Report finds safety testing flaws before tuk-tuk crash that injured six people in Wellington

The report into a tuk-tuk crash in Wellington in December, which injured six people, shows the canopy collapsed on ...

The report into a tuk-tuk crash in Wellington in December, which injured six people, shows the canopy collapsed on impact, endangering passengers.

A report into a tuk-tuk crash in Wellington late last year has revealed safety testing flaws put passengers at risk, and probably led to the injuries suffered by six people on board.

The $30,000 investigation into the crash, on Wellington's steep and winding Roseneath Tce in December, was commissioned by the New Zealand Transport Agency after its inspection of the tuk-tuk following the incident raised concerns about its stability and "rollover" strength.

According to the report, obtained under the Official Information Act, five passengers suffered head and facial injuries in the accident, including concussion, cuts and bruises, which required emergency medical care or hospital treatment.

The front right side of the tuk-tuk was significantly damaged.

The front right side of the tuk-tuk was significantly damaged.

The report says the vehicle's metal canopy offered "little to no resistance" to the crash, and its supporting pillars also failed to withstand the impact.

Tuk-tuk licences revoked after Wellington crash investigation
Tuk-tuk tours on hold after crash injures six
Tuk-tuk rolls in Roseneath hills

Tuk-tuks were certified as passenger service vehicles in September, and operated in Wellington and Auckland until they were taken off the roads in February.

The toppled tuk-tuk at the crash scene, in Roseneath Tce, Wellington.

The toppled tuk-tuk at the crash scene, in Roseneath Tce, Wellington.

The report, signed off in January, shows the vehicles were incorrectly given safety certificates and, had the issues been addressed, "the level of injuries would likely have been reduced".

"The condition of the vehicle does not meet the expected behaviour of a rollover frame; the vehicle structure has failed to provide reasonable protection to occupants."


The canopy was not able to withstand the impact of the crash, instead buckling and collapsing.

The canopy was not able to withstand the impact of the crash, instead buckling and collapsing.

NZTA hired Palmerston North-based company Sandbox Consulting to investigate the tuk-tuk's performance in the crash and, subsequently, to recommend design changes to improve the vehicles' stability.

Ad Feedback

According to the report, the error occurred because shortcuts were taken during safety testing that deemed the tuk-tuks to be roadworthy.

NZTA rules require a passenger service vehicle to be able to withstand an impact, at its highest corner, of half its maximum weight from side-on and total unladen weight from above, without sustaining permanent damage.

Police officers tend to injured occupants of the tuk-tuk. Skid marks can also be seen on the road.

Police officers tend to injured occupants of the tuk-tuk. Skid marks can also be seen on the road.

The independent engineer who issued the safety certificates for the vehicles operated in Wellington by Tuk Tuk Cartel erred by assuming the three-wheeled tuk-tuks would absorb the impact in the same way as heavy vehicles, such as buses, the report says.

The incorrect method was used for "expediency", when a separate analysis should have been carried out.

Unlike a heavy vehicle, the tuk-tuks would be unlikely to evenly distribute the force of any impact, making the front more vulnerable should it hit the ground and potentially "leading to failure".

The report also finds the steel canopy did not qualify as a rigid structure, as is assumed of heavy vehicles.

The police serious crash unit investigated the accident and deemed neither the driver nor Tuk Tuk Cartel was at fault.

Glen Varcoe, who set up Tuk Tuk Cartel with his brother Jeremy Marr, said the report appeared "interesting", and he would take a couple of days to consider it before commenting further.

NZTA said on Monday that the independent engineer involved was currently being investigated by the Institution of Professional Engineers.

He was issuing safety certificates as "a suitable qualified person", an NZTA spokeswoman said, but was not an NZTA appointee.

"Because there is an ongoing investigation, the Transport Agency is not able to comment on the circumstances that resulted in the vehicles being deemed compliant with PSV requirements.

"All Transport Agency-appointed independent vehicle certifiers are subject to performance monitoring and auditing by the agency with respect to certifications carried out under those appointments."

She added: "The process used for certifying the vehicles as passenger service vehicles was the correct one, but the crash investigation by the NZTA has indicated that the vehicles did not comply with the relevant technical requirements of the passenger service vehicle rule."


