What's the difference between decriminalising and legalising cannabis?

Stuff.co.nz

The cannabis debate: It's not as simple as 'legal' or 'illegal'. So what's the difference between depenalisation, decriminalisation and legalisation?

Imagine a future in which the possession of cannabis in New Zealand is no longer a criminal offence.

If you're caught with a small quantity, instead of being arrested you get a 'cannabis warning' and, perhaps, a fine.

The drug is confiscated and destroyed and you have to appear in front of a panel whose members include a health professional, a lawyer, and a psychologist.

You're still not allowed to grow any plants or sell the drug but you don't get a criminal record, although there is a system for recording warning notices (which is accessible in some cases when applying for a job).

This is what decriminalisation looks like. It's often confused with legalisation.

Drug Foundation executive director Ross Bell said the legal concepts underpinning decriminalisation and legalisation are poorly understood.

Decriminalising cannabis has gained momentum around the world.
Supplied

Decriminalising cannabis has gained momentum around the world.

"In my mind we use legalisation as a code word for commercialisation. As soon as you remove all criminal penalties, essentially you have legalisation.

"I think there's a whole lot of confusion."

The New Zealand Drug Foundation supports a Portugal-style system on decriminalised recreational drug use, so let's take that as an example.

Should New Zealand legalise cannabis?

Share your stories, photos and videos.

It's widely believed recreational drugs are legal in Portugal. They're not.

Ad Feedback

In 2001, Portugal was the first country to decriminalise all recreational use of drugs including heroin, cocaine, ecstasy, and LSD - but you still can't grow or sell your own.

The focus has switched from criminal justice and punitive remedies to one in which health, social costs, and treatment were at the forefront.

But the Portuguese system is still criticised by some of its interventions, Bell said.

"At a [Portugal-style] panel if you are somebody with a drug dependency you get referred to treatment but there are still penalties. It becomes a civil penalty that can include a fine, a speeding ticket-type infringement offence.

"A lot of people criticised it as too paternalistic but it does open up that referral. The other thing Portugal did was remove the ability to be sent to prison for personal use."

Drug Foundation executive director Ross Bell also supports the Portuguese system of decriminalisation.
CAMERON BURNELL/FAIRFAX NZ

Drug Foundation executive director Ross Bell also supports the Portuguese system of decriminalisation.

So if that's decriminalisation - what about legalisation?

One of the main differences between the two ideas is the ability to commercially produce and sell cannabis under legalisation.

Marijuana is legal in Uruguay, Spain, and in Colorado and Washington states in America, with different restrictions on growing, consuming and selling.

In Uruguay, cultivation is managed by the government - at least in theory. Adults can access cannabis by joining a cannabis co-op, growing up to six plants at home, and buying it from licensed pharmacies. The psychoactive ingredient tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) of the commercially available product is capped at 15 per cent and, if growing at home or in a club, an individual is limited to 480g per person per year.

Spain never criminalised possession of drugs for personal use and what emerged was the toleration of personal possession and supply for non-commercial use. The selling part is a grey area, but people get around that by forming private members' clubs.

In Washington DC, it's illegal to sell recreationally, but it's fine to possess, grow in small amounts, and gift the drug.

Displays at Shango Cannabis shop in Portland, Oregon, in 2015.
STEVE DIPAOLA/REUTERS

Displays at Shango Cannabis shop in Portland, Oregon, in 2015.

So, broadly then, legalisation translates as using, producing, growing, transporting, or supplying a substance as a commodity like any other, with restrictions attached.

It doesn't mean lawless, or a free-for-all.

In this sense, cannabis is controlled and consumed in a similar manner to alcohol, or regulated harmful substances, such as tobacco. Or regulated industries, such as gambling.

In Uruguay, adults can grow up to six cannabis plants at home.
REUTERS

In Uruguay, adults can grow up to six cannabis plants at home.

This is a way off for New Zealand, if it ever happens, Bell said.

"I think there are probably merits to that but I wouldn't want to take that approach. We'd need a stepped approach, get the public comfortable because you could change your drug laws and do it really badly.

"Essentially what Peter Dunne has proposed, that's our approach as well. Decriminalise with health referrals, using the Psychoactive Substances Act to regulate the sale."

Decriminalisation involves removing the criminal penalties for possession, for example, personal use, with a sliding scale in terms of personal limits, potential civil penalties, and health referrals.

Cannabis is already effectively decriminalised in New Zealand to a certain extent under the diversion system - in small amounts and in cases where it's a first offence.

However, young people are routinely convicted for cannabis possession, mostly young men and, within that demographic, mostly young Maori men, Bell said.

About 2000 young people aged 17-25 are convicted for drug possession each year. The average sentence is 65 days at a cost of $16,250 per person, which amounts to $29 million a year.

Young people are being imprisoned for repeat possession offences, leaving them with criminal convictions that limit travel and future opportunities, Bell said.

Under a decriminalised system, recreational drugs users would not face the same ramifications in other areas of their lives.

