SIS seeks varsity help in weapon watch

By TINA LAW - The Press
Last updated 05:00 18/11/2009

Relevant offers

Crime

Woman found guilty of Valentine's Day murder Police find drugs while fighting Blenheim fire Businessman to defend firearms charges Man loses drug ring sentence appeal Bomb-joke man offered a break More on wanted list face court Christchurch youth faces airgun charges 36 years to pay back WINZ after fraud 110,000 calls, texts intercepted in drugs op Prisoner escaped to show he was 'no threat'

A suggestion that New Zealand's universities might become involved in the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction is far-fetched and paranoid, peace campaigners say.

New Zealand's spy agency, the Security Intelligence Service (SIS), wants universities to alert the SIS to any illicit science relating to the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction.

SIS director Dr Warren Tucker met the New Zealand Vice-Chancellors' Committee (NZVCC) and sent university managers a letter and a brochure called A Guide to Weapons of Mass Destruction: Your Role in Preventing Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction.

The move has outraged the Tertiary Education Union (TEU), the Green Party and a peace group which described the request as unethical.

Disarmament and Security Centre co-director Rob Green said the SIS inviting university staff to spy on their students and colleagues was thoroughly unethical and ill-advised.

"The SIS is showing signs of paranoia in order to please their United States masters, I suspect."

Green believed the request was driven by other countries, including the United States, and was a matter of New Zealand trying to impress and keep up with the big boys. Such a request was extremely far-fetched to the point of being paranoid.

TEU president Dr Tom Ryan said asking university staff to report back to a spy agency would undermine the legislated autonomy of institutions, including the guarantee of academic freedom.

It could also lead to some academics being targeted because of their religion, nationality or ethnicity, he said.

The SIS pamphlet provided information and guidance for scientists, exporters and academics on how to identify proliferation-related activity and what to do should they become aware of such activity or have suspicions or concerns.

Tucker said of particular relevance to New Zealand universities was the potential application of knowledge or skills in the hard science, engineering, mathematical and medical fields to weapons programmes.

"Many technologies currently studied at advanced levels in these areas have dual-use applications relevant to weapons of mass destruction."

Canterbury University spokesman John MacDonald said vice-chancellor Rod Carr verbally informed his senior management team of the SIS request.

Carr did not distribute the letter or guide.

The NZVCC said the meeting with the SIS was a routine matter and was not in response to any perceived heightened threat to security.

Green Party human rights spokesman Keith Locke said it was unlikely New Zealand universities were doing any serious research into matters that were directly related to weapons of mass destruction.

Ad Feedback

"It just seems that the SIS is really trying to make work for itself given there are no terrorists or really dangerous people in New Zealand."

The SIS refused to answer questions from The Press and instead referred it to its website.

21 comments
Post a comment
pete   #21   11:51 am Nov 18 2009

Steve #10

Try adding a few sausage rolls, pies, baked beans, and pickled onions to the mix - guaranteed to clear a medium sized office in 7 seconds.

Smelltheroses   #20   11:40 am Nov 18 2009

It's like saying that if you study atomic physics in order to find a way of generating cheap & clean electricity you are [i]automatically[/i] suspect because the principles of atomic physics can be used to make a nuke.

Personally I'm completely against anything that has the potential to dumb down our universities any further.

If the SIS have suspicions about any person because they're studying a particular subject or other I'm sure they've the resources to monitor the person without issue, this "A Guide to Weapons of Mass Destruction: Your Role in Preventing Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction" reeks of the cold-war era paranoia and scaremongering.

No thanks.

Dave   #19   11:37 am Nov 18 2009

The Tertiary Education Union (TEU), the Green Party and the peace group are wrong about this.

We all need to be very aware that there are (sadly) people out there who want to kill many others because of their misguided religious beliefs - we all need to keep watch for our own security.

The SIS are right to ask our help in identifying these creeps - just like we do in our own neighbourhoods.

Get real TEU, the Green Party and the peace group! It's an increasingly crazy world out there!

Felicia Jollygoodfellow   #18   11:00 am Nov 18 2009

The SIS are looking for terrorists where none exist. The main reason this is happening is because the Key government is buying into the paranoid antics of the USA and Britain. For those who use 9/11 as an excuse for war mongering, remember that more Americans have died in Iraq than died when the planes hit the buildings. As with forty years of Cold War paranoia, the SIS justify their feeble existence by spend millions of tax payer dollars to spy on peaceniks and Maori radicals.

epsilon   #17   10:54 am Nov 18 2009

Any parliamentarian who makes statements like "there are no terrorists or really dangerous people in New Zealand", is out of touch with reality, and their presence in parliament is probably a threat to New Zealand.

samm   #16   10:49 am Nov 18 2009

Much as I'd love it to be otherwise, "Disarmament and Security" is an oxymoron.

Rod   #15   10:33 am Nov 18 2009

To Helena #3; yes, we live in the land of milk and honey... wakeup and smell the roses you twit. Apart from the domesti threat there is a very real international threat that needs to be monitored. Eg: A asian research company commissions a NZ company to research a better optical gyrospinktar, they are told it is for a better airbag design. the NZ company uses the Uni's to do the research, the company then builds the said device and ships them off to Hongkong, where they are shifted off Iran to be joined with other parts from around the world to make anti-aircraft rockets. This is not a fantasy, this happens everyday around the world

Nick   #14   10:21 am Nov 18 2009

I can see the SIS point of view, at university there is a lot of stuff that can be used for deadly purposes. And then there is the most dangerous thing of all, knowledge. But think of it this way, we live in a bad world with some very dangerous people in it, and I am afraid the world does need the likes of America to watch our backs.

Look at this way New Zealand is an ideal place to send would be terrorists to learn there trade in Physics or Chemistry etc, because we are such an open and a friendly nation. Guess what, the bad guys know that to.

Greens get a life, because and of the day we cant all dance, sing songs and the world will miraculously be come a safer and better place. Some one has to do the job, so you can sleep peacefully in your bed at night.

Which is the lesser of two evils, losing a bit of privacy or let the bad guys get away with murder?

Brent   #13   10:09 am Nov 18 2009

If the move has outraged the Green Party, then I'm all for it!

Steven Smith   #12   10:01 am Nov 18 2009

When will people wake up to realise, that government agencies like SIS are not exactly owned by our government? its funded by all sorts of people, mainly funded by the USA... I have some sources that tell me that because of this new trade deal with united states, we must beef up security, drop our new zealand equivalent of the FDA and buy our medicine from united states, like hell i want to be following such a corrupt system.

Who are they kidding, if people wanted to make bombs they could use the internet... i just searched and found a whole lot of things. But i would not use them! :D!


Show 1-11 of 21 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you sign in, you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions