Relevant offers
Crime
Lawyers for both sides of a family that are warring over the burial location of a Christchurch man have finished their submissions at the Supreme Court.
James Takamore died of an aneurysm in 2007 and was to be buried in Christchurch, where he had lived with his partner Denise Clarke and their two children for nearly 20 years.
But his body was removed by his Tuhoe relatives before this could happen and driven up to the Kutarere Marae near Opotiki in Bay of Plenty for burial.
Clarke has a High Court judgment upholding he right as executrix to decide his burial place, which has been upheld in the Court of Appeal.
Takamore's sister, Josephine, appealed the decision on the grounds that Tuhoe tikanga, or customary protocol, should decide the burial place.
This morning during the second day of the hearing, Clarke's lawyer Gerard McCoy continued to argue that while important, there was no way tikanga trumped his client's right as executrix under New Zealand common law.
He produced several previous cases from countries including Canada and Australia that he claimed supported his stance.
The removal of Takamore's body by his whanau had been unreasonable and a violation of the law, he said.
Clarke had a legal obligation as executrix to decide the burial place, but this had been "destroyed" when the whanau had take the body north in an "unrefrigerated van".
There was an opportunity for tikanga to exist alongside common law but it could not break it, he said.
Yesterday Josephine Takamore's lawyer Jamie Ferguson said Takamore could not opt out of being Tuhoe, no matter how he had chosen to live his life.
"The only basis on which they are not subject to tikanga is if they are not Tuhoe."
It was part of that tikanga that James Takamore's son and daughter were also Tuhoe, and the iwi was obliged to "address and redress" the conflict caused by the burial.
The hearing finishes this afternoon, but even if the Supreme Court decides in Clarke's favour, it is expected another court hearing will be needed to decide what happens next.
- © Fairfax NZ News
Sponsored links
Rush cleans out chickenpox vaccine supplies
Elderly woman 'abandoned' on couch
KiwiRail introduces random drug tests
Shoplifter nicked without knickers
Councillor murder case adjourned
Police chase teen in stolen truck
Enraged pupil prompts school to seek police help
District Health Board's website hacked
Woman trapped after head-on crash
Air New Zealand flew shark fins
Air New Zealand flew shark fins
District Health Board's website hacked
Vettori a no-go; four-seamers for Black Caps
Henry officially sanctioned over comments
Judge blasts herbal drugs as 'huge problem'
Sir Don McKinnon takes top award
Coromandel agent fined over forgery
Voluntary cheese slice product recall
KiwiRail introduces random drug tests
Warning skiers may bypass Chch
All Black Owen Franks ruled out by Crusaders
Everest's Hillary Step a 'chaotic mess'
South London attack a possible terrorism act
Has Home and Away jumped the shark? (spoiler)
Henry officially sanctioned over comments
Shoplifter nicked without knickers
Elderly woman 'abandoned' on couch
Best & worst of the fest: Day eight
Nasa cooks up 3D-printed food idea
Air New Zealand flew shark fins
