Cheating 'rampant' thanks to NCEA, former teacher says

NCEA standards are so poorly defined they should not be called standards.

NCEA standards are so poorly defined they should not be called standards.

"Never before have so many done so well for so long, yet learnt so little."

This is the product of our present examination system, used in all state, and some private, secondary schools. It's in turmoil, yet the powers that be do not have the intellect to recognise this.

It is the only system in the world where you can be a "straight-A student", yet be below average.

Your news and views

Share your stories, photos and videos.

Cheating - or at best, bending the rules - is rampant. This was inevitable; both teachers and schools have significant pressure put upon them to pass students.

* Check out Stuff's School Report interactive
* Constant NCEA testing making secondary school students anxious
* 'NZQA taught students nothing'
* Teachers, students outraged over difficult algebra exam

There are many students who are passing standards they would not have passed under the previous system. The tragedy is they have passed and learnt less.

While this may not be true for all subjects, it is certainly true for some of the more academic subjects. One of these that I have significant knowledge of is mathematics.

It is now possible for a student to pass an external standard, such as last year's Level One algebra, with a mark of 18 per cent. And, yes, they still scale grades! But it is now hidden, which is why last year's Level One algebra results seemed a little better than 2015, when it was actually a more difficult paper.

Students have told me that even though they gained a grade of 'M', they know they got most of the paper wrong.

The standards are so poorly defined they should not be called standards. If you took 10 independent teachers to write an assessment for a particular standard, you would get considerable variations in the degree of difficulty in the paper and hence the pass rates.

Ad Feedback

Even if the papers were similar, the assessment conditions such as how long students had, how close the practice assessment was to the real one, whether they were allowed a resubmission and whether they got help during the assessment would lead to different pass rates.

Initially the pass rates for internal and external standards were supposed to be similar. Now teachers are expected to get at least 85 per cent of students through the internals. We are doing this not by teaching our students more or better, but by making the tests easier and teaching them less.

For example, the Year 13 statistics course now has about 60 per cent less content and a lower difficulty level than it did 30 years ago. We no longer teach the central limit theorem which is fundamental to elementary statistics and to the understanding of averages.

It is now possible for a student to pass numeracy without doing a mathematics course in Level One. With this, they could go on to be a primary teacher, for which the minimum level used to be UE mathematics. No wonder the secondary intake is slowly getting worse at mathematics. There are a significant number of students - 10 to 20 per cent - who are obtaining "numeracy" without sufficient numeracy skills to cope with the outside world.

The method of marking in mathematics is fundamentally stupid, and I am ashamed to have been part of it in my teaching career. It is very difficult, if not impossible, to have consistency with the grade boundaries. It is also very common for two students to have the same grade yet have significantly differing ability.

Many students are satisfied with a grade of 'A' and choose courses with mostly internal standards as they know that these are much easier to pass. They also choose subjects that are easier, as now all subjects have the same weighting, even though this does not reflect the real world. Remember, an 'A' grade can mean a percentage from 20 to 60 per cent, such is the inaccuracy of our marking system.

If an examination system is good then eventually it works its way around the world, as do most clever ideas. This has not happened with our system; indeed, Britain, which had a similar system, is going back to external assessment for the very reasons I have outlined above.

Our system needs a thorough overhaul by people who have the capacity and knowledge to do it. This is critical and it needs to be done now. I, for one, would love to be part of this process.

* Roy Perrin is a former mathematics teacher at Pukekohe High School.

* Comments on this article have been closed.

 - Stuff Nation


Ad Feedback
special offers

Event encourages women to surf

The events take place at Omaha Beach.

Event encourages women to surf

Hundreds run the Millwater Parkrun

Millwater Parkrun is a weekly free timed 5km run.

The Millwater community got together to celebrate Parkrun's birthday.

Dangers Larger breaks New Zealand records

Dangers Larger breaks records.

"It's not flavoured water like your lower end cheaper beers and it's not too hoppy like some of the craft beers out there, it's just right."

'It's horrible out there'

'Comatose' addicts in a town centre is sparking concern.

A public meeting is called in west Auckland to confront synthetic drug use.


