Inspections of Riccarton Rd building 'inadequate'

Last updated 05:00 19/12/2012
CRUMBLED: The crumbled facade of the second-hand bookshop on Riccarton Rd that killed bricklayer Ross Bush, 75.
Ross Bush
GONE: Semi-retired bricklayer Ross Bush, 75, died in the February 22, 2011 earthquake.

Relevant offers

Christchurch earthquake

Woman who pinned her $472k theft on employer on post-quake trauma loses appeal Court throws out $6.5m insurance offer for Henderson property CTV engineer inquiry 'not in public interest' Gap Filler celebrates five years of brightening Christchurch's vacant spaces Earthquake insurer Southern Response sets aside $4m for legal fees Canterbury families tell their stories of quake rebuild Holy Trinity church bells set to ring Lyttelton again Christchurch's 100-day blueprint took 67 days with only 20-odd days of design Leukaemia battle for Christchurch boy who lost his father in February 2011 quake Oamaru woman reunited with fingers 80 years after death

Inspections that led to a Christchurch building reopening before its facade collapsed, killing a man, were insufficient and "made a nonsense" of post-earthquake placarding procedures.

Ross Bush, 75, died in Riccarton Rd on February 22, 2011, when the facade of a secondhand bookshop collapsed on him while he ate lunch in his car parked on the roadside.

Despite having cracks in the facade, the building was green-stickered - deemed safe to occupy - after an external assessment two days after the September 2010 quake.

The Christchurch City Council gave the building a yellow sticker, meaning it should not be occupied, on September 11 after a call from the tenant, but it was later downgraded to green after a third inspection by structural engineer David Elliott.

Elliott did not re-enter the building on the second and third in spections, as required by the council when considering downgrading a building's placard status, because he was confident there had been no structural changes.

The earthquakes inquiry found Elliott's third check was insufficient, and an internal inspection was "clearly called for".

The amended engineer's certificate should not have been accepted, "made a nonsense" of the council's change of placard policy and created "ambiguity".

"In effect, the yellow placard was simply put to one side as a result of the combined actions of Mr Elliott and the [council], without the relevant matters being given proper consideration," the royal commission said.

Elliott said in evidence at the hearing he was concerned that it was inappropriate for him to sign the form because no securing work had been done, but recalled the council officer telling him he should modify the form as he saw fit.

Cracks in the building were visible from the exterior and would not have been visible from the interior, Elliott told the commission.

Council resource consents and building policy manager Steve McCarthy did not believe the criticism was valid.

"We accepted [the certificate] at the time in good faith and believed that it complied with our policy," he said.

Bush's son-in-law, David Stanley, told The Press his family was grateful the commission "got to the bottom" of reasons for the collapse.

However, the "lackadaisical" approach to the safety of people in and around the building and the apparent rush to reopen the bookshop was "horrifying".

Ad Feedback

"If the recommendations were followed, that building would have been propped up and strengthened and barricades would have stopped people parking underneath it."

- The Press

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content