Mining the bigger issues
Is that uranium I can smell on John Key's breath? Or was there simply too much garlic in the lamb rack the prime minister cooked for his wife on Valantines Day?
Go on, laugh. But both seem to be legitimate topics of journalistic interest today. TVNZ's Breakfast tackled Key on such weighty matters as his cooking, the value of his doodles, and his romp with Buffy the Serious Story Slayer at the Big Gay Out at the weekend.
When you add the widespread coverage of Key's victory as New Zealand's sexiest politician in a condom manufacturer's survey and I really do start to despair.
Key won't be displeased, though. It's this mindless puffery - which he is very good at playing along with - that acts as a pressure valve and releases the head of steam that builds during the week on things of more moment. Such as GST or the speed wobbles within the coalition with the Maori Party.
As for the mining story, I'm a bit nonplussed. Frankly I don't give a monkey's whether Key owns shares in an Australian mining company, and I think TVNZ's pretext that it's a story because the Government is planning to mine national parks is a little flimsy.
If owning shares in a mining company could become an issue, it should already be an issue, since there is already extensive mining in this country. And we've known for ages that Key's share portfolio includes mining companies. I remember him talking about it during the election campaign.
As for the second leg of the story - that it's a bad look for a PM of a nuclear-free country to own shares in a company that mines uranium - I'm sorry, but I don't get that. Uranium might be a precursor to the manufacture of plutonium, which is used in nuclear weapons.
But it's also used in a vast array of medical and scientific procedures. I've always thought it funny that people claim we're "nuclear free'' when there's enough plutonium in our hospitals and universities to make your hair fall out.
The Nuclear Free Zone, Disarmament, and Arms Control Act 1987 bans nuclear-propelled ships from entering New Zealand territory, the dumping of radioactive waste, and the manufacture of nuclear explosive devices by New Zealand citizens. That's it.
I guess it's possible to argue a conflict of interest in Key owning shares in something that the Government is involved in, such as mining. But that pretty much extends to anything the Government does, since the [prime minister is across everything.
In which case, Key should have all his shares in his blind trust. Which he by and large does. He says he left out the mining shares because he planned to sell them. Nonetheless, it's a bit sloppy, and someone should have remembered this when announcing the decision to expand mining operations.
Selling the shares immediately after TVNZ's story also made him look more guilty of wrongdoing than he actually was.
Still, it goes with the general theme of things since the start of this year, which is basically a rather strange lack of political management.
Last week should have been a triumph for the Government, but it was pretty much an unmitigated disaster. As I posted previously, National seemed unprepared for the attack over raising GST, and didn't have answers at the ready for why they'd changed their minds on the tax.
Neither had they worked out any lines with the Maori Party, which duly sent conflicting signals all week about whether or not they'd support the idea of a GST rise.
For a brief time on Friday I thought Key was backing away from the GST increase if it meant blowing up the support arrangement with the Maori Party, but his office has since said that wasn't the case.
The result was a week spent on the back foot.
I hear there have been rumblings of discontent between the two parties over both the foreshore and seabed and the Whanau Ora policies as well, and neither of these is small beer as far as the Maori Party is concerned.
It's been an untidy start to Parliament by the Government, and Key will be keen to get back on the front foot tomorrow. But you can bet Labour will be ready with lots of lines from David Lange's famous Oxford Union address on nukes, and fresh reminders of Key's GST flip-flop.
Still, Key could always remind Phil Goff who's our sexiest politician.
» Follow NZStuffBlogs on Twitter and get fast updates on all Stuff's blogs.
» Fancy yourself as a blogger? Whoever wins Blog Idol 2 will blog on contract at Stuff as well as win a new Nokia phone. Put on your blogging hat and enter!
Sponsored links
Certainly the holding of mining shares, change of said company to include uranium mining and a link to NZ's Nuclear Free Policy was tenuous at best and at the most clutching a straws on a slow news day. I'm beginning to think that most day's in NZ are slow news days as both TVNZ and TV3 fill their news with such unimportant frippery that is unrelated to NZ it isn't funny. TVNZ needs to save $40M so start by cutting the news back to half an hour (plus the 'current affairs' bits if you must) as well as going back to one newsreader. If Prime does it day in day out with a 30 minute bulletin then so can TVNZ. Anyway, another storm in a teacup all round. Let's wait and see what is actually being proposed with regards to tax cuts, GST increases and mining and then launch into a debate. In the meantime it's just mindless speculation by the usual suspects. If we are borrowing $250M per week just to keep the country ticking over then the country MUST do something to increase it's income, only so much income can be generated from 'come and look at our pretty scenery' tourism.