Gorge options discussed

The 13 alternative route options are available for public viewing and comment on the NZTA website.

Thirteen alternative routes to the Manawatū Gorge have been laid out for the public to discuss.

SH2 closed after slip

Rimutaka Hill Road is closed due to a large slip.

Delays for motorists north of Wellington following large slip on State Highway 2.

Winter leaves hospitals stretched

Wellington Regional Hospital's emergency department witnessed a surge in patient demand over winter. (File photo)

High GP costs could help explain soaring ED admissions in the capital over winter, researcher says.

Fire victim 'fun-loving, caring man'

Zdenek Hanzlik died after an incident on parliament grounds. (File photo)

Man who died after a fire on parliament grounds has been named by police.


Fight to stay in the country video

Seamus Robertson with his fiancee, Pham Thu Thuong Nguyen, at his father's property in Eyrewell, where the couple have ...

Man faces having to leave his terminally ill father to be with the woman he loves after her visa was declined.

Two suspicious fires

Police are seeking information after two suspicious fires were lit in Christchurch overnight.

Police are investigating two suspicious fires in Christchurch overnight.

Dashed wedding turnaround

Central Otago Wedding Fair 'Dream Wedding' winners Ashleigh Sinclair and Jai Beck, of Clyde.

Couple who cancelled wedding after falling pregnant will still get to walk down the aisle.

'Gutted' memorial may be moved

Dunedin photographer Riley Baker with his partner, Amy McPherson. He died in hospital from injuries after a tourist ...

A crash victim's grieving family has been told their roadside memorial is "unfair to other families".


Helping hand through Hangman 

Kiwi MMA star Dan Hooker will help train fighters for the Hangman Challenge.

Dave Sawyer wants to help those "that are in a bad place" through his MMA event.

Huge egg farm plan

Mainland Poultry say their proposed new farm in North Waikato will be cage-free and cause "less than minor" disruption ...

A massive egg laying farm is proposed for North Waikato but not everyone is happy.

Bitter blow for Māori

Te Ururoa Flavell concedes to Tamati Coffey

OPINION: Te Ururoa Flavell and Marama Fox were truly independent voices but will no longer be heard

Fonterra 'fat cat' jibe

Theo Spierings and Winston Peters

The kingmaker Winston Peters slams the king of dairy's $8.32m pay packet.


Teens make blue cheese

Hāwera High School Students Maddison Hayes, 15, and Ivy Wall, 13, worked on the first stages of their blue cheese production.

And in five weeks they'll see who created the best one.

Blackmailer wants out

Blackmailer Jacob Kirby-Parker wants his jail sentence reduced to home detention.

Blackmailer Jacob Kirby-Parker threatened to send intimate pics of his teenage victim to her brother.

Powerful words for wāhine

Patea Area School students Tasiah Marino, Te Anahera Maraki, Maruata Cribb, IronMaori founder Heather Skipworth ...

Diversity is a cultural advantage, a Columbian-born entrepreneur says.

Heavy rain warning 

Rough weather has descended onto Taranaki as MetService issues severe weather watch. (View in New Plymouth and Hawera)

It's going to pour down and gale force northwest winds could batter the region today.


Two awards in one week

Heather Knox with co-founding Palmy Rocker Kate Parlane setting up August's "Palmy Rocks: We Are One" photo exhibition.

Palmy Rocks' Heather Knox would like council to have a comprehensive play policy

Fatal driving admitted

Josh McGinty, 17, died after the driver of the car he was in failed to give way at an intersection.

Restricted driver failing to give way results in the death of her passenger.

Cancer patient fighting to live video

Kerry McGrath wants to live her dream and travel the country in her house bus. But she needs some help to do so.

Kerry McGrath just wants to get to living in her gypsy house bus, cancer-free.

Manawatū Gorge: Your thoughts stuff nation

What should be done about the Manawatū Gorge?

We want to hear your thoughts, experiences and ideas about this beautiful, yet geologically unstable, landmark.


Farewell to kindly street 'godfather'

Ron Brinsdon, pictured in 2005, on his dawn can collection run in Hardy St. He was remembered as an intelligent and ...

