Concerns raised about email interception at Horowhenua District Council

Horowhenua District Council is under fire for its email blocking processes, affecting residents and politicians.
WARWICK SMITH/STUFF

Horowhenua District Council is under fire for its email blocking processes, affecting residents and politicians.

A council that intercepted and blocked politicians' emails engaged in "extremely high-risk" practices, a leaked report says.

The Horowhenua District Council practices were identified in a draft report by an internal auditor that has been leaked to media and members of the public. 

The report shows processes to block some emails going out and coming in, as well as a "blacklist" of external emailers. 

Emails from Horowhenua mayor Michael Feyen have been blocked by his council.
WARWICK SMITH/STUFF

Emails from Horowhenua mayor Michael Feyen have been blocked by his council.

Emails from blocked addresses were intercepted to be screened by chief executive David Clapperton. He then chose to block emails, redirect them, or let them continue to their intended destinations.

Blocked email addresses include one for mayor Michael Feyen, an iwi representative, a ratepayers' association representative, a councillor, and a former councillor.

When Brendan Duffy was still mayor, he and Joann Ransom, former chief executive of the trust that runs the Te Takere library complex, were blocked from emailing each other.

Horowhenua District Council chief executive David Clapperton, right, with former mayor Brendan Duffy, in 2014.
FAITH SUTHERLAND/STUFF

Horowhenua District Council chief executive David Clapperton, right, with former mayor Brendan Duffy, in 2014.

An email with questions from a Fairfax reporter to Feyen was among those reproduced in the report about blocking. 

It is not known when the practices started, but the report notes they were already in use in May 2015.

Council staff and Clapperton did not answer questions about the practices, but he said it was "necessary to protect my employees so they can carry out their roles safely without undue interference, inappropriate criticism, and racist slurs".

A council communications staff member said the audit draft "was not up to standard", was not accepted by the council and would not be officially released. A review of it was being completed by KPMG, but it was not clear when this would be completed and a request for it was not answered. 

Ad Feedback

Mayor Michael Feyen said the interception was worrying and needed to be looked into thoroughly. He was also concerned the draft report was only released to him after months of "back and forth" with staff.

He did not know who leaked it, but said Clapperton had accused him of being the leak's source and demanded his resignation because of it. Clapperton did not respond to questions about this.

Feyen said he was told in his previous term that his emails to council staff would be vetted because of claims he had been disrespectful to them. He disputes any rudeness, and said he never dreamed the interception could also include emails to him, or emails to people or organisations outside the council.

Nothing happened when he reported the email system was glitchy, and in 2015 he began using a private email address for official correspondence because of "niggles" that something was not quite right. 

"I always worried about my emails, but I just thought it was a really crap [IT] system. It really upsets me that when I took time to put in hours of thought and time to send [emails, that they might not even get anywhere].

"I want a council that works transparently for the people, and in a transparent way. Why on earth would a CE and staff withhold a document like that from their mayor?"

Councillor Ross Campbell is on the blacklist, and also did not believe he had previously been disrespectful in emails. It was possible hundreds of people's emails had been intercepted, he said. 

Residents had told him they felt the interception was both a breach of trust and an invasion of privacy, and he questioned its legality. 

His wife Janette Campbell represents several community organisations in Shannon, and was furious to learn from the draft report that her emails had been blocked, he said.  

 The council claimed in a media release that when an email was blocked an automatic reply would bounce back to senders, telling them the email was redirected. However, Campbell said he and his wife had never received this. 

Finance, audit and risk sub-committee chairman Philip Jones, who is not a councillor, said the release of the draft report had the potential to expose "ratepayers of Horowhenua to additional risk, including possible legal action".  

Deputy mayor Wayne Bishop said he had not read the draft report, but planned to read the KPMG version.

"It's not right for us to comment until we read the final report."

A spokeswoman for the Office of the Ombudsman said the Chief Ombudsman planned to seek more information from  the council to determine if the issue warranted a formal investigation. 

 

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Sport: Ten in starting XV

Auckland and Aorere College No.8 Glory Aiono was named player of the tournament at the combined Blues/Chiefs regional ...