It's a pity the MSM is so lame, I agree. We have a government that doesn't have a clue, and no-one asking the hard questions. The problem is the National Party. With no real ethics to guide them (or those that they have sacrificied to populist expediency), they're prey to any special interest with good soundbites. In turn the soundbites take the place of debate. Strong media organisations could challenge this but too often they're more interested in joining the special interest queue. And how incompetent is John Key? He didn't put the shares in a blind trust because he was planning to sell them anyway? At a loss, I expect. He wouldn't have waited for the best price, no siree you betcha. I say we find out what's in his portfolio and aggressively short-sell the lot.
Unlike the MSM most of us ordinary mortals out here don't give a tinkers about most of this stuff. What we see is a genial, assured PM who is tolerant of the untidy edges of human interaction instead of wanting to control every last detail and shut down discussion in that awful anal New Labour type of spin.
Too many reporters swot up the PR handbook and want everything free of debate, difference and variety but then leap on so-called gaffes and non-scandals.
And it's a bit tough to tick Key off for trivia when that's all that makes the news. Remember you yourself found the 20+ pages hard going!
"Last week should have been a triumph for the Government, but it was pretty much an unmitigated disaster."
Hence the soft photo ops over the weekend and the full out assault on the bludger beneficiaries this week. The polling is quite strongly against people on the dole for 10 years and solo mums with multiple kids to different deadbeat dads. As distractions go, this one's gold plated. Fact that there's only a handful of the 'ten year brigade' and the 'baby factory brigade' is irrelevant. One exception proves the rule. The MSM will run it, the folks will react, and the poll numbers will stabilise. Job done. It's called good government.
It's rather amusing watching people trying to throw mud with empty hands.
Mr Key .
If I were you I would tell them all to naff off!!!! Who cares about your share portfolio ? They wouldn't be happy if you gave all your shares to charity along with your salary.They would still find fault.
The tall poppy syndrome and the green eyed god are alive and kicking in this country.
I was utterly gob smacked when TV3 led with the story about shares in an overseas mining company and promptly switched off the news. What imbecile at TV3 thought that was a suitable lead story? The 6 o’clock news on both channels has sadly deteriorated to a point of inane stupidity. I suppose now we will have to put up with Labour slinging off for the next few weeks about it, along with Garner offering his 2 cents worth.
Petty beltway issue but good research. Those war mongering Aussies and Canadians with their uranium mines supplying fuel for those nasty power stations that have no CO2 emmissions in despotic countries like Finland, France and Japan. Shocking that our PM has invested in this industry ! At least it gives the lefties another 20 year old issue to get excited about.
Matt - are you keeping a list of all Key's faults? It must be a mile long. That such a man could have been so successful in every wordly sense and a loving husband and dad as well beggars the imagination! Would love to see your list. Then NZ can see just what a monster rules over us after cuddly old Aunty Helen.
All rise - On the House stands adjourned
Dumb and dumber: Axing Heather Roy
Carter commits political suicide
Green leader out of line with protest
Get Carter, but not because he's gay
Party's over for Labour's Hooray Henrys
Whinegate unlikely to sozzle the PM
English sprinkles the fairy dust
From TV to a tent: Family of eight evicted
Star claims Home and Away racism
Robyn Malcolm lays it all bare
Pub owners give up, open kindergarten
Fallen property king arrested in Auckland raids
Mallard sells festival tickets online at profit
Mallard sells festival tickets online at profit
Cyclist: Don't fine us, fix the road
Mallard sells festival tickets online at profit
Should you take your groom's name?
Can Paris Hilton save her image?
Is Kutcher an upgrade over Sheen?
Newest First
Oldest First
You might want to give your brother a clip round the ears Colin ;P As Phil O'Reilly said on Q&A, its a side show. I'm sure Guyon thought he'd scored big time with "Is that uranium I can smell on John Key's share portfolio?". And as you say, I thought we were nuclear weapon free, not out right nuclear free (no CO2 emissions from nuclear power generation).
The Maori parties push for what appears to be outright ownership of the foreshore & seabed worries me though (after recent comments from Turia). I prefer John Key's option of nobody owning it. Its there for all NZer's.