Attacker's sentence reduced on appeal

Last updated 10:45 27/06/2014

Relevant offers

Crime

Ramadan becomes central issue in mosque groping trial Rugby bosses need sincerity lessons, says Otago sports sociologist Residents fear door-to-door fraudsters are looking for Hawke's Bay victims Greymouth sergeant in another investigation Police warn online sellers to be vigilant after vehicle scam Sex offender liable for deportation after fraud conviction sparks residency review Wellington police want 'dangerous' man for breaching release conditions Young offender Shem Brokenshire lived in 47 homes in 10 years Timaru man sent to jail after stabbing teen with sharpened ruler Police unable to obtain DNA sample in Lisa Blakie case

An Auckland businessman who repeatedly struck another man with a broken bottle, causing serious injuries, has had his prison sentence reduced on appeal.

Sheng Sun was jailed by an Auckland District Court judge for six years for the February, 2011, attack, which left his victim with what the judge called significant and long-term injuries.

The attack happened when a man tried to break up a fight at a restaurant between Sun and a woman with whom Sun had been in a "brief and volatile" relationship.

Sun and the man got into an altercation which ended with them on the ground, with Sun on top of his victim. Sun repeatedly struck him with a broken bottle, and the sentencing judge said: "It is a matter of good luck rather than good management that much more serious injuries were not caused and that you were not in the High Court facing a murder charge."

Sun appealed his sentence, with his lawyer arguing the judge had taken too-long a sentence as a starting point in her deliberations when compared to what people convicted of similar offences had received.

In a decision released today, the Court of Appeal agreed.

It said the attack had not been premeditated, and although the injuries the victim received were "quite serious . . . we would not classify the violence on the part of the appellant as extreme".

The court also noted that the bottle that was used as a weapon was not taken to the scene by Sun, and had not been deliberately broken before it was used.

The six-year jail sentence was quashed and replaced with one of four years and nine months. 

Ad Feedback

- Stuff

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content