverty in the classroom

Stoke School principal Pete Mitchener.

Stoke School principal says children from low-income families face an uphill battle.

Nelson songbird flies home again

Nelson-born songwriter Sharon O'Neill is returning home for two shows at the Boathouse in September.

One of Nelson's most successful musical exports is coming home for two September shows.


Diarrhoea outbreak closes pool

Marlborough Lines Stadium 2000 will be closed for several days while it is tested for the parasite.

Seven swimmers have fallen ill after using a public pool in Blenheim.

Beached on an atoll

Roger Foley, left, confirmed Havana Coffee's Geoff Marsland, right, was on the yacht.

The crew aboard a badly damaged yacht in the Pacific Ocean have been found alive and well.

Hunting the 'Kiwi way'

The Gunshack Blenheim owner Peter Watson says hunters are being left with fewer places to shoot because of poachers.

Poachers, and even some young hunters, have "no respect for anyone or anything, not even the animals they're hunting".

Once bitten, not shy

The Employment Relations Authority has penalised KRSVP Limited $25,000 for failing to keep proper employment records.

Marlborough vineyard contractor stung for the same employment breach twice in two years.

South Canterbury

Prince rescued from steep cliff

Prince was cold, wet and hungry, but very vocal, as rescuers approached the area where he was stuck on Thursday.

Firefighters walk 22kms in cold, wet conditions to rescue dog from cliff near Fairlie.

$50k for rail case

Timaru Mayor Damon Odey is keen to see a Southern passenger rail service return.

Govt announces $50k to investigate return of Southern passenger rail service.

Drugs, guns 'don't mix'

A Pareora man has been given a warning after a cannabis bong and unsecured shotgun were found in his car as he left a ...

Police warn of dangers of mixing drugs, alcohol and guns after callout to bonfire

$500,000 aviary to protect stilts

A new breeding aviary for black stilt (kaki) will be built near Twizel.

A new $500,000 breeding aviary for the world's rarest wading bird will be built near Twizel.


Young performers face the music

Monique Clementson (Deloris), Annie Sherborne, and Rachael Scott (Sister Mary Patrick) at rehearsals for the ...

Young performers are gaining exposure and touring the country for Sister Act the musical.

Arrested after threats

08072016 Newsphoto. SIMON MAUDE / FAIRFAX NZ. Generic, stock, NZ Police, police car, The po po, police. 08-N-policeC

A 54-year-old man was arrested after threatening Work and Income staff.

Father 'evil', grief-stricken mum says

Police staff at the Riverton home where three-month-old Honour Ashworth was injured.

Grieving Southland mother says her soul was "ripped to pieces" when she found out her partner caused her infant son's death.

Green Party takes off

Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand Invercargill candidate Rochelle Surendran speaks at a Green Party Launch in Invercargill.

Green Party co-leader comments on Clutha-Southland MP resignation during Invercargill visit.

Ad Feedback