South Auckland players dominate the champion Auckland under-15 girls' rugby team. South Auckland players dominate the Auckland's champion under-15 girls' rugby team.

Winning ticket kept under pillow

The Auckland woman knows exactly what she's going to do with the money.

Powerball's latest millionaire spent a restless night waiting to claim her $8 million Lotto prize.

Writing improves overnight

Northcross Intermediate principal Jonathan Treadway said marking writing was subjective.

A new method of teaching writing has seen achievement rise at one Auckland intermediate school

Blank round fired in court

Gustav Sanft is on trial for the manslaughter of his two-year-old daughter.

Gustav Sanft wailed in court as the sawn-off shotgun which killed his two-year-old daughter was fired as evidence.

Wellington

Sports fields turn to mudbaths

Wellington City Council may be forced to close some of the city's traditional grass sports fields, or restrict play on ...

All Wellington's grass sports fields are closed, with many now "sodden bogs".

Porirua rates shock 

The hilltop suburb of Camborne, overlooking Pauatahanui Inlet, has had the highest average rates increase in Porirua ...

Many residents have been flabbergasted by double-digit increases on their bills.

'Always challenge parking tickets'

Consumers should challenge "unreasonable" parking tickets,  Consumer NZ advises.

Pay what's reasonable and let them chase you for the rest, says Consumer NZ.

Matterhorn bar to close

Matterhorn restaurant has called Cuba St home for 54 years.

Wellington bar will have to shut so old Farmers building can be strengthened.

Canterbury

Going blind with no warning

Andy Dickerson says he's "very lucky" an eye exam revealed he had glaucoma - before he went blind.

Andy Dickerson had no symptoms, no family history, and good eyesight – but he was going blind.

Rebuilds years late

Construction continues at Waltham School. The school's redevelopment was meant to be completed last year.

Education Ministry says all on schedule to finish in 2022, but just 12 of the 115 rebuilds are complete so far.

Assault ends career

The relief teacher grabbed the boy's backpack, but the strap broke and the boy fell between closing doors.

Teacher grabbed 12-year-old's backpack for a word, but the strap broke and the boy fell.

Sheep to the rescue

Rabbits catch a ride out of floodwaters on a flock of sheep on a Taieri Plains farm.

A small colony of rabbits rode a flock of sheep to safety from the floodwaters in Otago.

Waikato

Storm set to roll in from Tasman

A brief respite from rain won't last long, with more forecast towards the end of the week.

Heavy rain and possible thunderstorms on horizon before cracker weekend.

Brother's final minutes

Anthony Hallmond died on Sunday night after what was believed to be an altercation on a Te Awamutu street.

Family arrived to find paramedics trying to revive Anthony Hallmond on a Te Awamutu street.

ACC U-turn on glasses

Hamilton man Glenn Hodges' eyesight was damaged following a crash at Hampton Downs Motorsport Park in December.

After an eight-month battle, motoring enthusiast Glenn Hodges has scored a win.

Outrage over skids on cemetery

Skid marks from vandals are all that remain at the Ngaruawahia Cemetery

The Ngaruawahia Cemetery has been targeted three times since June by drivers skidding on the grass.

Taranaki

Protecting Taranaki's historic bridge

A cyclist has absolutely no problems with the new width restrictions at the Bertrand Rd suspension bridge.

"It's not something that you need to race over anyway, just take your time."

Couple rescued 

The Taranaki Rescue Helicopter was able to get to the couple in time before the cloud came in. (File Photo)

If the helicopter hadn't reached the injured German couple, it would have meant an extra six hours stuck on Mt Taranaki.

Man attacked abuser

On Monday in the New Plymouth District Court, a man avoided convictions for burglary and assault, after a successful ...

After he was taken advantage of while drunk, a man sought retribution against his abuser.

Agency in liquidation

Liquidators were able to recover fees from a failed debt collection business.

High Court gives liquidator permission to recover fees but customers owed almost $200,000 will miss out.

Manawatu

America's Cup secret weapon

Palmerston North's secret weapon in the America's Cup racing Ryan Thomas.

