Pike River families granted leave for Supreme Court appeal of dropping charges against Peter Whittall

Pike River mine protesters Anna Osborne and Sonya Rockhouse.
SUPPLIED

Pike River mine protesters Anna Osborne and Sonya Rockhouse.

The families of those killed in Pike River mine have been granted a Supreme Court hearing to appeal the decision to drop charges against Peter Whittall.

Sonya Rockhouse, who lost her 21-year-old son, Ben, in the 2010 disaster, and Anna Osborne, who lost her husband, Milton, sought a judicial review of the decision by WorkSafe NZ to drop the charges against Whittall, who was Pike River's former boss. 

Twenty-nine men died when the West Coast coal mine exploded on November 19, 2010.

Former Pike River chief executive Peter Whittall in Greymouth District Court before the charges against him were dropped.
IAIN MCGREGOR/FAIRFAX NZ

Former Pike River chief executive Peter Whittall in Greymouth District Court before the charges against him were dropped.

Whittall, the mine's chief executive at the time of the disaster, initially faced 12 health and safety charges. All were dropped in December 2013.

READ MORE: 
Families lodge appeal on Pike River judicial review decision
Pike River judicial review rejected​
Pike River: Five years on
Pike River blast victims awarded compo

Pike River Coal Ltd, the mine owner, pleaded guilty to nine charges and was fined $760,000.

Whittall offered to make a voluntary payment of $3.41 million from his insurer if Worksafe did not offer any evidence against him. The court ordered the reparation. 

The families and two survivors received payments.

Osborne said earlier the families had no say in whether to accept or reject the $3.4m, which amounted to $110,000 per family.

She previously called it "blood money".

Ad Feedback

The Court of Appeal upheld a High Court decision to reject the judicial review in February. It found the decision by Worksafe was "lawfully made".

"As a matter of law, the prosecutor was entitled to consider and give weight to a conditional reparation undertaking as one factor in deciding whether or not to pursue the prosecution further," the Court of Appeal said.  

However, a Supreme Court judgment, released on Monday, granted the families leave to challenge the decision to the Supreme Court.

Lawyer Nigel Hampton QC, who represents Osborne and Rockhouse, said they would argue in the Supreme Court the payment to families was an "unlawful bargain", not "just a voluntary payment". 

"Historically you should not be able to pay money or have money paid on your behalf to have a prosecution dismissed," he said. 

Hampton expected the matter to be heard in the Supreme Court later this year.

 

 

 

 

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Schools go 'water-only'

Charlie, 5, and Jack, 8, make sure they take a full water bottle to school every day.

Two Auckland schools ban sugary drinks and adopt 'water-only' policy.

Botox is sooo last year, sweetie

The 24 carat gold facial luxury facial is growing in demand.

Golf is out, and 24-carat gold facials and McLarens are in for our local super-rich.

Kids wait to see psychiatrists

One-hundred and eight children under 12 had to wait more than eight weeks to be seen by a Waitemata DHB mental health ...

Hundreds of children in Auckland's north and west are waiting months to see psychiatrists, as the service comes under pressure.

Preventing the preventable

Christie Marceau's inquest concluded this week at the Auckland District Court.

OPINION: The one thing the Christie Marceau inquest never heard was the one thing which should be said - "sorry, we got it wrong".

Wellington

Yacht found, crew safe

Roger Foley, left, confirmed Havana Coffee's Geoff Marsland, right, was on the yacht.

Air Force spots Wellingtonians missing "miles from land in the open ocean".

Barred from rest home

A Hastings woman has been trespassed from her mother's rest home. (file photo)

Woman says she's been deprived of time with her mum, which she can never get back.

Flying doctor? Must be a man

Jetstar says a system error meant a doctor's gender was automatically selected as male.

Female doctor furious after Jetstar booking system assumes all doctors are men.

Daughter's bill to parents soars

Colleen Warin was ordered to pay her parents $367,000, now topped off with nearly $14,000 legal costs.

Colleen Warin's $367,000 debt to her parents has increased by $14,000 thanks to a new court order.

Canterbury

Cancer 'shaped me as a person'

23062017 Photo: John Kirk-Anderson/FAIRFAX NZ

Jonny Schwass, Christchurch chef and restaurateur and cancer survivor.

The Cancer Society Ball is personal for prominent Christchurch chef Jonny Schwass.

New job offers hope video

Conan McLennan, pictured with 11-month old Paityn, has been struggling to care for his two children, without a job.

When a rare illness struck his ex-partner, Conan McLennan became a full-time dad. But finances were tight.

Quake advocate accused of fraud

Christchurch manager of WorldClaim NZ Guy Sayers has been ordered to surrender his passport.

Guy Sayers allegedly pushed WorldClaim clients to invest in a Ponzi scheme.

One dead in SH1 crash

One person has died and four are injured after two cars collided on SH1 north of Dunedin on Friday evening.

Two cars crashed north of Dunedin, leaving one dead and two critically injured. 

Waikato

Razor-laced balls at dog park

Heather Gowans often throws a tennis ball for her dog at Day's Park and is horrified Peppa could have bitten into one of ...

Tennis balls containing razor blades have been found in popular Hamilton dog park.

Fraudster stole $1.9m

Tessa Grant at a court appearance in 2016.

