Unicef releases damning child welfare report

Kaleb Hurn died by suicide at the age of 17. A new Unicef report has ranked New Zealand the worst in the world when it ...

Kaleb Hurn died by suicide at the age of 17. A new Unicef report has ranked New Zealand the worst in the world when it comes to teen suicide.

New Zealand frequently sits at the top when it comes to international rankings in tourism and economics. A new Unicef report has ranked us number one in another global measure. This is not one to celebrate.

New Zealand has topped the global teen suicide rankings, again.

Our position in the world was cemented on Thursday by a Unicef report that called into question the wellbeing of Kiwi kids.

Kaleb's dad David Hurn says society has created this problem, now it's up to us to find the solution.

Kaleb's dad David Hurn says society has created this problem, now it's up to us to find the solution.

The Innocenti Report found New Zealand's rate for teen suicides (15-19) was the highest of the 41 OECD and EU countries included. We also came in 38th out of 41 countries when it came to overall health and wellbeing of our young people.

Meanwhile, Portugal topped the list at the right end, with a teen suicide rate of 1.7 per 100,000. Italy and Spain were close behind.


* Unicef report: Wellbeing of Kiwi kids languishes behind other developed countries 
* OPINION: NZ is failing its children and we must do better
New Zealand needs to talk about suicide, bereaved dad says 

The report put New Zealand's teen suicide rate of 15.6 people per 100,000, based on data from 2010. The rate had dropped slightly from the previous comparable report that used 2005 data but more recent figures show we were now headed in the other direction. 

Provisional suicide statistics released by the Coroner's Office, show 51 (16.02 per 100,000) people in the age group died by suicide in the year to June 2016 and 52 (16.41 per 100,000) the previous year.

In an average week two young people would kill themselves, and about 20 young people would be hospitalised for self-harm, according to Youthline.

Unicef NZ chief executive Vivien Maidaborn says the rates don't stand in isolation - a range of societal shortfalls are ...

Unicef NZ chief executive Vivien Maidaborn says the rates don't stand in isolation - a range of societal shortfalls are exacerbating the problem.


Ad Feedback

Kaleb Hurn was one of 46 in the 15-19 age bracket who killed himself during 2014. The Waikato teen was 17 when he took his own life.

His father David Hurn said a mix of societal factors played a big part in the high teen suicide rate.

Acting Minister for Children Amy Adams says the government is committed to putting children at the centre of policy.

Acting Minister for Children Amy Adams says the government is committed to putting children at the centre of policy.

A lack of social skills and face-to-face interactions, an ingrained fear of failure, a fear of being different, and bullying all played a part.

Hurn said New Zealand would never completely eradicate teen suicide but the rates could be significantly lowered by teaching children a few fundamental things.

"We need to show our kids it's OK to be different… there's nothing wrong with failing and it's OK to make mistakes."

Labour's deputy leader and spokesperson for children Jacinda Ardern says child poverty measures are needed to hold those ...

Labour's deputy leader and spokesperson for children Jacinda Ardern says child poverty measures are needed to hold those in power to account.

"It's building up that resilience," Hurn said.

Kiwis needed to look in the mirror and start making changes if they wanted to fix the problem.

"We've created what we have, now it's up to us to create what we want."

Hurn's father died recently and a section of his eulogy resonated: "I didn't grow up to be a rocket scientist; I didn't grow up to be prime minister; I grew up to be me, and I'm the best me that I can be."

Suicide, especially teen suicide, has become a high-profile political issue during the past few months given New Zealand's consistently high rates.

The government is in the midst of writing its new national suicide prevention strategy, which is currently out for public consultation. But the strategy was thrown into the limelight for the wrong reasons after mental health advocate and comedian Mike King quit the consultation panel, calling the draft strategy "deeply flawed".


Unicef chief executive Vivien Maidaborn said the rate should not be considered in isolation. It was influenced by a constellation of other factors, such as socio-economic background, poverty, cultural influences and inequality.

The Unicef report highlighted other areas where New Zealand was doing terribly, including equality where we ranked 26th.

The report also found 19.8 per cent of Kiwi kids were living in relative income poverty, and the neonatal mortality rate was 3.1 children per 1000 (the same as in 2005), and the teenage birth rate was 23.3 births per 1000 females aged 15-19, a reduction from 28.7 per 1000 in 2005.

Asking why the rate was so high might be the wrong question, Maidaborn said.

Historically, New Zealand governments focused on the economy and an economic approach to policy when there was a need for a "whole-life" approach to welfare.

A more honest conversation about income poverty and inequality was necessary, she said.

"We design our economic policy and then try to fix it if we get it wrong for young children [but] it's like we're designing for the middle and most well-off New Zealanders.

"I feel like we have been talking about the economy as a measure of success in our society in collaboration with individual responsibility now for 25 years. That's resulted in a penal welfare system."


Acting Minister for Children Amy Adams said government work was underway to support children and young people's wellbeing, especially our most vulnerable.

Both the newly formed Ministry for Vulnerable Children, Oranga Tamariki and the Ministry of Social Development were involved in "a range of cross-government projects to improve children and young people's wellbeing", she said. 

This included the refreshed suicide prevention strategy, the Mental Health Strategy and implementation of the Youth Mental Health Project, as well as anti-bullying strategies.

She also listed recently announced funding that focussed on at-risk children and families, like $2 billion into Family Income Packages and $28.1 million into Family Start, a home visiting programme that helped the government target support to at-risk children.

Then there's the Child Hardship Package - $790m for up to 100,000 kids in extreme hardship, and increased benefits and tax credits for low-icome families.

"It's important to have child-centred policy," Adams said.

"This is a core focus in the government's four-to-five-year transformation of our care and protection system, and has resulted in a child-centred operating model led by the Ministry for Vulnerable Children, Oranga Tamariki."

Legislation that passed in December 2016 ensured children and young people's views were taken into account in the development of services and policy. And if successful, legislation currently before parliament would establish enhanced complaints processes for children, young people and their families, whānau and caregivers, Adams said.


Labour deputy leader and spokesperson for children's issues Jacinda Ardern said the report's results were "astounding but not surprising".

New Zealand should be striving to be "world-leading" when it came to child wellbeing.

"This is an area where we need to be aspirational," Ardern said.

New Zealand should be setting goals and reporting on progress when it came to child health and wellbeing.

"We need to be lifting our game on child poverty."

The government had dismissed the idea of setting child poverty measures in the past, saying it wanted to focus on getting on with fixing the problem rather than reporting on goals.

"But they're not doing that either."

Arden said she hoped this report, which included sustainable development goals as set out by the UN, would not be dismissed by the government as had been the case with previous Unicef reports.


The World Health organisation has identified youth suicide as an issue that needs addressing.

For countries like New Zealand that have a national strategy in place, "the emphasis can be on evaluation and improvement", the WHO report said.

"The emphasis for these countries is on the timely inclusion of new data and ensuring that the national response improves in effectiveness and efficiency. Effective suicide prevention will require a continuous cycle of learning and doing."

In New Zealand, the Coroner's Office compiles the provisional suicide statistics, while district health boards across the country keep data on events including completed suicides, and attempts that lead to hospital admissions or interaction with mental health services.

While data is being collected and evaluated, there have been recent, loud calls for a Royal Commission of Inquiry into the mental health system, following the publicly organised People's Mental Health Review.

It's important to note people with mental health issues are at higher risk of suicide but many young Kiwis who take their own lives do not have a diagnosed mental illness and never came into contact with mental health services.


Le Va chief executive Monique Faleafa said the teen suicide rate was "unacceptably high".

New Zealand's suicide rate was an anomaly, she said.

While other countries experienced large increases and decreases, our rate remained relatively constant. This made it harder to use the data to figure out what caused and prevented suicide.

What we did know was causal factors were complex, Faleafa said, adding that meant prevention strategies also had to be complex.

Prevention had to happen at all levels: in communities and schools, in legislation and at a societal level.

Faleafa said poverty did not cause suicide but it could be one of the risk factors.

Current initiatives were underway to bring rates down, including the national suicide prevention strategy that was currently under consultations, and a soon-to-be-launched national training programme for those who were likely to come into contact with people at risk of suicide.

Almost 20 years ago, the government released a report on youth suicide, highlighting the high rate in the 15-24 bracket, among males, and among the Maori population.

In 1998, New Zealand had the second highest reported suicide rate for those aged 15-24, the report said. And since then, not much has changed.

Faleafa said while there was good work being done around the country, she hoped the Unicef report would bring "a sense of urgency". 


Lifeline (open 24/7) - 0800 543 354

Depression Helpline (open 24/7) - 0800 111 757

Healthline (open 24/7) - 0800 611 116

Samaritans (open 24/7) - 0800 726 666

Suicide Crisis Helpline (open 24/7) - 0508 828 865 (0508 TAUTOKO). This is a service for people who may be thinking about suicide, or those who are concerned about family or friends.

Youthline (open 24/7) - 0800 376 633. You can also text 234 for free between 8am and midnight, or email talk@youthline.co.nz

0800 WHATSUP children's helpline - phone 0800 9428 787 between 1pm and 10pm on weekdays and from 3pm to 10pm on weekends. Online chat is available from 7pm to 10pm every day at www.whatsup.co.nz.

Kidsline (open 24/7) - 0800 543 754. This service is for children aged 5 to 18. Those who ring between 4pm and 9pm on weekdays will speak to a Kidsline buddy. These are specially trained teenage telephone counsellors.

Your local Rural Support Trust - 0800 787 254 (0800 RURAL HELP)

Alcohol Drug Helpline (open 24/7) - 0800 787 797. You can also text 8691 for free.

 For further information, contact the Mental Health Foundation's free Resource and Information Service (09 623 4812).

 - Stuff


Ad Feedback
special offers

Auckland citizens' arrest

Waitemata police with loot allegedly stolen from a North Shore home, where a burglar was detained by construction workers.

A group of construction workers nabbed a would-be burglar and held him while police were called.

Buy food or go to the doctor?

A visit to your doctor will cost the same whether you have a community services card or not.

Community services cards are pointless, critics say, as health costs cripple.

Thirty for Amazing Chase

Group I NZ Breeders' Stakes winner Thrilling Flo has been nominated for the Amazing Chase.

Greyhound bosses thrilled with level of nominations for new match-racing series.

'I want to salute your resilience'

Teenager Christie Marceau was murdered in 2011. An inquest into her death is currently taking place.

Coroner tears up as she thanks Marceau parents in the final day of their daughter's inquest.


Maccas to quit Johnsonville Mall

McDonald's NZ has confirmed it will leave the Johnsonville Shopping Centre in September. (File photo)

Future looks more uncertain with exit of McDonald's and optometrist OPSM.

Bistro closes its doors

An empty and closed Tinakori Bistro on Tinakori Rd.  The restaurant has gone ...

Tinakori Bistro is in liquidation, owing more than $300,000, including unpaid wages.

Landfill bills to rocket

Wellington ratepayers are facing heavy cost increases for dumping over the next two years.

Costs created by gas emissions could mean higher fees and a rise in rates.

'Koro Ap' killed in crossing crash

Aporo Joyce, 79, was hit and killed by a car in Tawa on Wednesday night.

The pedestrian hit in Tawa was ex-cop Aporo Joyce - "such a special person".


Playground, pools by Christmas

The planned New Brighton playground.

New Brighton's new seaside playground and children's pools should be ready by Christmas.

'Barclay must go now'

Glenys Dickson was paid the clandestine money when she was made aware of the dictaphone left running.

The woman at the centre of the Todd Barclay scandal says he should've resigned immediately.

Canterbury trio's illegal duck cull

From left: Timothy Peter Donald, Phillip Julian Moore and Nigel Donald McMillan leave court after being sentenced for an ...

Three men say they killed the ducks as the birds' faeces makes their livestock ill.

Ram-raid for snacks, then chase

Five youth offenders were caught by police after allegedly ram-raiding a Z service station in Waikuku, Canterbury.

Youths arrested after allegedly ram-raiding a Canty petrol station and stealing snacks.


Teacher retires after 40 years

Deanwell School principal Pat Poland retires at the end of the school term after 40 years in education. He's pictured ...

A Hamilton principal would rather drive trucks than put up with the red tape in education.

Fatal crash closes SH1

The fatal truck crash happened near Lichfield about 2.15pm on Thursday.

One person is dead following a crash between two trucks on State Highway 1 in South Waikato.

Grad-entry med school pays off

Flinders University Professor Paul Worley, dean of the School of Medicine, said offering a four-year graduate-entry ...

NZ is putting all its eggs in one basket by not offering a graduate-entry medical programme.

Missing man's case 'sinister'

Rick Hayward went missing in September 2013, aged 67. Now police say they have new information.

Police say they're a step closer to knowing what happened to Rick Hayward.


How Beauden learned his trade

Beauden Barrett on the attack against Samoa.

To appreciate the zest and mastery with which Beauden Barrett plays rugby, you have to understand his childhood.

Counting pennies

The Taranaki District Health Board's budget for the coming year was cut by 1% after the Government discovered  a mistake ...

The Government giveth and the Government taketh away...

Meeting? No, the Lions are on

New Plymouth Mayor Neil Holdom has rescheduled a council meeting so the chief executive could attend the Lions v ...

Council boss will be watching the Lions take on the Hurricanes instead of setting rates.

Cows moooved off state highway

One cow is still outstanding.

The cows may have gone looking for the greener grass on the other side of the state highway.


Kapa haka delights gallery

Peara Aumua, of Russell Street School, performs at the Regent on Broadway.

The Regent on Broadway pulsed with haka and songs as hundreds took the stage.

Robber confronted

A woman escaped on a bike down College St in Palmerston North after robbing the West End Store.

Dairy owner confronts a robber on the street, but he is assaulted and sent to hospital.

Manawatu asked to cough up

A perspective of the Whanganui velodrome with its proposed roof.

Palmerston North mayor Grant Smith supports Whanganui cycle pitch.

People flee fire

The fire service respond to two fires in quick succession. (File photo)

They escape from the second floor of a building alight in Whanganui.


Hogey rides new wave

John Hogan is catching a new business wave, selling his Nelson surf shop after 12 years of doing business.

Slow winters and rise of online shopping spells end of veteran retailer's Nelson surf shop.

Fatal fire investigated

Emergency services cordon off at the scene of a fatal house fire in Stoke, Nelson.

A post mortem will be carried out on the victim of a fatal house fire in Stoke.

School mourns 'unique' teacher

Graeme Woods in his classroom at Broadgreen Intermediate.

A fit, energetic 52-year-old, Graeme Woods passed away suddenly in his sleep.

Kiwi craft chocolate wins gold

Marina and Karl Hogarth in front of their coffee roaster adapted for chocolate roasting.

Nelson chocolatiers Hogarth won top prize at the global chocolate awards in London.


Who makes your clothes?

New Zealand-made is thriving in Blenheim thanks to the ladies at Forward Fashion.

The little town at the forefront of the NZ-made movement. And yes, people are happy to pay more.

Truck rolls on SH63

Police are at the scene of a truck crash and waiting for a crane on State Highway 63.

Crane called in to move truck near Renwick on State Highway 63.

Airport talks successful

Marlborough Airport is in discussions with the New Zealand Defence Force about accessing the land they need to expand.

Airport chief executive hopeful meeting with Defence Force staff will pave the way for the airport to grow.

Gymnasts flock to stadium

Local competitor Greta Williams competes at last year's Marlborough gymnastics championships.

Over 550 gymnasts will attend the Marlborough Gymnastic Championships this weekend.

South Canterbury

Two takes on South Canty issues video

Opportunities Party leader Gareth Morgan said skilled workers should be welcomed in South Canterbury, but unskilled ones ...

Finance Minister Steven Joyce vs TOP leader Gareth Morgan.

Kiwis urged to help

An online petition has been launched to help keep the Davies family in New Zealand.

Former South African journalist urges Kiwis to help fight deportation of blind girl.

Plan change rules frustrate

A dairy farm in the Waitaki Valley, on the north bank of the river. If ECan's "Plan Change 5" goes ahead, all farming ...

"Farmers will be immediately frustrated and won't have respect for some of the rules."

First dirty air days for two towns

Traffic on Timaru's Evans Street, on the shortest (and coldest) day of the year.

Timaru has sixth high pollution day as Geraldine and Waimate record first of 2017.


Literacy students as busy as bees

Spelling contestants, Mai MacRae, Brooke Scott, Callum McMurtrie, and Riyanna Stevenson, all 10, of Te Anau School A ...

A spelling bee competition has hundreds of Southland students buzzing.

Turned away from GP

Dr Martin Tooke and practice manager Kody Young of the He Puna Waiora Wellness Centre in Invercargill, which has capped ...

"If we wanted to increase our patient numbers slightly we would definitely need another fulltime GP on board."

MP exits swiftly, but what next

Todd Barclay fronts the media on Monday, June 20.

OPINION: Falling on his sword has redeemed MP Todd Barclay and his leader. But for how long?

Family community-minded

Chief fire officer Brent Shepherd has been a volunteer in the Edendale brigade for 22 years.

Volunteer firefighter Brent Shepherd is active in community events in Edendale.

Ad Feedback