Pike River families granted leave for Supreme Court appeal of dropping charges against Peter Whittall

Pike River mine protesters Anna Osborne and Sonya Rockhouse.
SUPPLIED

Pike River mine protesters Anna Osborne and Sonya Rockhouse.

The families of those killed in Pike River mine have been granted a Supreme Court hearing to appeal the decision to drop charges against Peter Whittall.

Sonya Rockhouse, who lost her 21-year-old son, Ben, in the 2010 disaster, and Anna Osborne, who lost her husband, Milton, sought a judicial review of the decision by WorkSafe NZ to drop the charges against Whittall, who was Pike River's former boss. 

Twenty-nine men died when the West Coast coal mine exploded on November 19, 2010.

Former Pike River chief executive Peter Whittall in Greymouth District Court before the charges against him were dropped.
IAIN MCGREGOR/FAIRFAX NZ

Former Pike River chief executive Peter Whittall in Greymouth District Court before the charges against him were dropped.

Whittall, the mine's chief executive at the time of the disaster, initially faced 12 health and safety charges. All were dropped in December 2013.

READ MORE: 
Families lodge appeal on Pike River judicial review decision
Pike River judicial review rejected​
Pike River: Five years on
Pike River blast victims awarded compo

Pike River Coal Ltd, the mine owner, pleaded guilty to nine charges and was fined $760,000.

Whittall offered to make a voluntary payment of $3.41 million from his insurer if Worksafe did not offer any evidence against him. The court ordered the reparation. 

The families and two survivors received payments.

Osborne said earlier the families had no say in whether to accept or reject the $3.4m, which amounted to $110,000 per family.

She previously called it "blood money".

Ad Feedback

The Court of Appeal upheld a High Court decision to reject the judicial review in February. It found the decision by Worksafe was "lawfully made".

"As a matter of law, the prosecutor was entitled to consider and give weight to a conditional reparation undertaking as one factor in deciding whether or not to pursue the prosecution further," the Court of Appeal said.  

However, a Supreme Court judgment, released on Monday, granted the families leave to challenge the decision to the Supreme Court.

Lawyer Nigel Hampton QC, who represents Osborne and Rockhouse, said they would argue in the Supreme Court the payment to families was an "unlawful bargain", not "just a voluntary payment". 

"Historically you should not be able to pay money or have money paid on your behalf to have a prosecution dismissed," he said. 

Hampton expected the matter to be heard in the Supreme Court later this year.

 

 

 

 

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Live: Storm shifts south

Here it comes - the low pressure system nears the country in this MetService satellite image 6am on Thursday.

Low pressure system to soak Canterbury and Otago, with flooding and snow possible.

Power back on for Aucklanders

Traffic built up on Auckland's motorways on Thursday evening as commuters headed home through heavy wind gusts.

Weather warning lifted and electricity restored after strong winds batter region.

Govt apology on passport fraud

Paul Sisson said he hit a brick wall with the Department of Internal Affairs when he complained about alleged passport fraud.

DIA promises to investigate complaint about suspected international money scam.

From loss to blessings video

Emma Farry, author of book 'Beloved' at Muriwai beach where she lives.

A Muriwai author helped deal with loss of her mother by sitting on a rock at the beach.

Wellington

Fraudster's home to be sold

Former Tenths Trust chairman and Te Puni Kokiri chief executive Sir Ngatata Love is serving a jail term for obtaining by ...

Police win order to sell Ngatata Love and Lorraine Skiffington's "tainted" home.

Ngauranga tunnel plan

Ohariu MP Peter Dunne, who is also leader of United Future, suggests a Ngauranga tunnel could run parallel to the main ...

United Future leader Peter Dunne proposes 4km route in case gorge road shuts.

Island Bay cycleway, the sequel

Former Wellington Mayor Celia Wade-Brown cycles along the controversial first section of the Island Bay cycleway (file ...

Some Wellingtonians already worried about plans to extend the Island Bay cycleway.

Tree branch crashes near brothers

The macrocarpa branch fell over the footpath and on to Golf Rd.

"The whole side of the tree fell down," say pair walking near Kapiti golf course.

Canterbury

Conman faked his death

Wayne Eaglesome, alive and well, outside one of his backpackers last year.

Millionaire "Alex Newman" needed super yacht staff. Then he "died", leaving all to charity.

'Something sinister'

Police working on the case of missing Christchurch builder Michael McGrath are asking for sightings of a late 1990s ...

Michael McGrath's brother believes the missing man met "something sinister" as police appeal for car sightings.

Concerns for missing woman

Canterbury Police are looking for 34 year old Melissa Jane Dalgety. She was last seen on Thursday morning and is ...

Police have concerns for the welfare of a woman missing in Canterbury.

Labour to rid contentious fire rule

Labour's Rangitata candidate Jo Luxton.

Rule banning use of woodburners 15 years or older would be scrapped under Labour.

Waikato

Homes, sections shrink

Council rules allow duplexes to be built on a 400sqm section.

At one Hamilton development, 14 semi-detached homes are being built on a section that could accommodate five stand-alone homes.

Sanctions hit kids

Green Party co-leader Metiria Turei says the policy "is clearly not working because so many women are not complying".

