Blind 5-year-old faces boot from NZ after High Court dismisses deportation appeal

Charmaine and Jonathan Davies with their two children, Jonathan and Caitlyn, right.

Charmaine and Jonathan Davies with their two children, Jonathan and Caitlyn, right.

The family of a blind South African child living in South Canterbury are "absolutely devastated" by a court's refusal to allow her to stay in New Zealand on humanitarian grounds.

The Davies family are now weighing up their options after their failed High Court bid to stop her being deported.

They say the level of care Caitlyn, 5, needs is not available in South Africa, and it would be "extremely unsafe" for her to return.

Caitlyn is blind, suffers from global development delay, and has chronic medical conditions the Immigration Protection Tribunal considered would impose significant costs on New Zealand's health and education systems.

* Terminally ill woman allowed to stay in New Zealand
* 'Life-affirming' Fijian woman loses cancer fight
* Reasons for majority of exceptional citizenship grants

Caitlyn Davies and her father, Jonathan, arrived in New Zealand on a work visa in 2015.

A few months later Caitlyn's mother Charmaine, and then 1-year-old brother, Jonathan, arrived in New Zealand on work and visitor visas. They were granted further visas in 2016.

Caitlyn's interim visa expired in July last year, meaning she was unlawfully in New Zealand.

Since then the family has fought for her to stay in the country.

Her father works on a farm near Geraldine.

Ad Feedback

The tribunal's decision meant Caitlyn would have to be deported back to South Africa. The Davies' lawyer, Andrew Riches, appealed the decision to the High Court.

After a hearing May 19, Christchurch High Court Judge Gerald Nation found in favour of the tribunal's decision that it would not be "unjust or unduly harsh" to deport her.

Riches said the family was struggling to take the decision in.

"She's (Charmaine) absolutely devastated. She really doesn't know what the family is going to do from here, all she knows is returning to South Africa is simply not an option because she won't be safe there."

In October last year the tribunal refused an appeal against Caitlyn's deportation, but gave the family three months to better plan for, and finance, returning to South Africa.

Immigration New Zealand declined to issue Caitlyn the same visas granted to the rest of her family because she was "not considered to be of an acceptable standard of health," Nation's judgment said.

Riches said under the visitor visa process, Caitlyn could not get a medical waiver as she was too young and dependent on her parents.

The tribunal recognised Caitlyn had a better chance at life here than in South Africa, where there were limited educational opportunities for disabled children and a high rate of violent crime in schools.

It considered the high level of support she received at kindergarten "would have to continue indefinitely" if she started primary school here in May.

Riches said the tribunal accepted there were "exceptional humanitarian circumstances" for her to remain, but simultaneously ruled it would not be "unduly harsh to remove her".

The tribunal did not accept the family's argument that returning to South Africa would cause them financial hardship and dismissed their appeal to "maintain the integrity of the New Zealand immigration system".

In appealing the case to the High Court Riches argued the tribunal made an "error".

"They should have have put the prime attention on her and what she is going to suffer, then weigh that up against public interest".

"In assessing whether it's unjust to deport her, the focus needs to be on her personal circumstances ... they placed too much weight on the wider public.

"It's a fairly technical argument, but in the midst of it you have got this poor young girl and her whole future is hanging in the balance."

In the appeal Riches included an example of what happened at a South African school for blind children.

He said there was a fire at the school, which had "no safety protocols" in place and children died in the fire.

"It's the standard of care she needs that is simply not there. It would be extremely unsafe for her to go back there", Riches said.

Both he and the family were "assessing all the options, but its not an option for her to go back", he said.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers

Far North school goes from ghetto to $14m facility

Northland College principal Jim Luders is ecstatic about the new buildings for the school.

The $14 million rebuild of Northland College has been completed and will be officially opened on July 7.

Best places to bag a beanie

A good beanie can do many things from completing an outfit to covering a bad hair day.

Beanies: de rigueur for capping off an outfit in the depths of a Kiwi winter.

Best winter day trips

Kill time in the lazy river at Waiwera Hot Pools.

Use the cooler weather as an excuse to see a different side of the Super City.

One killed, one critically injured

Police have closed Linwood Rd in Karaka after a fatal crash on Wednesday morning.

One person dead and another badly hurt in early morning Auckland smash.


The red fans are here

Johnsonville Rugby Football Club's Mike Segetin (centre) shows British and Irish Lions' supporters the meaning of Kiwi ...

Johnsonville is being invaded by red shirts, much to the delight of locals.

Great roaring ripoff

Lions fan Noel Geraghty said his trip around New Zealand had been going well until he came to Wellington.

Wellington costs Lions fans $130 a night to park their campervans in the city.

Fans double-booked at stadium

Several fans caught up in a ticket gaffe missed seeing Rory Best lead the British and Irish Lions out at Westpac Stadium ...

Ticketek apologises, and insists there won't be a hitch for All Blacks game.

Marae founder dies after illness

Bruce Stewart in 2002.

Moves afoot to have, Bruce Stewart, founder of Island Bay's marae, buried on site.


A big, purple, bulbous theatre 

The theatre would include two performance spaces, offices and a cafe.

An $18m spaceship-shaped theatre has been proposed for the city's performing arts precinct.

New hotel open in days

The Crowne Plaza Hotel opens on the Colombo-Armagh streets corner on July 1.

The new 204-room Crowne Plaza Hotel opens in the former Forsyth Barr on Saturday after two-year project.

Mini-mart in Weet(a)bix battle video

Sanitarium trademarked the Weet-Bix name in 1928.

British grocer wanting to sell Weetabix in stoush with food giant Sanitarium after order seized.

