Cold case murder to be probed in Sensing Murder episode

Sue Nicholson is one of the psychics called on the help shed light on an unsolved murder.

Sue Nicholson is one of the psychics called on the help shed light on an unsolved murder.

The brutal murder of a Hawke's Bay woman is being investigated by psychics from Sensing Murder in the hope of uncovering new information.

Chattrice Maihi-Carroll, a 46-year-old mother-of-five, was stabbed to death in her Napier home in 2008. 

Her neighbour, Zion King, was charged with her murder but was later discharged after private investigators working for the defence found evidence that contradicted the prosecution case. 

Chattrice Maihi-Carroll was murdered in her Napier home in 2005.
SUPPLIED

Chattrice Maihi-Carroll was murdered in her Napier home in 2005.

The murder is now the subject of the TVNZ's Sensing Murder programme. It is understood Sue Nicholson is one of two psychics featured in the episode. 

READ MORE: 
*Sensing Murder reruns questioned
*Psychics' killer lead hits a wall
*Police reopen cold case
*Sensing Murder: Sleuths or scammers?
*Sensing Murder's Kelvin Cruickshank

Maihi-Carroll's sister, Marilyn Walker, hoped the show would shed light on the mysterious case. 

The house in Cottrell Cescent, Onekawa, Napier, where Maihi-Carroll was stabbed to death.
TOMMY LIVINGSTON/STUFF

The house in Cottrell Cescent, Onekawa, Napier, where Maihi-Carroll was stabbed to death.

"All we want to know is who murdered her," she said. 

Maihi-Carroll's family had believed police would be able to take King to trial, but were left shocked when the charge was later dropped. 

"We believed the police. For it to not go to trial was a huge bomb shell," she said. 

"Our mum and dad have died since then, they never really got over it." 

Ad Feedback

King, who spent 14 months in custody while charged with Maihi-Carrol's murder before being granted bail, said he had been contacted by the programme.

He refused to appear on the show, but instead said he was focusing his efforts to get compensation for the time he spent in prison. 

"I definitely want her killer to be found. I have had enough of it, though. I have had enough of the media. What are they going to do to solve it?

"It is just entertainment. I am not an entertainer." 

Maihi-Carroll's other neighbour, Eddie Nathan, was also considered to be a "person of interest" after a small spatter of his blood was found in his house. 

He died in 2015, but always denied any involvement in her death. 

Forensic scientist Dr Anna Sandiford, who helped analyse evidence for Zion King's defence, said she had reservations about any new information the psychics may uncover. 

"I would be incredibly skeptical as a scientist with anything which came from a programme like that."

What background information the psychics are given could heavily influence the conclusions they come to, she said.

"Ideally you wouldn't give anybody any information. They should be providing a comment based on identifiable facts. If you start giving people background information, or names of people who may have been involved, you are already creating a bias." 

A woman who stays at the flat where Maihi-Carroll was killed said psychics recently spent a day in the house trying to connect with her spirit. 

"They said she was at peace. They said sometimes you might see something in the corner of your eye, and that will be her." 

A police spokeswoman said they were aware the case was being looked into by the Sensing Murder psychics. 

"The investigation into the death of Chattrice Maihi-Carroll remains open and police welcome any information from the public in relation to the case," she said. 

TVNZ would not confirm when the show would air. 

 - Sunday Star Times

Ad Feedback
special offers
Ad Feedback