Nearly 20,000 children are paying the price for the government's benefit policy.

Dam lowered ahead of weather

The Matahina Dam expects to operate normally thanks to lowering lake levels ahead of the storm.

There is plenty of rain, but there is also plenty of room in Lake Matahina.

Dancer stars in Psy's video video

Psy performs Gangnam Style at the 40th American Music Awards.

A Hamilton 12-year-old dances in Gangnam Style star's latest music video.

Taranaki

Mark makes food his living

A Fridge specialty is manuka smoked salmon.

New Plymouth butcher Mark Wormald talks about his life in the trade.

Best mate's brutal blow

A Taranaki man pleaded guilty in the New Plymouth District Court to a serious assault on his best friend. (File Photo)

He admitted he was stealing from his mate and for his honesty he was punched in the head.

Mary Poppins brings smiles

Mary Poppins finds a treat in her magic bag for Xavier Pike.

The visit went down in the most delightful way - "it's not every day Mary Poppins pops in to visit."

New festival coming

Chefs from the Hobson Hotel's Governors Eatery and Bar will take part in a new food and drink festival in New Plymouth ...

Taranaki's food and beverages to be showcased at new festival.

Manawatu

Greening the gullies up

The Mangaotane Reserve on the outskirts of Palmerston North in 2015 showing the results of native planting by the Green ...

A native planting project had matured into a winner with the birds.

Link broken by neglect

The Saddle Rd is restricted to one east-bound lane during the day as upgrades are carried out.

A Massey University academic is blaming a lack of planning from the authorities for the current Manawatu Gorge woes.

Email interception confirmed

Chief executive David Clapperton and Mayor Michael Feyen are at loggerheads over email blocking revelations at the ...

Emails from councilors not blocked but "quarantined and vetted", council says.

Two-car crash in Woodville

A two-car crash in Woodville injured three people.

Three people are in hospital, one with serious injuries, after a two-car crash in Woodville.

Nelson

Shipwreck danger

The wreck of the Janie Seddon on Motueka's foreshore.

A wooden prop holds up the stern, but children still love climbing it. 

Land grab off to court

Lindsay McKenzie says compensation for the land required for the dam project is unlikely to exceed $2.5m on current ...

Landowners whose properties are earmarked for the proposed Waimea dam are heading to court.

Road layout unsafe?

Nelson City Councillor Tim Skinner with the new signage and curbing on Brook St.

New signage and road layout in the Brook is fuelling the cyclist-driver debate. 

Airport marks milestone video

Abby Nalder, the millionth passenger to arrive at Nelson Airport, is congratulated by her mother Kirsten.

Nelson Airport breaks 1 million passenger a year mark.

Marlborough

For the love of lawn

Blenheim lawn enthusiast Russell Bulfin likes to keep his grass as green and cleanly cut as possible.

Russell Bulfin's answer to perfect grass is simple: mow three times a week and fertilise monthly.

Fifteen people in crash

A minivan, ute and car crashed at the intersection of Alabama Rd and State Highway 1 about 5.30pm on Wednesday.

Minivan, car and ute crash at State Highway 1 intersection.

Funds to finish theatre

From left, theatre manager Andrew Scott, trustee Anton James, Kaikoura MP Stuart Smith, trustee Tim Leslie, trust vice ...

Government commits $900,000 to finish the ASB Theatre, in Blenheim, a year after it officially opened.

Truck company fined after crash

The truck drove down a bank near Ward, Marlborough, after the steering shaft detached.

The truck veered across the road, down a bank and into a swamp because its steering shaft was incorrectly installed.

South Canterbury

Wild weather on the way

Fire service Mid-South Canterbury assistant area manager Steven Greenyer said fire fighters, even those off duty on ...

Wild weather could bring half of South Canterbury's yearly rain fall to the region in one day.

Rain a 'real worry'

Residents encountered a foggy start to the day in Timaru on Wednesday.

Region prepares as a months' rainfall is expected for South Canterbury on Friday.

Labour to scrap fire rule

Labour's Rangitata candidate Jo Luxton.

Controversial rule banning use of old woodburners would be scrapped under Labour.

Jailed for 'predatory' behaviour

Judge Joanna Maze said Maze said Blair Beaumont had a "extraordinarily large amount of dishonesty offending".

Man jailed after gambling habit led him to a "very dark" place.

Southland

Army appealing for donations

Gerry Forde with a gnarly carrot from his community veggie garden where volunteers were growing vegetables to support 20 ...

The Spirit Army are appealing to the public for support as they look to support vulnerable families through winter.

Another speed record video

Watch: Lee Munro - great-nephew of Burt Munro - screams across California desert on high-powered custom Indian Scout

Fifty years after Burt Munro set a land speed record, his great-nephew emulates him.

Government gives oyster removal contracts to oyster farmers

Farmed Oysters removed from Stewart Island being unloaded in Bluff under MPI supervision.

The Government is awarding oyster removal contracts to oyster farmers to support them as they lose their livelihoods.

SBS looks to the future

SBS Bank chief executive Shaun Drylie addresses members at the bank's annual meeting at the Kelvin Hotel in Invercargill.

Catering services to different generations was a key message from the SBS annual meeting.

Ad Feedback