Councillors stand by under-fire chief executive embroiled in email snooping revelations

Horowhenua District Council chief executive David Clapperton, left, at the swearing-in ceremony of mayor Michael Feyen ...

Horowhenua District Council chief executive David Clapperton, left, at the swearing-in ceremony of mayor Michael Feyen last year. Relations are now seriously strained.

Horowhenua councillors are backing embattled council chief executive David Clapperton amid scrutiny of him snooping on emails.

Deputy mayor Wayne Bishop has responded to the council's latest tumult  by calling for mayor Michael Feyen's head, arguing he is to blame for the organisation's troubles.

But critics, including people who had their emails intercepted or blocked by Clapperton, said he had interfered in the democratic process, calling his behaviour "paranoid" and a breach of trust.

Horowhenua deputy mayor Wayne Bishop is blaming the council's struggles on mayor Michael Feyen.

Horowhenua deputy mayor Wayne Bishop is blaming the council's struggles on mayor Michael Feyen.

An internal draft audit leaked to media reveals the council boss blocked some email addresses and then screened emails sent to staff, as well as elected members. The conduct was labelled "extremely high risk", but the council says the draft is incomplete, "not up to standard" and should not have been made public.

Concerns raised about email interception at Horowhenua District Council

* Editorial: Clapperton's position is untenable

Blocked email addresses include one for Feyen, an iwi representative, a ratepayers' association representative, a councillor, and a former councillor.

In a statement, Bishop said nine out of 10 councillors reiterated their support for Clapperton, who had "repeatedly offered olive branches to work with and support the mayor". 

"My colleagues and I are only too well aware of the stress and strain council officers have been under during this triennium and, sadly, we expect it to continue under the current mayor's regime. Is it time for a by-election?"

On Tuesday, Bishop said the suggestion of a by-election was in reaction to what "a lot of people" were saying.

Time that senior management had spent on issues such as leaked reports could be better used on improving the district, he said. 

Ad Feedback

Councillor Victoria Kaye-Simmons said Feyen should have been aware as early as 2015 that some emails were being blocked as all councillors were copied into an email notification from Clapperton. 

Emails were being checked because of inappropriate and abusive content, Kaye-Simmons said. 

She supported Clapperton's move as she did not think council staff should have to cop abuse. 

Kaye-Simmons added that she "wouldn't mind" if Feyen resigned.

"I do think the mayor's doing a crappy job." 

Dr Catherine Strong, a former reporter and academic who specialises in freedom of speech, said censoring an elected politician's emails was "horrendous". 

"It slashes across the democratic tenet that councillors represent their community, not the district council corporation."

Council staff, especially CEOs, were known to share policies and procedures between different councils, so the "elephant in the room" now was how widespread the practice was, she said.

Feyen said he was relieved the emails controversy was now out in the open, and calling for a by-election would allow councillors to "sweep things under the carpet".

Cr Ross Brannigan said he did not think Feyen had the majority of the public behind him and the draft report should not be debated until it has been peer-reviewed. 

The report lists an email belonging to Ngati Whakatere spokesman Robert Ketu as among those blocked.

This was news to him, but if true he said it seriously undermined the council's relationship with iwi.

"That's shocking because I represent eight other hapu of Ngati Raukawa around the issues of cleanup of the Manawatu River, and we've had meetings with these people about issues like the Shannon Wastewater Treatment Plant. 

"What it means for me is that all this process of good faith and trust and honouring the Treaty of Waitangi has been breached, and we want some answers. I'm blown away."

Former chairwoman of the Ratepayers and Residents' Association Christine Toms' email is another listed as blocked. She said the practice was "paranoid behaviour".

Some blocked email addresses belonged to people involved in Feyen's election campaign, and another to a vocal supporter. 

"If we knew that these emails were intercepted, we wouldn't have continued to email [the] council," Toms said. 

"It's brought the Horowhenua District Council into reputational harm. It's done damage to the organisation. [Clapperton's] got to go."