Critics of decriminalisation point to a potential range of problems: increased availability leading to more use; difficulties in comparing different countries' policies; the fact decriminalisation does not fix the social, health and justice questions around drug use.

Last year, UK drug policy charity Release conducted a global roundup of drug policies.

What emerged is this: the harms of criminalisation "far outweigh" the harms of decriminalisation.

In other words, a punitive approach does very little to reduce rates of drug use, which are on an upward trend and have been for years.

"[One] conclusion that can be drawn is the doomsday predictions are simply wrong, and removing criminal sanctions for possession and use of drugs does not lead to skyrocketing prevalence rates."

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Benji's a broadcaster

Benji Marshall - unwanted by the Kiwis for the Rugby League World Cup - will become a television commentator.

The Kiwis don't want Benji Marshall - but Channel Seven does.

First fuel down the line

The fuel pipeline from the Marsden Point Refinery to south Auckland, which crippled New Zealand air travel after ...

Freshly-repaired pipe delivers seven million litres of jet fuel to Auckland.

Cycleway must be included: court

Moir Hill will be the centre of a proposed development removing pine forest and replanting with natives

The prospect of being able to cycle through regenerating bush on a trail from Warkworth to Puhoi has come a step closer.

National wins Auckland

Nikki Kaye was ready for a "tough fight" for Auckland central electorate and she got one from Labour rookie Helen White.

A nasty scare in Central Auckland could have cost National the country's biggest city, but they still landed on top.

Wellington

Defiant Wellington turns redder

24092017 Photo: ROSS GIBLIN\STUFF   
Greg O'Connor, left and Paul Eagle have both been elected to Parliament under the ...

Capital's new MPs celebrate, as the party vote swings Labour's way too.

Back to the polls, again

Here we go again ... Wellington hasn't seen the last of election billboards with a by-election scheduled for the end of ...

Wins for Paul Eagle and Lawrence Yule trigger by-elections in capital and Hastings.

King backs the kingmaker

Annette King delivers her valedictory speech to Parliament, applauded by Jacinda Ardern. She says Peters is good to work ...

Kingmaker Winston Peters has an unlikely cheerleader: Annette King.

Housing top of Yule's agenda

National's Lawrence Yule is the new MP for Tukituki.

More homes need to be built, says new Tukituki MP. "It's as simple as that."

Canterbury

All Blacks' guard's $225k tax bill

Security consultant Jayson Ryan has admitted charges of aiding and abetting his three companies to apply tax deductions ...

Jayson Ryan's sold his home to pay back the debt. He also has to serve a sentence of home detention.

Police hunt gunman 

Police guard Andrew Cameron's house near Hanmer Springs on Tuesday morning.

Police officers had to travel armed and in pairs after a Canterbury kidnapping.

Live: The election aftermath

Talks could begin shortly with NZ First over a coalition, National's Bill English says.

There's no clear result. Winston Peters faces a choice: Join National or Labour-Green.

Election pleases Pike River families 

Sonya Rockhouse, whose son Benjamin was killed in the Pike River mine, speaking in September.

Familes hope manned re-entry into the West Coast mine will happen next year after election favours parties supporting their cause.

Waikato

Mahuta romps home

Nanaia Mahuta took at swipe at the Maori Party after she crushed her opponent in the Hauraki-Waikato electorate.

Māori Party no competition for Labour's Nanaia Mahuta in the Hauraki-Waikato electorate.

Hamilton backs blue video

Hamilton East National MP David Bennett receives congratulations from Hamilton East Labour candidate Jamie Strange after ...

It's a clean sweep for National in Hamilton, with David Bennett and Tim Macindoe fending off two Labour rookies.

A timely drop in Waikato's 'ocean'

Eliza Webster, who commutes twice weekly to Auckland for university, is counting on a commuter rail between Auckland, ...

National's spending promises are timely for the growing Waikato and Bay of Plenty.

First-time MP romps in

Tim van de Molen says he is more than up to the challenges ahead of him.

National Waikato candidate Tim van de Molen won the Waikato seat with ease.

Taranaki

Taranaki continue to move forward and up

Kane Thompson made his first start for Taranaki against Hawke's Bay.

Coach delighted to end four decades of misery.

Māori voice 'lost from Parliament'

Maori Party candidate Howie Tamati,with supporter Jim Niwa on election night at  Mururaupatu Marae , Bell Block

Māori Party candidate "deeply disappointed" there is no independent Māori voice in the new Parliament.

Coalition mix 'the sooner, the better'

New Plymouth MP Jonathan Young, with wife Maura, at election night celebrations at The Plymouth Hotel.

The sooner the make up of the coalition is decided, the better, MP says.

SAR off to get walkers

Four young people who went for a walk on Mt Taranaki on Sunday got into difficulty and called for help.

Four people are being helped off Mt Taranaki.

Manawatu

Winners are grinners video

Ian McKelvie is the National candidate for the Rangītikei electorate.