Engineer Ryan Thomas was programming machinery for factories when he was discovered.

New gorge route likely

A third slip fell on the already-closed Manawatu Gorge road this weekend.

Rocky old road could remain closed as officials turn their attention elsewhere.

House prices spike

Feilding's Smeaton family sold their home in just eight days. From back left: David holding Evie, 1, and Hayley holding ...

House sales prices in Feilding are at a 20-year high but that hasn't stopped them selling fast.

When rural pests invade the city

A possum trapped.

UNDER THE RADAR: What to do if you live in suburbia and spot a stoat or possum.

Nelson

New plan to save grandstand

The fight goes on to save the grandstand.

It all looked done and dusted for Takaka's grandstand. But could it get a last gasp reprieve?

Shooting 'justified'

The shooting of Ford Hurinui, by police during an alleged armed standoff in Motueka in 2015 was justified, an inquest ...

Nelson police officer who shot a wanted man cleared of any wrongdoing after inquest.

Time to fix 'scary' highway

The section of State Highway 6 from Okaramio to Havelock is the most dangerous stretch on the Blenheim to Nelson road, ...

The Nelson-Blenheim road has claimed 12 lives in 10 years. NZTA says it's unacceptable.

Judge's blunder boosts jail time

A woman convicted in the Nelson District Court earlier this year on drugs charges has had her sentence quashed and ...

Woman convicted of meth dealing will spend longer behind bars after a sentencing error.

Marlborough

Burglar caught by paper trail

The diamond ring was pawned at a Cash Converters in 2010. (File photo)

Seven years after burglar pawns diamond ring, police realise he gave Cash Converters his real name.

Picture perfect

Marlborough photographer Jessica Jones won four awards at the annual Iris Awards for professional photographers.

Professional photographer Jessica Jones impresses judges in one of New Zealand's most prestigious competitions.

Guerrilla knitters yarn-bomb town

West End retailers Stephanie Thompson and Jacqui Harnett are behind Kaikoura's yarn-bombing project.

Many a good yarn has come out of quake-hit Kaikoura over the past few months, and that doesn't seem to be wrapping up anytime soon.

Teen denies knifepoint robbery

Dylan Joseph Dredge admitted seven charges at the Blenheim District Court. (File photo)

He wasn't trying to rob the woman, he was just attacking her with a knife, court hears.

South Canterbury

Keeping culture alive

Ti Kouka Kindergarten children sang some of the waiata they will perform at the festival in front of Beaconsfield School ...

Hundreds of children are gearing up for events designed to help keep Maori culture alive in South Canterbury.

Disease reaches NZ

Cows on a South Canterbury farm have been found infected with the disease Mycoplasma bovis, the first time it has been ...

A highly contagious cattle disease has infected a South Canterbury dairy herd in the first recorded case in NZ.

Insurers face expensive year

The Plains Irrigators business in Washdyke was flooded on Friday. Technician Theo Joubert looks at the mud.

Flooding expected to generate about 2000 claims nationwide, adding to expensive year for insurers after two cyclones and the "Tasman Tempest".

New burner rule pitched

The warm glow of a good log fire: a residents' group says the resource consent process could keep older burners burning ...

Retrofitting old burners should be made official, group says.

Southland

ILT prank 'disappointing'

The "GET LIT" T-shirts are advertised on the Bunker Bar Facebook page.

Young people using the Invercargill Licensing Trust's logo to promote drinking is being called "disappointing".

Pedestrian hit by car

Emergency services were called to the intersection of Don and Kelvin streets, Invercargill, after an elderly pedestrian ...

An elderly man was struck by a car in central Invercargill.

Early start for Barclay

What exactly Barclay has been doing in his electorate has been in the spotlight as he continues to sit on a $170,000 ...

Disgraced MP arrives back at work with smile on his face.

Factory worker awarded $30,000

20082014   
Image ID : 21188809
Image Type : Stock Photo
Copyright : Matthew Benoit
attorney, auction, authority, brown, ...

An Invercargill factory worker has successfully claimed over $30,000 from his former employers, after being unjustifiably dismissed.

Ad Feedback