Tessa Grant lived it up on stolen funds, but that luxury lifestyle has come to a crashing halt.

What a winning streak

The $27.3 million winning Lotto and Powerball ticket was bought at the Four Square in Thames owned by Sukhpal Singh.

Six $1m-winning Lotto tickets have been sold in the Waikato in as many weeks.

Teen dies at work

A man who died after a work place accident at Torpedo7 on Wednesday has been named (file).

Teenager Jacob Woods was killed while working at a Hamilton distribution centre.

Taranaki

Word to your mother

21062017 News Photo ANDY JACKSON/Fairfax NZ.   Brittany Bourgoise runs her own nail technician business from home.  Kids ...

Brittany Bourgoise is a mumpreneur and reckons other mothers can become one too.

Activist joins council

Environmental activist Emily Bailey has been appointed as an iwi representative to the regional council policy and ...

Former Urewera raids activist looking forward to being part of making decisions on regional council

Marae dream over

The initial design of the Ngamotu Marae, which was to be located on Ocean View Pde site, was to cost $4.5 million and ...

Theft linked to scrapping of $4.5 million New Plymouth marae proposal.

A man and his kereru

Kereru like to flock but are usually only seen in ones and twos.

OPINION: Sometimes you get what you want and it just isn't enough.

Manawatu

Kiwi injured in London

Manawatu man Joel Perry is recovering in hospital after an assault and mugging while on his way home in London.

A vicious attack on a New Zealand tourist has left him in hospital and struggling to get home.

Woman's web of lies

Nakita Sue will serve six months' home detention.

Woman stole man's life savings with sob stories and threats to post nude pics.

No more limits

Cameron Holland, 20, had a brain injury after a car crash when he was 11.

A double blow robbed him of his father and gave him a serious brain injury.

Food or the doctor?

A visit to your doctor will cost the same whether you have a community services card or not.

Community services cards are pointless, critics say, as health costs cripple.

Nelson

Doughnuts selling like hot cakes

Josiah Smits of the Smoking Barrel Cafe and Restaurant with some of his famous donuts at his High St, Motueka business.

A Motueka cafe is struggling to meet demand for its syringe-injected gourmet doughnuts.

Greens target Nelson

Nick Smith has held the Nelson seat for 21 years.

The Green Party is campaigning to break Nick Smith's 21-year grip on Nelson.

Meet the Kiwi helping Oracle

Boat Build Manager Tim Smyth with the saw blade used by the giant CNC Milling machine  used on America's Cup yacht Oracle.

If Oracle turn it round to beat Team NZ, it will be thanks in part to a boat builder from Nelson.

Acting chief's pay confirmed

David Hammond has been appointed acting chief executive for the Nelson City Council.

Interim NCC chief executive David Hammond will take on the role from June 26.

Marlborough

Diarrhoea outbreak closes pool

Marlborough Lines Stadium 2000 will be closed for several days while it is tested for the parasite.

Seven swimmers have fallen ill after using a public pool in Blenheim.

Beached on an atoll

Havana Coffee's Geoff Marsland, right, was on the yacht.

The crew aboard a badly damaged yacht in the Pacific Ocean have been found alive and well.

Hunting the 'Kiwi way'

The Gunshack Blenheim owner Peter Watson says hunters are being left with fewer places to shoot because of poachers.

Poachers, and even some young hunters, have "no respect for anyone or anything, not even the animals they're hunting".

Once bitten, not shy

The Employment Relations Authority has penalised KRSVP Limited $25,000 for failing to keep proper employment records.

Marlborough vineyard contractor stung for the same employment breach twice in two years.

South Canterbury

Clone sought for vet practice video

Stepping back after 40 years at the Veterinary Centre Waimate is vet Dougall McLachlan.

Dougall McLachlan's colleagues want his last pair of work gumboots to last a very long time.

RSA restructure looms

South Canterbury Returned and Services' Association president Greg O'Brien.

Restructure looms as South Canterbury RSA tries to improve its financial situation.

$1.1m for new lights

Netcon chief executive Steve McCoy with an LED light of the type his company has already installed in Temuka. The Timaru ...

Work to replace Timaru's street lights can start next month thanks to boost.

Timaru top choice for graduates

Registered medical officer Samantha Warhurst said she went back to work in South Canterbury because of how much she had ...

More than 200 new doctors pick Timaru Hospital for first job.

Southland

Young performers face the music

Monique Clementson (Deloris), Annie Sherborne, and Rachael Scott (Sister Mary Patrick) at rehearsals for the ...

Young performers are gaining exposure and touring the country for Sister Act the musical.

Arrested after threats

08072016 Newsphoto. SIMON MAUDE / FAIRFAX NZ. Generic, stock, NZ Police, police car, The po po, police. 08-N-policeC

A 54-year-old man was arrested after threatening Work and Income staff.

Father 'evil', grief-stricken mum says

Police staff at the Riverton home where three-month-old Honour Ashworth was injured.

Grieving Southland mother says her soul was "ripped to pieces" when she found out her partner caused her infant son's death.

Green Party takes off

Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand Invercargill candidate Rochelle Surendran speaks at a Green Party Launch in Invercargill.

Green Party co-leader comments on Clutha-Southland MP resignation during Invercargill visit.

Ad Feedback