What's next after What Next? We must continue discussion about NZ's future

Presenters John Campbell and Nigel Latta hosted "What Next", a five-part, live and interactive series that explored what ...
TVNZ

Presenters John Campbell and Nigel Latta hosted "What Next", a five-part, live and interactive series that explored what New Zealand could look like in 2037.

OPINION: What's next after What Next?

TV One's What Next?, which explored what society might look like in 2037, concluded on Thursday last week, having aired across five consecutive nights.

It was a welcome experiment by TVNZ: public interest programming in prime time, John Campbell back on our screens, and - most significantly - a serious look at the future beyond the short-term focus of most factual and current affairs media.

What Next? took a look at how New Zealand's future might be in 20 years - but Luke Goode says while the show was a good ...
SUPPLIED

What Next? took a look at how New Zealand's future might be in 20 years - but Luke Goode says while the show was a good starting point, more discussion is needed.

We desperately need informed public debate about potential pathways into the future. Steady-as- she-goes, what the show called "Plan A" is no plan at all. We need bold thought experiments and new ideas about our approach to the economy, the environment and disruptive new technologies.

READ MORE:
What Next? takes on health, retirement and housing
What Next? Bugs are NZ's farming future
What Next? Nigel Latta and John Campbell team up

 

What Next? has been a positive but limited first step.

The show covered a wide range of interesting topics: automation, self-driving cars, insects and synthetic meat as alternative protein sources, extended lifespans, the future of consumerism, and many more besides. Sadly, these came so thick and fast that there was rarely time to explore them in any depth.

What Next? usefully showcased some of the ideas that should be on the agenda for debating the future but in a rather chaotic way that frequently lacked a wider context. It is of limited value to discuss autonomous vehicles, for example, without linking this to transport policy, energy infrastructure and economics: who will be in a position to enjoy this hi-tech future?

A second issue with What Next? is that it focused heavily on the choices facing individual consumers, communities and especially businesses, but very lightly on questions of government policy.

Ad Feedback

The show should be applauded for presenting the future in terms of choices, rather than using its expert panel of futurists to predict our inevitable fate. But while there is an important role to be played by individuals, enterprises and civil society groups in creating a desirable future, we also need to think carefully as citizens about the kinds of governments we elect.

What Next? focused heavily on social entrepreneurship, philanthropy, local resource sharing schemes, individual lifestyle choices and other voluntary initiatives (such as the excellent Free Store project in Wellington that redistributes good food from eateries that would otherwise be wasted).

But these will only take us so far. Policy platforms around infrastructure, transport, housing, taxation, wealth distribution, retirement policy, environmental regulation and so forth are vital components that will shape our future.

These remained mostly off the table in what was perhaps an understandable but misguided attempt to keep the show apolitical: like it or not, the future is political.

Even inequality and poverty were framed largely as problems of attitude rather than policy. The welcome discussion of a Universal Basic Income was a notable exception to this relative neglect of policy.

Finally, we come to the question of public engagement. What Next? made use of live comment feeds, running polls and after-show online discussion as part of a well-intentioned effort to make us feel involved.

But poorly framed questions, scattergun topics and a disconnect between studio discussion and audience feedback made it seem more like interactivity for its own sake than a platform for serious public debate.

In order to engage the public in serious debate about the future, it's also important to excite, inspire and motivate.

Sadly, What Next? fell short on this front.

There is no need to sensationalise or to deviate from the facts as we know them.

But, to a substantial degree, thinking about the future will always be an exercise in imagination and speculation. What's needed are visions that can move us: visions of the future that are inspiring enough to fight for them, and visions that are repellent enough that they motivate us to avoid them.

What Next? devoted an episode to the environment, for example, but barely articulated the seriousness of the consequences we face if we don't find new ways to manage our economy, nor the urgency of the challenge.

 

And while the futuristic vignettes were an interesting device, they would have benefited from more drama: for example, they could have depicted some very different futures side-by- side, depending on the choices we make in the present.

Perhaps it's unreasonable to expect a single TV show to be oriented towards practical policy on the one hand and be dramatic or exciting on the other.

Despite the best efforts of the hosts (especially Nigel Latta's enthusiasm, assisted, it transpires, by a genetic disposition towards optimism and sprinting), it managed to be both a little dry and light on practical and policy implications. For example, seeing politicians from the main parties grilled in one episode about the future implications of their policies would have been both beneficial and a welcome variation in what became a rather repetitive format.

