'Concerns remain' after deadline passes for David Marshall to improve skinny horses' condition

Holly Farm owner David Marshall is under investigation for his treatment of Arabian horses on his Canterbury stud farm.

Holly Farm owner David Marshall is under investigation for his treatment of Arabian horses on his Canterbury stud farm.

A Canterbury horse breeder under investigation after claims he was keeping skinny, wounded and dead animals has made "some improvement", but concerns remain.

The Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) gave Holly Farm owner David Marshall until the end of May to improve the condition of some of his 70-plus Arabian horses after it received a complaint about skinny horses in January.

MPI's clout in dealing with animal-welfare complaints has since been questioned as it received 12 complaints about Marshall's horses between 2010 and 2017.

The horse's rib cage is visible in this photo taken in January.

The horse's rib cage is visible in this photo taken in January.

Some claim Marshall mistreated horses at his Leeston property for years and authorities took too long to act.

READ MORE: Canterbury's Holly Farm owner David Marshall under investigation over skinny horses

An MPI spokeswoman said the ministry was now "carefully considering" its next steps.

MPI said it found the condition of some horses, like this one photographed in January, needed improving.

MPI said it found the condition of some horses, like this one photographed in January, needed improving.

"We have noted some improvement in the condition of the majority of the horses at Holly Farm, however there remain some concerns regarding the management of the stock."

The latest investigation was sparked after "multiple" complaints, many of which related to a circulating photograph of at least two dead horses in a water-filled offal pit.

Marshall said he had the wellbeing of his horses under control and that complaints about their condition were "unfounded".

Horse neglect photo taken by a complainant in January and sent to MPI.

Horse neglect photo taken by a complainant in January and sent to MPI.

"Their care and daily needs were never lacking."

Ad Feedback

It was a "perception" his horses were "too light", he said.

"At the end of the day I do not have horses die from neglect or malnutrition or lack of provisions."

He claimed he had not been forced to put any animals down, as some complainants had said, but he had euthanised two old, retired mares: "They were just old."

"There is an encouragement to lessen numbers and to improve condition and that's been done via sales and normal procedures that I've undertaken myself."

He had sold at least 10 horses and had about 60 left, he said.

"There's no doubt about it, with autumn conditions being so ideal from being basically through three seasons of drought, the whole situation is streets ahead of where we were in February."

Marshall continued the stud's breeding programme and said he did not see any reason why he could not continue adding to his stock.

"I have not been told that I'm not allowed to buy a horse."

Marshall felt "absolutely bullied and targeted" by a social-media "hate campaign".

Horse-welfare activist Nikki Subritzky said she did not believe a month was enough time to rehabilitate horses in a bad condition.

"It doesn't happen overnight with them when they're so neglected. It takes about a year."

She claimed complaints about Marshall in the past had all ended the same way.;

"We complain, authorities step in, cull a few [horses] off because they don't want to spend the resources on rehabilitating and they think 'Out of sight, out of mind'," Subritzky said.

"Then they leave him to repeat the process."

MPI documents said inspections of Marshall's animals over the years identified no welfare issues or found horses were in "light body condition, but not below minimum standard". Marshall was often advised and educated on stocking rate and feeding.

Last month, experts claimed there was a "major problem" with New Zealand's animal-welfare law, with just 17 inspectors in charge of protecting millions of animals.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers

Early childhood teacher makes top 20

The 18-year-old took up the challenge as it supports children and youth in need.

Whangaparaoa early childhood teacher Brooke Houia has made the top 20 in the Miss Universe NZ competition.

Whangarei Boys win Northland Stage Challenge

Whangarei Boys won the Northland Stage Challenge with five  award wins and placings in four other categories.

Whangarei Boys High School takes the Northland Stage Challenge win.

New Zealand's most expensive car wreck?

It appears every single exterior panel on the 2015 McLaren 650S was ruined in the high-speed flip.

Brand new it cost about $480,000, but someone's bought it, shall we say, a little used.

Axle's a water baby

Axle is an elite armed-offenders-trained dog, one of only four in Auckland.

It's surgery, physiotherapy and hydrotherapy for the much-loved veteran police dog.


'League must be banned forever!'

Warriors halfback Shaun Johnson's silky skills are a welcome sight on most footy fields, with the possible exception of ...

Masterton is keen to lure the NZ Warriors to town, but an archaic rule may present a problem.

Diversion for Norman?

Russel Norman swims in front of oil ship

Greenpeace chief may avoid conviction following an open-sea protest.

Boards too revealing

A board showing defendants' names, and parties in civil cases, can be read from the footpath outside the court.

Defendants are identified before they get a chance to ask for suppression.

Shot fired at Masterton home

A shot was fired through this kitchen window, according to police.

Police say shotgun was fired through kitchen window in the early hours of Wednesday.


Beautiful, but abandoned gallery video

This beautiful Colonial mansion in North Canterbury, built in 1885, has been abandoned by its UK owners whose dream fell ...

UK owners abandon North Canterbury colonial mansion after their dream falls through.

Graves under play field

Graves, Graveyard, St Josephs School, Ben Gorman, Rangiora, Playing Field, Matthew Salmons. PHOTO: The former St Josephs ...

Rangiora school children played on the field for decades. Beneath them were more than 350 graves.

Cows tarnishing NZ image

Is it my fault?

Greenpeace launches campaign to decrease cow numbers.

A tiny house for $26k video

A tiny house built by Queenstown's Ayumi Gallagher and her partner near Arrowtown.

Ayumi Gallagher built a house in Queenstown for a fraction of the cost others pay. 


Rail trail contributes millions

The Waikino Station Cafe is a popular stop on the Hauraki Rail Trail.

The Hauraki Rail Trail has brought an estimated $39m return to the region.

Seeking answers

Lucas Cochrane went missing in September 2016.

Lucas Cochrane's hat was found and placed on a fence. It meant his body was not found for three more days.

League ref fleeces club

Dwayne Hibbs stole $13,620 from Waikato Rugby League Referees Association coffers.

Ref siphoned $13,620 from Waikato Rugby League Referees Association to feed his gambling addiction.

Cuts to sand mine jobs

Kaumatua Patrick Maikuku, pictured on the Taharoa Destiny, is unhappy about the prospect of job losses at the sand mine.

Part of Waikato iron sands operation is going and so are 16 jobs, worker says.


Jetstar reduces flights

01022016 News Photo Charlotte Curd/Fairfax.  First day  of Jetstar doing domestic flights into New Plymouth started ...

The weekly number flights will drop from 40 to 28.

Mistrial declared 

On Wednesday, Judge Chris Sygrove declared a mistrial and discharged the jury. The reasons for the mistrial have been ...

 A week and a half after a case involving three men started, it came to a sudden end.

Firm, but go easy on the swing


Superindendent Domenico Squatriti and committee member Craig Waite in a new ...

Enjoy a cold one after fighting to escape a firm and fluffy glass sand bunker

Woolshed burns down 

Fire crews were dampening down the scene after it burnt down overnight.

A woolshed has burnt down overnight at a rural property in South Taranaki.


History comes alive

The Fantasy in Lights display returns to Feilding this month, but with a new host.

Bright lights will dawn on the Coach House Museum in this year's Fantasy in Lights display. 

Glimpsing alcohol OK

Melody's New World's proposed alcohol display area passes the test.

Impulse booze buying not encouraged by shoppers catching a look at packaging.

Elderly fear road crossings

Joy Carter and Doreen Broadbent lead a group of elderly residents across the Kimbolton Rd and Aorangi St intersections.

Elderly residents are crossing the road in fear as concerns about Feilding traffic grow.

Black in blue

Otere Black is leaving the Hurricanes to join the Blues.

Manawatu's Otere Black has signed with the Blues for Super Rugby next year.


Naval salute for Nelson's 'ice man'


Chief of Navy Rear Admiral John Martin, left, appointed Ice pilot Andrew ...

One of the country's most respected ice pilots has received a major naval accolade.

Jobs 'in jeopardy'

Waimea Nurseries director Bruno Simpson warns the company may have to move its operations to the North Island if it ...

Waimea Nurseries boss could move from Nelson to North Island if dam doesn't get built, taking 75 jobs with him.

Funding boost for 'bursting' school

Waimea College principal Scott Haines overlooking the site for new classrooms with Associate Minister of Education Tim ...

Region's biggest school given $4m for new classrooms after roll "sky-rocketed".

Baristas give it their best shot

Nelson College students Jason Peng, left and Robbie Cookson will compete in the Secondary School division barista ...

Two budding baristas are hoping to grind their way to glory at a national coffee contest.


Swimming deer stuns mussel farmer

Clearwater Mussels owner John Young spotted this deer taking a swim through one of his mussel farms, on the western side ...

Deer makes like a dolphin and takes a midwinter dip in the Marlborough Sounds.

Car crash on SH6

Fire and police attended a two-car crash on Wednesday about 7.30am.

A car is blocking the middle of a state highway after crashing into another car.

Church burglar steals children's money

Harvest Life Church elder John Etheredge outside the Nelson St church after it was burgled.

Burglar ransacks church, steals money raised by children for children.

Pools reopen

Four pools at the Marlborough Lines Stadium 2000 aquatic centre have been chemically treated.

After three tests and a chemical treatment, the aquatic centre is back in action.

South Canterbury

Tears, relief on Grasmere St video

Grasmere St resident Don Boot gives one of the remaining condemned pin oaks a final hug before it is cut down on Tuesday.

Some residents watched in horror as condemned pin oaks were cut down on Grasmere St.

Vets support proposals

Dr Dries Meyer at Vetlife Timaru with a stray cat, found injured.

Proposed changes to cat ownership bylaws supported by Timaru vets.

Sugar policy difficult

A national policy on sugary drinks in council workplaces would be difficult to regulate and pose problems when ...

Councillors unimpressed by proposed national sweet drinks policy.

Timaru's annual plan adopted

Timaru mayor Damon Odey. The district's council voted to adopt their annual plan for the next financial year in about an ...

Rates for an average Timaru household are expected to be in the region of $2000.


Steel netball fever builds video

Southern Steel captain Wendy Frew surrounded by Waverley Park Kindergarten kids, including son Archie, at their Steel ...

Stadium Southland boss Nigel Skelt has challenged the crowd to transfer the stadium into a sea of Steel colour.

Steel's dedicated fans video

Alva, 88, and Jack Faul, 92, are dedicated Southern Steel supporters and are excited about Wednesday night's grand final.

Are Jack Faul, 92, and his wife Alva, 88, the Southern Steel's most dedicated couple?

Recycling habits slammed

Southland disAbility Enterprises workers John Kemp and Mary-Ellen Joyce sort recycling on the conveyer belt.

From sex toys to live ammunition and even dead animals, South recycling habits are a cause for concern.

Speeding up transport for mums

Southland Hospital run by Southern District Health Board, in Invercargill.

Pregnant mums in rural areas are getting improved access to emergency transport because of a new policy, the Southern DHB says.

Ad Feedback