PrimeProperty ordered to pay more than $7500 for renting out 61 Molesworth St illegally

The interior of one of the illegal tenancies in 61 Molesworth St, which was demolished after the November earthquake in ...

The interior of one of the illegal tenancies in 61 Molesworth St, which was demolished after the November earthquake in Kaikoura.

A renters' lobby group has labelled a $600 fine for letting a family live in a now-demolished Wellington office block a "ludicrous and inadequate" slap on the wrist for its owner. 

PrimeProperty Group owns the block at 61 Molesworth St, and has been ordered to pay damages of just $600 after illegally housing tenants in the building.

The Tenancy Tribunal has ordered the group to pay back $6900 in rent to the tenants, and their $20 filing fee.

Olive and Ernest Mape were living in the building illegally, and will now have their rent paid back to them.

Olive and Ernest Mape were living in the building illegally, and will now have their rent paid back to them.

But Kayla Healey, of Wellington Renters United, said the tribunal had not gone far enough in punishing the company and its chief executive, Eyal Aharoni. 

Earthquake-displaced family could lose everything when Wellington office building is torn down
Perfect storm as Wellington's rental squeeze spreads to suburbs
Greed, desperation, and squalor - life in illegal boarding houses
Building on Wellington's Molesworth St being torn down

The case was "an unfortunate illustration" of how desperate the situation for renters was at the moment, especially in Wellington. 

Kayla Healey, of Wellington Renters United, said the $600 fine had been irrefutably inadequate for putting a family's ...

Kayla Healey, of Wellington Renters United, said the $600 fine had been irrefutably inadequate for putting a family's life at risk.

"If it weren't for the utter lack of affordable housing in the city, this situation is unlikely to have occurred in the first place," she said.

"It's only out of desperation a family would choose to live in a place which put their lives at risk."

The $600 fine for damages for putting people's lives at risk was "irrefutably an inadequate penalty handed down by the tribunal".

PrimeProperty chief executive Eyal Aharoni agreed with the tribunal that the tenancy should not have been allowed to go ...

PrimeProperty chief executive Eyal Aharoni agreed with the tribunal that the tenancy should not have been allowed to go ahead.

"I can't think of any other justice department in which it would be acceptable to hand out a $600 fine for intentionally putting lives in danger and generating a profit from it." 

Ad Feedback

Healey said the case highlighted the desperate need for licensing and regulation of landlords and property management companies. 

After November's Kaikoura earthquake, the building was evacuated and the Mape family was found to have been living there.

Olive and Ernest Mape​ had been living in the nine-storey building with their two teenage children since June.

November's 7.8 magnitude earthquake did so much structural damage to the building that a decision was made to bring it down.

The Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) tenancy compliance and investigations team sought an order on behalf of the tenant saying the tenancy was illegal.

MBIE​ said the building could not lawfully be used for residential purposes.

In a statement, an MBIE manager, Steve Watson, said the case was "a prime example of taking advantage of someone who is in a vulnerable position".

He said the exemplary damages costs of $600 reflected the extent of the health and safety risks tenants faced, and the fact the landlord should have known better. 

"This decision sends a strong message to landlords that the penalties are high if you are caught renting commercial property to tenants."

Aharoni said on Wednesday evening that he was disappointed by Watson's comments, as he was trying to help the Mapes by giving them cheap rent, and there was no financial gain for PrimeProperty.

"I know we were doing them a favour."

The tribunal was not persuaded the tenancy was entered into on compassionate grounds as the landlord had a legal obligation to the Mapes after another PrimeProperty building offered to the family under a fixed term lease was leaking. 

Aharoni agreed with the tribunal that the 61 Molesworth St tenancy should not have been allowed to happen.

"We regret it and I can assure you that this kind of tenancy will not be repeated," he said. 
The tenancy was intended to be short term to allow the family to find alternative accommodation and, when they refused to leave in October before the earthquake, PrimeProperty had no option but to serve the Mapes with a notice to leave by January, Aharoni said.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers

Anti-abortion club faces ban video

University of Auckland's pro-abortion club are facing disaffiliation from the students association in a referendum being ...

Students to vote to keep or disaffiliate pro-life group from student union.

Road closed, power pole snapped

The power pole was snapped in the crash.