'Lots of yelling and screaming' video

State Highway 8 is closed until further notice.

One dead, four seriously injured after tour bus crashes with 4WD in Central Otago. 


River Plan gets going

The Hamilton River Plan is expected to take about 30 years to roll out.

Three River Plan projects have been given the go ahead for Hamilton.

Man chases child in fog

Cambridge East School principal Hamish Fenemor said the man took advantage of the thick fog in the area to try and chase ...

Driver follows pupil to school before jumping out and chasing child through thick fog just a block from school.

Calves found suckling on killed cow

"They just couldn't understand why she wasn't standing up," farmer Noel Hair said (file photo).

Farmer found calves hungry for milk and a bullet in the eye of their mother.

New clues in missing man case

Frederick Hayward went missing on the way from Hamilton to Raglan in September 2013.

Police now have descriptions of two vehicles sought in relation to missing person cold case.


Soup kicks off Puanga festival

The harakeke planting is a symbol of new life. Hana Corbett, Hunter Keat, 2, Arden Duffell, 3, Logan Tubb, 4.

Matariki or Puanga? The message is still the same.

Tramper found dead

Officials were waiting for daylight to break on Mt Taranaki before airlifting the man's body off.

Police searching for a tramper walking to the summit of Mt Taranaki have found a body.

'Oh, I wish I knew how to use a computer'


Max Barnard partakes in free computer training courses for the community at the ...

Can you remember when you learned when to use a mouse?

Rust restrictions 

Myrtle rust is a fungal disease that is found on plants such as pohutukawa and manuka.

Massive restrictions now in place for moving myrtle species plants in and out of North Taranaki.


Home is where the words are

Thom Conroy is the editor of Home: New Writing.

What home means to some of New Zealand's best writers is housed in a new book.

700 new jobs needed

Bidfoods assistant general manager Adam Rapson shows work experience pupils Reece Hodgson, right, and Josh Alexander the ...

Quick action is needed to make sure Manawatu is ready for logistics boom, CEDA says.

Future of universities discussed

Panelists discussing the future of tertiary education, from left, Green MP Gareth Hughes, Professor Chris Gallavin, ...

Increased competition from private education providers is a key issue for universities.

Missing the point

The One Plan is supposed to preserve the Manawatu River for future generations.

OPINION: Horizons was asleep at the wheel and ignoring its One Plan obligations.


SH6 reopens after double crash

Emergency services attend the scene of a crash involving a truck and a 4WD near the Whangamoa Saddle on Wednesday night

A  truck fire which led to a separate crash near Havelock left a driver with critical injuries.

Investors' $18m wait

Forestlands' website tells visitors: "Under section 48 of the Financial Markets Conduct Act we are not currently ...

People who invested in a group of forestry investment companies are still waiting.

Who do we think we are?

Eighty riders rode in the Nelson Mountain Bike Club's Shred Like a Girl event at Codgers.

Results of a project to create a regional identity for Nelson-Tasman revealed.

Nelson all set for Super Club

The Trinidad and Tobago netball players after a training session at Saxton Stadium.

The first team has arrived for the Super Club netball tournament which starts on Sunday.


Lawyers keep turning him down

Lawyers in Blenheim say they can't represent Graham Donald Church because a witness works at the courthouse. (File photo)

Man on assault charge can't get a lawyer because they all know a witness - a security guard at the courthouse.

SH6 reopens after double crash

Emergency services had to cut a driver from his car after and attempt to overtake vehicles banked up from the previous ...

A serious truck fire which led to a separate crash near Nelson left a driver with critical injuries.

Off-road pastor gets round disaster

Taking deliveries to those still isolated by the earthquake are pastor Tom Hatch, left, and Matthew Tempest from Elim Church.

They're a church group devoted to their 4WDs, but this weekend they have good reason to tackle some rough terrain.

Flexible fitness

Gym owner and personal trainer Leeland Roche wants anyone visiting his Renwick based gym to enjoy it.

Leeland Roche combines his love of fitness with a dream to help others achieve their goals.

South Canterbury

Dropping lake levels lift prices video

An aerial view showing Tekapo B power Station at Lake Pukaki. The lake level is currently at 524 metres above sea level, ...

'Spot' power prices could continue to rise as hydro lakes drop across the South Island.

Pursuit ends at railway

Police abandoned a pursuit after the vehicle entered the railway tracks at the junction of Seadown and Meadows Rd, near ...

Police abandon pursuit after driver flees onto railway near Timaru.

Vets support proposals

Dr Dries Meyer at Vetlife Timaru with a stray cat, found injured.

Proposed changes to cat ownership bylaws supported by Timaru vets.

Three guns, drugs seized from car

Two firearms were found in the boot and one in the interior of the vehicle.

Three loaded firearms and class 'A' drugs found in car in Timaru after traffic complaint.


Steel dominate Premiership final

Ginna Crampton, Wendy Frew (centre) and Shannon Francois celebrate Premiership success.

 The Southern Steel complete the perfect season with a big win over the Central Pulse.

Pet goat killed

22022017 Photo: ROSS GIBLIN\Fairfax
Generic pic: emergency services, police, police car, ambulance, Wellington Free ...

Police are investigating reports of illegal hunting after a pet goat was killed.

Milford tourist boom's problems

The stunning Mitre Peak rising 1.6km vertically out of Milford Sound.

Visitor numbers to Milford Sound are expected to reach 875,000 in 2017 and exceed one million by 2019.

Southland Arts Festival runs at loss

Southland Festival of the Arts organiser Angela Newell ahead of the 2017 festival held in April and May.

The month-long Southland Arts Festival ran at an $8000 loss this year and changes may be afoot.

Ad Feedback