New testing criteria has been introduced to assess the stability of three-wheeled vehicles before they are issued with a certificate of fitness.

The testing will ensure "real-world stability" similar to that of a four-wheeled vehicle, and includes a raft of engineering calculations. 

It was unclear whether the necessary improvements could be made to tuk-tuks to bring them to an acceptable safety level, the report said.

NZTA said it was up to tuk-tuk operators to decide if they wanted to reapply for an operating licence if and when they were deemed roadworthy.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers

Power cut to 5,000 Auckland homes

The cause of the outage isn't yet known.

Households were affected from Mt Wellington to St Heliers.

Gunman 'likely dead' video

A house reportedly belonging to the gunman could be seen on fire from outside the cordon.

Police say gunman who shot dead two women in rural Northland is "very unlikely" to have survived after house went up in flames.

Seizures and deaths escalate video

Police seized 50 synthetic cannabis bags from a Ranui, west Auckland address earlier this week.

As an eight person dies related to synthetic cannabis use, police reveal large drug seizures.

Auckland rugby pivot heads south

Ponsonby's Willie Talataina-Mu will play rugby for Southland in 2017, pictured doing chin-ups at the The Mike Piper ...

From Ponsonby to Invercargill for one of Auckland's top club rugby's top points scorers.


Step back in 'Horn time

Mary Tresch, a Swiss immigrant, started the iconic Matterhorn restaurant in Cuba st which is due to close after 54 years.

Mary Tresch remembers opening Wellington's Matterhorn, which was this week told it must close.

Reinsurer's warning

Cinema company Reading International got a $27.5 million insurance payout for quake damage to the Courtenay Central ...

Quake cover may become more expensive and harder to get, reinsurer says.

Caught twice in a week

Caught drunk driving twice in a week he was both times more than four times the legal limit.

Driver caught more than five times over the limit was on his way to get more booze.

Council under 'urgent' investigation

Wellington City Council is being investigated by the Ombudsman over its failure to release information on the ...

Ombudsman probing Wellington City Council's refusal to release Shelly Bay info.


New look likely for Sq

06052015 News Photo: John Kirk-Anderson/FairfaxNZ
Cathedral Square from Novotel Hotel looking west over Convention ...

Bold ideas for a new-look Cathedral Square in central Christchurch are expected to be unveiled next week.

Officer threatened

A Westport house is surrounded by police after a man threatened to shoot an officer on Wednesday. (File photo)

Armed police surrounded house near Westport after man threatened to shoot cop.

The last person to see Michael

David Benbow outside his house in Halswell on Wednesday.

Prison guard at the centre of the missing builder inquiry has talked about when he last saw him.

More rain, snow ahead

The Heathcote River in flood on Saturday. More rain is expected in Christchurch.

Repeated storms are part of a bigger weather pattern that is not letting up yet, forecasters say.


No sea, no problem for cup visit video

Team New Zealand boss Grant Dalton with year eight student Daniel Over, 14.

Grant Dalton stopped by on Wednesday to share the success with a Te Kauwhata school.

Creepy cop's betrayal

Sergeant Gregory David Waters, 53, appeared in Hamilton District Court on Wednesday after earlier being found guilty by ...

The police sergeant was there to teach self-defence but he indecently assaulted a vulnerable woman.

Waikato DHB boss a no-show

Waikato DHB chairman Bob Simcock is disappointed a "confidential human resource issue" was leaked to the media.

Waikato health boss goes on leave as questions remain over spending habits.

Driving eases family's struggle

Anita Annan, 4, suffers from a progressive illness affecting her nervous system.

When you're dealt a heart-breaking hand, sometimes little things make a big difference.


Saved with minutes to spare

The Taranaki Rescue Helicopter Trust rescued two people who fell on Mt Taranaki on Tuesday.

Two tourists are alive because of a huge team effort to rescue them on Mt Taranaki.

Ombudsman weighs in

Lee Hurley's complaint about New Zealand Transport Agency delays in processing his service provider application is being ...

Driving trainer says he wants $100,000 compensation from Government department.

Digital doctor double-up

A week ago Patea had no doctor. Now there's two digital doctor services open.

Patea now has two virtual services offering medical help while the hunt for new GPs carries on.