Busy Auckland intersection closed for eight hours after car hits power pole.

Labour's 'golden triangle' rail plan

Labour leader Jacinda Ardern says her party will create a passenger rail service linking Auckland, Hamilton, and ...

Jacinda Ardern reveals $20m plan for commuter rail between Auckland, Hamilton, and Tauranga.

Family First loses charity status

Bob McCoskrie from Family First said the group would fight the decision in the High Court.

Controversial group vows to fight decision to strip it of its status for not exclusively advancing charitable purposes.


They're taking the P

Kapiti Mayor K Gurunathan says there are better ways of raising awareness about methamphetamine abuse than altering ...

Dozens of Kapiti road signs have lost the letter P - and some people are not amused.

Grand theft avo

A spate of avocado thefts down the East Coast have resulted in the stolen fruit appearing on Facebook.

Police warn avocados are being pinched from orchards and sold on Facebook.

Hutt's hotel coming soon

A 2014 architect's impression of a proposed nine-storey building on the BNZ site now owned by the Hutt City Council. ...

Developer says Hutt hotel site will see action by mid October.

Lights out at Staglands

Staglands, home to this kunekune pig, will have its power cut off for a day on August 24, meaning the park will have to ...

Lines maintenance will see the wildlife reserve close for a day this week.


Forestry fail: Bach destroyed

The felled tree trunk pierces into the living room.

Miracle no-one home as felled tree writes off much-loved family Marlborough Sounds family bach.

ECan 'heavy-handed'

Most of the 176 properties in the subdivision have been told their land may be contaminated.

Subdivision residents told their land might be contaminated, despite tests indicating it's clear.

Driver calls for taxi stand access

18082017 Photo. Stacy Squires/Stuff.
Christchurch Uber Driver Matt Foot,  says he should be allowed to use the Baretta / ...

Uber driver says it's dangerous to pick up passengers - who are often young and have been drinking - from other parts of the street.

Motorcyclist misjudged corner

Motorcyclist Marian Grafhorst, 63, died when she collided with a car on the West Coast in 2015.

Motorcyclist Maria Grafhorst died in head-on collision after taking a corner badly.


Rail promise for Hamilton

Labour leader Jacinda Ardern announces her plan to create a commuter railway connection between Auckland, Hamilton and ...

Billions of dollars' worth of roads will not help ease congestion - but rail will, Labour says. 

Paedo priest jailed

Mark Mannix Brown, 74, was jailed when he appeared in the Hamilton District Court on Monday, on four charges of indecent ...

Devastating effect of former Catholic priest's abuse heard as he's again jailed for molesting boys.

Tuheitia reaffirms Māori Party

Waikato Tainui Kīngi Tuheitia Pootatau Te Wherowhero Vll at the 11th annual Koroneihana, celebrating his ascension to ...

Māori King Tuheitia also dismissed Māori TV in an address at Tūrangawaewae​ Marae.

BBQ blast burns men

Two people were left with burns when a barbecue exploded at a Coromandel man's birthday party.

Two men in hospital with burns after spit-roast barbecue caught fire at a birthday party.


Mourie humbled by honour  video

Graham Mourie told the 1200 students that life was going to change a lot in the next few years.

One All Black great Graham Mourie remembers Sir Colin Meads as a character, but also a part of the New Zealand psyche.

NZ First choose Chong

He's been hinting at it for weeks. Now New Plymouth district councillor Murray Chong is officially standing for NZ First ...

Finally it's official. Murray Chong is standing for NZ First in New Plymouth.

Vying for votes

Harete Hipango is the National Party candidate  for Whanganui.

A gathering of South Taranaki voters take their first look at their electorate candidate lineup.

Fire investigation

New Plymouth bar Our Place has been shut following a fire at cafe Istanbul in July.

Inquiries into what ignited a New Plymouth restaurant fire are ongoing, police say.


$10.5b roading plan

Manawatu Gorge will be a roading focus for the National Government.

Major upgrade to stricken Manawatu Gorge part of ambitious vision to improve New Zealand's roads.

Parking powers sought

Chief executive Ross McNeil says the council won't employ parking wardens.

The Rangitikei District Council is seeking the power to fine motorists.

Before and after 

Villagers have described the events that unfolded when NZ SAS troopers visited in 2004.

Calls for apology and punishment over firefight at centre of one of NZ's proudest military episodes.

Hidden history of war

Two New Zealanders and four Afghans died in the 2012 Battle of Baghak.

Documentary reveals secret details about operations involving our soldiers.


Forestry fail: Bach destroyed

The felled tree trunk pierces into the living room.

Miracle no-one home as felled tree writes off Nelson family's much-loved bach.

Fiery end to test drive

Emergency services respond to a vehicle fire on Princes Drive in Britannia Heights, Nelson.

A car for sale in Nelson probably won't be bought after it burst into flames during a test drive.

Transport transformed

Press Drive August 9 Briefs

Driverless cars could radically change Nelson in the not-so-distant-future, says IT expert.

Tailwind for Tineli

Ali Kimber,left, Sandy Vincent, Tim Vincent and Jono Kalma are part of the Tineli team that have just received a $35,000 ...

Nelson-based firm Tineli is looking to break away from the peloton thanks to a $35,000 business award.


Log spears family bach

The felled tree trunk pierces into the living room.

Family demands answers after felled tree destroys Marlborough Sounds bach.

Back in the race

Marlborough Racing Club president Eric Bowers has previously opposed the sale of Waterlea Racecourse land. (File photo)

Hold your horses! All bets back on after ministry U-turn on campus site.

Unfair to 'single out' jet skis

Seamonkeez Jetski Hire owner Mike Stewart supports registration but says it is unfair to single out jet skis.

It's not just Ferraris and Lamborghinis that have to be registered on the road, so why single out jet skis on the water?

Blackwell does it again

Stephen Blackwell steams towards victory in the 2017 Woodbourne Half Marathon.

Methven athlete Stephen Blackwell claimed back-to-back Woodbourne half marathon titles on Sunday.

South Canterbury

Mobility tricycle for school

Celebrating the gift of a mobility tricycle to Highfield School pupils on Monday are, clockwise from left, Henry ...

Geraldine Lions Club gifts mobility tricycle to pupils of Highfield School.

Twizel man missing

Police are looking for Twizel man David Fountain, who was last seen in the early hours of Sunday morning.

Police looking for Twizel man last seen out with friends in the early hours of Sunday.

Food processing course launched

The new food processing course would begin at Ara Institute of Canterbury next year.

New qualification to prepare students for life in the food processing sector launched.

Daffodils blooming gorgeous

South Canterbury Vintage Car Club members Grant Mitchell and Marion Foster help deliver some of the more than 32, 0000 ...

More than 32,000 daffodils have been delivered in style around the Timaru District.


Southland powerlifter breaks NZ record

Southland's Andy Meek won the masters two category 66kg class at the NZ Powerlifting Championships in Dunedin.

Southland powerlifter Andy Meek broke a national record at the 2017 National Classic Powerlifting Championships recently.

More pooches, less poo in QT

There's been 183 dogs registered in Queenstown district this financial year, with less fouling complaints and no serious ...

Queenstown Lakes district now has 4485 dogs, but less poo complaints and attacks.

Qtown goes nuts on nuts video

Frank Goes Nuts worker Dan Lythgoe, 22, enjoys selling caramelized nuts on Queenstown streets.

Queenstown is going nuts about new caramelised nuts business in town.

Dunedin's 'Minority Report'

Police arrested a burglar before the crime was reported in Dunedin, much like the 2002 Hollywood movie 'Minority ...

Police have solved a crime before it was even reported. Welcome to Dunedin's Minority Report.


Are you in?

Celebrate being a Southlander by taking part in Purple Work Shirt Day on Thursday, August 24.

The Southland Times and Rugby Southland are coming together this week to hold a purple work shirt day.  

South's top cop defends officers

Southern district commander Superintendent Paul Basham says "some things can go wrong sometimes".

Alleged murder, stalking and sexting cases involving police may harm reputation of hard-working officers, top cop says.

Police dog back at work

The scene on Dee St, Invercargill, where a car hit a police officer and dog.

A police dog pulled from under a car after a police pursuit came to an end is back at work.

A win that got away

Southland Stags midfielder Matthew Johnson scores a try in his debut game against Hawke's Bay in Napier on Saturday.

"It was just a couple of errors in the second half and Hawke's Bay punished us."

Ad Feedback