Foiling plot takes toll on sister

BLAIR ENSOR
Last updated 05:00 11/01/2014
Daniel Tobin

Lee-Anne Cartier, the sister of Philip Nisbet talks to Blair Ensor about how she feels now that Helen Milner has been found guilty of her brothers murder.

Lee-Anne Cartier
DANIEL TOBIN/Fairfax NZ
LEE-ANNE CARTIER: Giving evidence in Helen Milner's trial.

Relevant offers

Crime

Christmas present burglary foiled Hazardous chemical pourer gets community work Burglars hit Manawatu schools Peter Ellis inquiry bid led by Don Brash Stepfather's rape appeal fails Sex trial judge is scathing of teens Police seek three men after assault Prisoner escapes from hospital Dog-bite victim's smile 'a sneer' Corrections officer stood down after Phillip Smith claims

There are times when Lee-Anne Cartier wishes she hadn't discovered her brother was murdered.

The hundreds of hours and thousands of dollars she spent trying to unravel Helen Milner's poisonous plot have plunged her life into turmoil.

She's financially ruined, her relationship with her four children is strained and at times people have questioned her sanity.

"Sometimes I wish I was the dumb idiot who didn't put all this together and this didn't become part of my life," Cartier told The Press.

"I just wish I could wake up and it was all a nightmare."

Milner, 50, was last month found guilty of the murder and attempted murder of her husband, Philip James Nisbet.

Police acknowledged the case may never have made it to court had it not been for the sleuthing of Cartier and the keen eye of a coroner.

An internal report identified detectives made many basic errors during an initial investigation, which concluded Nisbet had committed suicide at his Checketts Ave home in Halswell in May 2009.

In an extensive and at times emotional interview with The Press this week, Cartier revealed plans to sue the police for tens of thousands of dollars.

She also said detectives involved in the initial inquiry should have been demoted and suspended without pay.

"I want an apology from the police who screwed up, not their boss," she said.

"It was like sending in a couple of kindergarten kids to do a grown man's job. [The investigation] wasn't even half-arsed."

Cartier, 44, was living in Queensland at the time of her brother's death.

She was brought up in Christchurch's eastern suburbs.

It wasn't until she flew home for his funeral and was told conflicting accounts of how he died that she became suspicious.

A month later, Milner showed Cartier a typed suicide note with "Phil" scrawled by hand at the bottom. The signature was not her brother's and she then realised he had been murdered.

The note included the revelation that Nisbet had discovered that his son, Ben Porter, was not his biological child.

Cartier went to police with her concerns before returning to Australia to begin her own detective work.

She called friends, family and colleagues and told them her theory while continuing to sympathise with Milner in the hope she would let something slip.

"Do you know how hard that was, talking to her like she's your best friend when you absolutely hate her for what she's done?

"She just made me sick."

Cartier also found out about her brother's $257,000 life insurance policy and arranged for DNA tests, which later proved Ben was his son.

"Initially, I was just trying to piece things together in my head, but the police weren't really doing anything.

"I'd get hold of them and they didn't seem that interested - it was like I was telling them how to fry eggs.

"I didn't know where to turn. I was at my wits' end."

It was not until May 2011 when Coroner Sue Johnson ruled there was no evidence Nisbet intended to commit suicide that Cartier believed a police officer finally took her seriously.

Ad Feedback

Detective Inspector Greg Murton read about the findings in The Press and emailed her to say he would review the file into her brother's death.

Cartier said her confidence in police was shattered and she had to meet Murton because "I needed to know I could trust this guy".

"I couldn't go through that nightmare again - hitting my head against a brick wall, dealing with idiots," she said.

She remained in regular contact with Murton throughout the homicide investigation and recalled the morning of October 27, 2011 when he called to say that Milner had been arrested and would be charged with Nisbet's murder.

She went home and celebrated with a bottle of bubbly.

"I was totally relieved we were at that point.

"I'm so grateful for Greg. I know there was no stone unturned."

When the trial began on December 2, the jury heard it was likely Milner crushed up Phenergan tablets then mixed them in with her husband's dinner the night before his body was found.

The antihistamine and sedative killed him outright or she may have suffocated him while he was sedated, the Crown argued.

Milner then set the scene of a suicide and tried to cover her tracks by forging a suicide text and suicide notes.

The jury of seven men and five women took nearly eight hours to find her guilty of murder.

Cartier said she wanted to confront her brother's killer to put her mind at ease.

"I know why she killed him - she killed him for money.

"What in her mind made her think that it was acceptable? What made her think that she could get away with it?

"It's just hard to believe that someone like that could actually exist.

"You watch movies and she's that nutty, screwed up chick . . . that you think that someone just made up, but she's it for real.

"I think it would put my mind at ease - and it would help with my book."

Cartier hoped Milner would never be released from jail because she would always pose a risk to society.

"She's not like the nutter at the pub who has a couple of beers and flips out and starts throwing s... . You can't tell what she's up to and who knows what she's up to?" she said. 

Cartier has engaged a lawyer and wants to sue the police "for expenses and the emotional stress of doing their [the police's] job".

Reflecting on the last four and half years she regretted the toll her obsession with the case had taken on her family. She felt like she had let her children down - putting the investigation before them.

"No money can pay for the time they've been robbed of," she said.

"It had to be done. No-one else was going to do it - it's just something you can't let go."

Cartier has been unemployed since moving back to New Zealand in 2012 to prepare for the trial and sold assets to fund her stay.

The saga has left her financially ruined, she said. She planned to move back to Australia.

"I thought maybe we could make New Zealand our home, but [it has] got too much to do with this whole thing."

She hoped that writing about the ordeal would allow her to move on with her life.

"If I get it all down in a book and it's there then it's out of my head, then I can let go of it. Then when people start asking [about the case] I can tell them to read my f...ing book."

But before that happens her family planned to hold another funeral for Nisbet.

"We were ripped off by the first one. It was run by a murderer. [Milner] shouldn't have been there."

- The Press

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content