Despite these limitations, TVNZ should be applauded for the worthy ideals behind What Next? We need more conversations about the future. And we need better ones. Let's see What Next? as first steps and keep talking about the future.

Luke Goode is Associate Professor in Media and Communication at the University of Auckland. The University was a sponsor of What Next? However, Luke was not involved in this initiative. The views expressed in this article are his own and do not reflect those of the University of Auckland.

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

From five-figures to $47

Maya Shatura was diagnosed with acute lymphyoblastic leukemia in 2015.

Auckland mum says financial help for parents with sick kids is a "grey area" after trading her five-figure income for a $47 weekly benefit.

Chef's kitchen: Anne Thorp

Chef Anne Thorp in her Pakiri home, north Auckland.

My home at Pakiri Beach was built in 1999, and it was built around the kitchen.

Right teams, wrong game

The group pose for a selfie with All Black Sam Whitelock after the game.

Wellington fans turn up at Eden Park with tickets to the wrong test match.

Beard grabbing mutual

Corey Webster and his partner of two years Tanya Mackintosh both testified for the defence at the North Shore District ...

Corey Webster says a beard pulling incident that led to his court appearance was a mutual joke.

Wellington

$100,000 to rename a highway

The new Kapiti expressway at the intersection with Poplar Ave, with old SH1, and new local road, at the top.

Kapiti council gets big lump of taxpayer cash for its road renaming process.

Right idea, wrong test

The group pose for a selfie with All Black Sam Whitelock after the game.

Wellington fans turn up at Eden Park with tickets to the wrong test match.

U-turn on special housing area

A building on George St, in Thorndon, which Wellington City Council turned down as a special housing area for 31 new ...

A proposal to fast-track consent for 31 apartments in Thorndon has been scrapped.

Disgust at killer's Facebook page

Clem Pepene has a Facebook page in his name, despite serving a life sentence for murder.

"Honestly, it's just traumatic," says angry relative of murder victim.

Canterbury

Restoration project with 'heart' video

The Kilwinning lodge on Canterbury St, Lyttelton, was significantly damaged in the Canterbury earthquakes.

Old Masonic lodge and studio for artist Bill Hammond could become a micro-brewery, offices or shops after massive restoration.

Changes challenged

Traffic on Worcester St will not be able to cross Fitzgerald Ave when the current design for the Rapanui-Shag Rock ...

Business owners threaten legal action as council pushes ahead with cycleway.

Disappearance nears 40 days

Christchurch builder Michael McGrath, 49, has been missing for almost 40 days.

Prison guard who police need to eliminate from inquiry into man's disappearance says he's the victim of a witch hunt.

Man seriously assaulted

Police are investigating a serious assault on a man as he walked  to work in Invercargill early on Thursday (file photo).

A man has been admitted to hospital with serious injuries after an unprovoked street attack.

Waikato

Lake trip all it's quacked up to be

They flock in numbers, trying to be the first to get the bread.

A flock of ducks joins this Taupo cruise captain every day as he motors around the lake.

Masks on in flu fight

From Monday, visitors to Waikato Hospital will be asked to wear a mask if they haven't been vaccinated against the flu.

Waikato Hospital visitors given a choice: get a flu shot or wear a mask.

Fleeing driver caught

All four of the car's tyres were blown after police laid spikes.

Passing motorists said the driver of a car on rims was puffing on a cigarette with his headphones on.

Man chases child in fog

Cambridge East School principal Hamish Fenemor said the man took advantage of the thick fog in the area to try and chase ...

Driver follows pupil to school before chasing child through thick fog.

Taranaki

Is it time to regulate mountain climbing?

Officials were waiting for daylight to break on Mt Taranaki before airlifting the man's body off.

Low cloud hindering rescuers recovering body on mountain

New bike after crash

Brenda Crummey treasures her new racing bike, which was bought by the man who struck her with his car on May 16.

Struck down by his car, an injured cyclist's spirits were lifted by the driver's gift of a new bike.

Parking charges to start again

A 12 month week trial of free Saturday car parking in the New Plymouth CBD has ended.

It was good while it lasted.