Farewell to the Tin Man: a homeless man who touched many lives was described as an intelligent and caring man at his funeral.

Fire prompts reminder

The fire that took hold of a house in Washington Valley is thought to have started when embers were blown underneath the ...

Ceiling fire in Nelson a strong message about clean chimneys says Fire Service.

Robbery "look-out" pleads guilty

Jacob Harmon has admitted to playing a role in a recent armed robbery in Nelson.

Judge tells man who played "look out" for an armed robbery that jail time is likely.

Mayor's 'talk' over councillor's blog

Mayor Richard Kempthorne says no other action is planned over the blog.

Cr Dean McNamara gets a talk from Tasman mayor over allegations in his blog.


Little town the sculptor forgot video

Twisted iron from the quake-damaged railway line bears the names of affected townships around Kaikōura, including Oaro, ...

It's not the first, and it probably won't be the last, time someone has asked 'where's Rakautara?' But this time, it's a resident asking.

Muddy cover-up fails

Reid Kevin Heyward has been caught poaching up the Awatere Valley in Marlborough. (File photo)

The number plates were carefully covered in mud so no-one could identify the truck. But then the farmer showed up.

Threatened for testifying

Police target boy racers doing burnouts on public roads. (File photo)

"Good luck, you're stuck with me forever," says teen, as she threatens to send her boy racer mates around.

Grape result for young vintner

Young Winemaker of the Year winner Kelsey Daniels from Vinlink Marlborough works on her blending skills.

A Marlborough vintner keeps young winemaker award in the region.

South Canterbury

Swooping magpies concern

Shirley Halkett is dive bombed by a protective magpie while cycling in the Scenic Reserve.

Cyclists call for signage warning of the dangers of nesting magpies in a Timaru reserve.

Fine weather back

A severe weather warning was in place for heavy winds in Canterbury on Monday morning.

The majority of South Canterbury is expected to have fine weather on Tuesday.

Craigmore a designer's 'dream' video

Olympian Jock Paget is being hosted at Craigmore Station for the first fundraising event for a proposed new eventing course.

Olympian throws support behind proposed world class eventing course at Craigmore Station.

Grace makes NZ Schools side

Timaru Boys' High School First XV captain  Cullen Grace has made the NZ Schools side to tour Australia.

Timaru Boys' High School First XV captain Cullen Grace will wear the silver fern.


Premises needed for Frankton library

There's a "real desire" for a library in Frankton, Queenstown Lakes District Council say.

Expression of interest for a short-term Frankton Library in Queenstown is open.

Dashed wedding turnaround

Central Otago Wedding Fair 'Dream Wedding' winners Ashleigh Sinclair and Jai Beck, of Clyde.

A Clyde couple who cancelled their wedding after falling pregnant will still get to walk down the aisle.

Owaka eatery changes hands

Pictured left, new Lumberjack Bar and Cafe Owaka owners Peter and Irene Walton with former owners of 20 years Janice and ...

Owaka's longstanding Lumberjack Bar and Café has recently changed hands.

RSA seeks missing plaque

Clutha District RSA is hoping to locate this commemorative Balclutha Netherlands Society plaque, missing since a club ...

Clutha District RSA is looking for a missing Netherlands Society plaque.


Craig focus remains on health, housing

Labour candidate for Invercargill Dr Liz Craig at the Newfield Tavern in Invercargill on election night, who is to ...

New MP looking forward to working for Invercargill constituents.

Policy considered

The council introduced its captive bolt gun policy in April 2016, with the support of the local branch of SPCA.

An urgent recommendation on the Invercargill City Council's dog euthanasia policy is expected to be put forward at a meeting this afternoon.

Centenarian gains family

Wallace Price, left, with his son Graeme at the Grasmere Kindergarten to vote in the 2017 general election.

Among the gifts Wallace Price received for his 100th birthday he got a whole new side to the family.

They're 'flooding my family farm' video

Looking out over the Hollyburn creek which has been flooded by water from the Waiau river.

Every time Meridian Energy releases the Manapouri dam, Thomas O'Brien loses another chunk of farmland.

Ad Feedback