Former mayor Brendan Duffy said he was aware to some degree of email blocking carried out by Clapperton during his term, but had not seen any offensive emails that prompted these decisions. 

"They were bad enough for the CEO to take action. I entirely support a CEO protecting his organisation as he saw fit." 


 - Stuff


Ad Feedback
special offers

EDITORIAL: Make your voice count

At the ballot.

EDITORIAL: If you've been driving around South Auckland lately, you will have noticed a colourful change to our streets.

Periodic table gets new look

Dr Nicola Gaston's emoji periodic table is a thing of beauty.

As far as scientific breakthroughs go, the emoji periodic table is up there with splitting the atom.

Gunman believed at large video

A bullet hole can be seen in the windscreen of a red 4x4 inside the cordon.

Police are hunting for a gunman after two people were feared shot dead and a third injured in Northland.

Someone yelled 'she's got a knife'

Anna Brown, 36, denies murdering Carly Stewart.

Witness says she could sense something was about to happen - seconds later her cousin lay dead.


Pedestrian hit in Lower Hutt

Ambulances and police at the scene of an accident at a Lower Hutt roundabout.

Pedestrian in hospital after being hit by car near a busy Lower Hutt intersection.

NZ not ready for Asia

The survey has raised concerns school-leavers might be missing out on opportunities coming as New Zealand grows closer ...

Many senior high school students have poor knowledge of Asia. What about you? Try our quiz.

Warrant issued for Napier beggar

A warrant to arrest Frank Lovich was issued by Judge Geoff Rea on Wednesday.

Man with more than 300 convictions fails to show in court

Concern for missing woman

Missing woman Tamzyn Whitehead, 41, last seen in central Waikanae.

A police search is underway for a woman last seen in Waikanae on the Kapiti Coast. 


Firewood queues for hours video

Adrian Allen loads firewood into his vehicle at City Firewood. He had a big load delivered after Christmas but has burnt ...

Hundreds of people queued for hours to buy firewood from Christchurch's largest supplier as harsh wintry continues loom.

Car dealer's road rage

Christchurch car dealer Nigel Thompson motors admitted assaulting a man after a collision, but escaped conviction "by a ...

He got angry after a crash, punched a man who told him to calm down, but avoided conviction by citing good works.

Snow crack clears ski area

Avalanche work was carried out at Broken River ski area after a crack was discovered in the snow pack.

Skiers were taken off a Canterbury skifield after a 30-metre crack ripped across the snow.

Rain, snow warning

Surface flooding in Christchurch on Friday. MetService says Canterbury will get "persistent" rain on Thursday.

Snow could hamper travel on alpine passes as a front moves up South Island.


Driving eases family's struggle

Anita Annan, 4, suffers from a progressive illness affecting her nervous system.

When you're dealt a heart-breaking hand, sometimes little things make a big difference.

House bought unseen

Post-auction celebrations continued into the evening after Donald Gordon (right) sold his unfinished house to Raglan ...

Raglan man who bought another man's unfinished dream house before seeing it was "blown away" when he did.

Pig's life of 'misery' revealed video

SAFE has now launched a petition calling for the government to stop mother pigs being confined to cages.

Campaigners say footage shows crates are cruel, expert says they save piglets.

Jury out in neck slashing trial

A High Court jury are considering their verdicts in the trial of Sameh Khalil Salem Ali, 42, who has been charged with ...

Both sides in the case of Sameh Ali have delivered their final arguments.


Pine trees turning red

Pine trees affected with red needle cast which has been seen in Taranaki

It may look like they're dying but these pine trees are just sick.

The best four

The Crusaders know how to work collectively to shut down opposition.

Crusaders should meet the Hurricanes in the Super Rugby final.

To Nelson, direct

Originair will offer direct flights between New Plymouth and Nelson from late-September.

Nelson and New Plymouth are to have a direct air link.

Learning to poach properly

Sauce is drizzled over the pears.

Most can poach an egg but the method of cooking is not used well in the kitchen, a teacher says.


They're yelling timber

Reclaimed Timber Traders boss Robert Scott amid a vast array of wood.