Maori Land Court date for hapu

A hearing in the Maori Land Court will be held on August 10, involving the Ngati Te Whiti Whenua Topu Trust.

Ngati Te Whiti hapu members will appear before a Maori Land Court judge next month.


Crash metres from Plaza

Two cars crashed at a busy intersection outside the front doors of The Plaza on Wednesday afternoon.

Afternoon traffic disrupted by fender bender in Palmerston North.

Gorge health concerns

Another slip fell on the already-closed Manawatu Gorge road at the weekend.

As the ambulances drive over the top of the cliff, patients have to wait longer.

Closure an opportunity

The Manawatu Gorge is closed indefinitely.

A "significantly more resilient route" is expected if the gorge never reopens.

Privacy complaints over emails

Christine Toms is disappointed her emails were being intercepted by Horowhenua District Council's chief executive.

Under-fire Horowhenua council could face privacy probe.


10 underrated NZ towns

Paeroa should be world famous in NZ for more than L&P.

Motueka and Murchison feature on a list of towns worth your while.

Dying man fulfills wish

Doug Murcott and Sally Tolliday on their wedding day at the Nelson Tasman Hospice.

Doug Murcott loses his fight with cancer days after fulfilling his wish to marry his partner.

New direct flight route

Originair will offer direct flights between New Plymouth and Nelson from late-September.

Nelson and New Plymouth are to have a direct air link.

Anatomy of a shooting

Ford Hurinui who was shot by Police in Motueka on August 20, 2015.

Holding a shotgun and surrounded by police Ford Hurinui was "prepared to die".


Scoring a bullseye

Despite badly injuring her hand six months ago Shannon Campbell has been selected to play at the Australasian Championships.

A darts player left with a horrific injury to her hand has beaten the odds to become one of New Zealand's top players.

Cycle trail will happen - advocate

A cycleway will run along the edge of this damaged stretch of SH1, just south of Ohau Point, as part of $231 million of ...

Government chips in to build stretch around Ohau Point, deemed the most difficult section.

Time to fix 'scary' highway

The section of State Highway 6 from Okaramio to Havelock is the most dangerous stretch on the Blenheim to Nelson road, ...

The road from Blenheim to Nelson has claimed 12 lives in 10 years. Now it's a priority.

Boat ramp back in action

Now the slipway has been excavated, it takes the Coastguard boat Kaikoura Rescue half the time to respond to an emergency.

Eight months post-quake and the Coastguard Kaikoura ramp at South Bay has been officially re-opened.

South Canterbury

More rain and snow on way

Federated Farmers meat and fibre president Miles Anderson has advised farmers to be prepared for the predicted bad weather.

Farming leader questions how much more rain water-logged soil can handle.

Infected cows must go

Labour spokesman for primary industries Damien O'Connor is calling for all the cows on the property where Mycoplasma ...

The 150 stricken cattle on a South Canterbury farm should be put down, MP says.

Luxton to meet with ECan

Rangitata Labour Party candidate Jo Luxton.

Labour candidate to push ahead with efforts to have ECan change woodburner policies.

Council hotly denies claims

A smoky chimney in Timaru.

ECan shoots down claim by former policeman it could be caught by peeping tom rule.


Resident wants to beautify wharf

Bluff resident Cherie Chapman stands near the closed Bluff Wharf which she wants to see it beautified and made open to ...

Bluff resident Cherie Chapman has put her case to the Bluff Community Board to restore the old Bluff wharf and return it to the public.

Let sleeping seals lie

The seal is believed to have travelled up the nearby Waiau river, and was found about 10kms from the sea.

DOC is asking the public to trust its judgement when it comes to dealing with wild animals.

MPI proposing changes

10082016. News.Kavinda Herath. Southland Times/FairfaxNZ-Uplift of oysters to tanker in  Big Glory Bay, Stewart Island today

MPI is hosting a public meeting about proposed changes to the aquaculture industry.

Coroner reminds hunters of gun safety after death

Cromwell man Garry Tall, 61, was killed in a hunting accident on the Old Woman Range in March 2016.

Cromwell man Garry Tall was an experienced hunter but on March 3, 2016, he died after shooting himself in the stomach after a hunt.

Ad Feedback