Woman's cancer shock

Nicole Huston and Emma Wilson were enjoying a girls' trip to Hawaii at this time last year.

She went to the doctor expecting to be given iron pills but was diagnosed with leukaemia.

Manawatu

World record scrum attempted video

Black Fern fullback Selica Winiata places the ball into the scrum.

The attempt had the numbers - but will it satisfy the scrutineers?

Second murder charge

Palmiro MacDonald was last seen in the week leading up to Easter 2016.

A 28-year-old man has been charged with Palmiro MacDonald's murder.

Physicality key for Laumape video

Ngani Laumape will become All Black No 1160 if he makes it on the field on Saturday.

Moving from the loose forwards to midfield started the rise of Ngani Laumape in rugby.

Shooter's appeal fails

The aftermath at the central Palmerston North police station after Faraniko Pei shot at it with a shotgun on August 10, 2015.

 Man who fired shots into police stations, and in full view of constable, has appeal dismissed.

Nelson

Nelson's first catamaran?

27062017 NEWS / SUPPLIED

Patricia and Jack Stent of Nelson.

Team NZ's win brings back memories of Nelson's first cat.

Socks, sex and school

Nelson College for Girls student Madi Fulton Buckle wearing her over-the-knee socks.

A Nelson school's ban on 'creepy porn looking' socks has sparked a student documentary.

'Good-guy' farmer's free motocross

Travis Langford hosts motocross for kids every Wednesday after school on his track.

A farmer has turned a paddock into a free motocross "playground" for local kids.

Nelson winner cashes in with Lotto

A Nelson store is one of eight winning Lotto ticket sellers during this week's second division round.

A Nelson store is one of eight stores to sell second division winning Lotto tickets.

Marlborough

The little weed threatening NZ

Seddon farmer Tim Struthers discusses the spraying programme he has introduced to fight Chilean Needle Grass on his property.

It used to be a farmers' problem, but it could threaten the country's other 'cash cow': tourism.

Clean pee pays off

Charles Wiremu Maru used codenames such as "garlic bread" to offer drugs to people through text messages. (File photo)

Man who used codenames including "garlic bread" to sell cannabis and meth is now off drugs.

Maori school for Marlborough

Omaka Marae general manager Kiley Nepia, back left, with Renwick School principal Simon Heath, back right, and some of ...

"Where succeeding as Maori and being Maori is not an extra curriculum activity, but is at the centre and heart of everything we do."

SH6 reopens after truck fire

Emergency services had to cut a driver from his car after and attempt to overtake vehicles banked up from the previous ...

One lane of the road between Havelock and Nelson has reopened following a truck fire on Wednesday evening

South Canterbury

Teachers push for pay parity

Little Wonders Early Childhood Centre acting manager Laura Trott helps Paris Ngatamiriki, 4, along a plank. The New ...

Early childhood education workers say it is time to pay qualified teachers fairly.

DHB ups ante on air

Timaru District Councillor Peter Burt says he does not support monitoring PM2.5 levels, as the town is already failing ...

Health board wants to take air quality guidelines further and monitor smaller particles.

Concern over gun finds

New Zealand Police Association president Chris Cahill.

Concern after firearms discovered in two incidents in South Canterbury in one week.

Low levels lift prices video

An aerial view showing Tekapo B power Station at Lake Pukaki. The lake level is currently at 524 metres above sea level, ...

'Spot' power prices could continue to rise as South Island hydro lakes drop.

Southland

Steel dominate Premiership final

Ginna Crampton, Wendy Frew (centre) and Shannon Francois celebrate Premiership success.

 The Southern Steel complete the perfect season with a big win over the Central Pulse.

Pet goat killed

22022017 Photo: ROSS GIBLIN\Fairfax
Generic pic: emergency services, police, police car, ambulance, Wellington Free ...

Police are investigating reports of illegal hunting after a pet goat was killed.

Milford tourist boom's problems

The stunning Mitre Peak rising 1.6km vertically out of Milford Sound.

Visitor numbers to Milford Sound are expected to reach 875,000 in 2017 and exceed one million by 2019.

Southland Arts Festival runs at loss

Southland Festival of the Arts organiser Angela Newell ahead of the 2017 festival held in April and May.

The month-long Southland Arts Festival ran at an $8000 loss this year and changes may be afoot.

Ad Feedback