Palmerston North's Reclaimed Timber Traders loses its lease.

Closure an opportunity

The Manawatu Gorge is closed indefinitely.

A "significantly more resilient route" is expected in the likelihood the gorge will never reopen.

Horowhenua councillor cleared

Horowhenua councillor Ross Campbell is not in breach of his council's code of conduct, an investigation has found.

Under-fire chief executive "dulled" down findings, cleared Ross Campbell councillor claims.

Anzac wreaths cost police thousands

Police have traditionally laid wreaths at Anzac Day services, but they're cutting back on the practice in the Central ...

Taxpayers have forked out more than $30,000 for police to lay wreaths in the past three years.


Ex junior All Black fulfills wish

Doug Murcott and Sally Tolliday on their wedding day at the Nelson Tasman Hospice.

Doug Murcott loses his fight with throat cancer just days after fulfilling his dying wish to marry his partner.

Anatomy of a shooting

Ford Hurinui who was shot by Police in Motueka on August 20, 2015.

Holding a shotgun and surrounded by police Ford Hurinui was "prepared to die".

Robbery suspect found

Victory Discount Dairy manager Darshini Chauhan's store was robbed at gunpoint earlier this month.

A fourth man has been arrested over the armed robbery of a dairy in Victory, near Nelson, earlier this month.

Truck rolls near St Arnaud

Police are attending to a crash near St Arnaud.

Bridge closed while crane retrieves truck on Picton to Christchurch highway.


Abseilers on a mesh mission

Abseilers working at the top of a bluff at Ohau Point, with a view down to the Pacific Ocean.

Ohau Point is the only place roading contractors can't reach, but abseilers with a head for heights are working to change that.

Truck rolls on SH63

Police are attending to a crash near St Arnaud.

The alternate highway claims another truck, but luckily nobody was hurt.

Cycle trail will happen - advocate

A cycleway will run along the edge of this damaged stretch of SH1, just south of Ohau Point, as part of $231 million of ...

Government chips in to build stretch around Ohau Point, deemed the most difficult section.

Time to fix 'scary' highway

The section of State Highway 6 from Okaramio to Havelock is the most dangerous stretch on the Blenheim to Nelson road, ...

The road from Blenheim to Nelson has claimed 12 lives in 10 years. Now it's a priority.

South Canterbury

Celtic set to be best

Celtic are shooting for their ninth consecutive title. (From left) Matt Fetu, captain Nick Strachan and Kali Latu have ...

Celtic Rugby Club's golden run in grand finals could see them stand alone.

Infected cows must go

Labour spokesman for Primary Industries Damien O'Connor is calling for all the cows on the property where Mycoplasma ...

The 150 stricken cattle on a South Canterbury farm should be put down, MP says.

Council hotly denies claims

A smoky chimney in Timaru.

ECan shoots down claim by former policeman it could be caught by peeping tom rule.

Wilding conifer GPS welcomed

Wilding pines growing near the shore of Lake Pukaki.

New technology to help fight the spread of wilding conifers welcomed in South Canterbury.


Resident wants to beautify wharf

Bluff resident Cherie Chapman stands near the closed Bluff Wharf which she wants to see it beautified and made open to ...

Bluff resident Cherie Chapman has put her case to the Bluff Community Board to restore the old Bluff wharf and return it to the public.

Let sleeping seals lie

The seal is believed to have travelled up the nearby Waiau river, and was found about 10kms from the sea.

DOC is asking the public to trust its judgement when it comes to dealing with wild animals.

MPI proposing changes

10082016. News.Kavinda Herath. Southland Times/FairfaxNZ-Uplift of oysters to tanker in  Big Glory Bay, Stewart Island today

MPI is hosting a public meeting about proposed changes to the aquaculture industry.

Coroner reminds hunters of gun safety after death

Cromwell man Garry Tall, 61, was killed in a hunting accident on the Old Woman Range in March 2016.

Cromwell man Garry Tall was an experienced hunter but on March 3, 2016, he died after shooting himself in the stomach after a hunt.

Ad Feedback