National candidate Ian McKelvie has won Rangitīkei comfortably.

An MP in Government

Palmerston North MP Iain Lees-Galloway dances with his wife Clare Lees-Galloway as they celebrate him winning a fourth ...

Palmerston North will have an MP influencing Government, no matter how the cards fall.

Ōtaki, Whanganui staying blue

National MP Nathan Guy has kept his Ōtaki seat, easily.

Nathan Guy and Harate Hipango set to retain electorates for National.

Tamati tackled short of line

Te Tai Hauauru Maori Party candidate Howie Tamati with supporter Jack Niwa

Touted as a possible kingmaker before the election, Howie Tamati trails in his electorate.

Nelson

Smith wins Nelson seat video

23092017 NEWS PHOTO BRADEN FASTIER / NELSON MAIL
Rachel Boyack speaks to her supporters on election night at the Labour ...

Nelson seat stays true blue but the party vote swings to the red corner.

O'Connor victorious

Damien O'Connor says he's very pleased to be returned as the West Coast-Tasman MP.

Labour's Damien O'Connor increases his margin in West Coast-Tasman.

Green's profile lifted

Matt Lawrey is flanked by family and supporters at his election party at Lambretta's in Nelson.

Matt Lawrey drew nearly triple the votes of his predecessor for the electorate tick.

Care switch-up 'upsetting'

Pamela Duffy has built up a close relationship with her carers, who will no longer be visiting her at home after the ...

A sudden change in home carers has left an elderly woman confused and upset.

Marlborough

Freight hub to keep trucking

The container transfer site was upgraded to a 24/7 freight hub in a matter of days after the earthquake.

After the earthquake, they started working 24/7 loading and unloading more than 100 trucks a day.

Smith cleans up

National's Stuart Smith has been re-elected in Kaikōura.

Stuart Smith wins easily in Kaikōura

Grants help unlock walkways

NZ Walking Access Commission chief executive Eric Pyle walks Daltons Track between Daltons Bridge and Pelorus Bridge. ...

Kiwi's love of the outdoors is being supported by cash as more funding for walkway access is up for grabs.

Next 'cultural treasure'

Weaver and artist Peg Moorhouse says it is important to recognise the great talent in Marlborough.

"Extraordinary", "inspiring" and "significant" are just some of the criteria for the Living Cultural Treasure Award.

South Canterbury

Mojo Mathers: 'I made a difference' video

Green Party candidate Mojo Mathers, who has lost her seat in Parliament, was enjoying the serenity of the Waihi river in ...

Jo Luxton "rapt" after party confirmed seat, but "devastated" Mojo Mathers not returning.

Falloon takes seat video

Green Party candidate Mojo Mathers watches the first results come in with members of her campaign team, from left, Ray ...

National's Andrew Falloon has won the Rangitata seat, but National's majority is down.

Leatigaga hat-trick sinks N Otago

South Canterbury captain Kieran Coll with the Hanan Shield after defeating North Otago in the Heartland Championship.

South Canterbury have the edge on neighbours North Otago to retain Hanan Shield.

Dean comfortably wins Waitaki

National Waitaki MP Jacqui Dean addresses her supporters at an election night function at the Oamaru Opera House after ...

Jacqui Dean wins a fifth term in Parliament

Otago

Two MPs for Clutha-Southland

Clutha-Southland New Zealand First candidate Mark Patterson watches his leader Winston Peters, give his coalition speech ...

Clutha-Southland has a new New Zealand First MP, Lawrence farmer Mark Patterson.

Revealing ancient and heavenly stories at Cardrona

Cardrona astronomy guide Alex Thom peers through Cardrona's new telescope.

Cardrona Alpine Resort is reaching for the skies with its new visitor attraction.

Flames beat back rescuers

The fire was in one unit in a block of four.

Neighbours reportedly tried to rescue the occupant of a Dunedin flat where a person died overnight.

Woman rescued, police thank app

A Christchurch woman was found on Ben Lomond, near Queenstown, about 12am on Friday.

A Christchurch woman was rescued from a Queenstown mountain after her husband tracked her location through a phone app.

Southland

Live: The day after the election

Talks could begin shortly with NZ First over a coalition, National's Bill English says.

National's keen for a quick deal with Winston - and if they get it, they could thank Auckland voters.

South's election night

It was all smiles for Invercargill MP Sarah Dowie, pictured here with her husband Mark Billcliff.

Invercargill will have two MPs in Parliament, Labour's Liz Craig and National's Sarah Dowie.

Craig will become Labour list MP

Invercargill Labour Candidate Dr Liz Craig is set to become a list MP after the 2017 general election.

Invercargill Labour candidate Dr Liz Craig lost the battle for the Invercargill electorate seat but will still become an MP.

Ria Bond to leave parliament

NZ First Invercargill candidate Ria Bond with her father Ariki Hoterene-Shortland at the Kelvin Hotel in Invercargill.

There were tears of disappointment for former MP Ria Bond.

Ad Feedback