Key defends charter schools

DANYA LEVY
Last updated 08:15 06/12/2011

Related Links

Christchurch schools amongst first for private funding trial

Relevant offers

Education

Click Here
Pupil's eye injured in water fight No background checks on Education ministry staff School orders safety review after boy's death Demolition protest shelved but tension high South Island could become 'quake school' Good start for trades facility Children prepare to go to classes in a tent Gourmet school grub is delivered to order Woman found unconscious at university Ngaio quake-prone classrooms closed

Prime Minister John Key is defending the introduction of charter schools under a deal with ACT despite National never campaigning on it, saying "that's MMP for you, isn't it?".

ACT's Epsom MP John Banks and United Future leader Peter Dunne yesterday signed support deals with National, giving it the numbers to govern.

In return both men gained ministerial warrants and concessions for their parties.

Under the deal with ACT, community, religious or ethnic groups, or private companies, will be allowed to operate state-funded charter schools.

School boards will be able to set class hours and introduce performance-related teacher's pay.

A trial will be held in South Auckland which, along with Christchurch East, will be the first areas to have the state-funded private schools within the next three years.

Key this morning acknowledged the move had not been National policy.

"That's MMP for you, isn't it? That you agree to different proposals," he told Radio New Zealand.

"I don't think the New Zealand voters are going to be up and arms because in a couple of communities in New Zealand we give some new model a go.

"If those students don't want to go there, they'll be free to go to the existing schools they are at."

Key said "more often than not" parents had objectives that some in the education sector were opposed to.

"That doesn't mean just because they are opposed, they are in line with what the New Zealand parents and student want."

The Prime Minister rejected suggestions National had blindsided voters with changes to the education system.

"Are you really telling me that because we might trial in parts of the country, one or two schools, to see whether they can deliver better results, that somehow it's undermining the education system in New Zealand?

"Sorry but it sounds a bit far-fetched to me."

However, Labour claimed National had used what was called a "bogus" agreement with ACT to introduce bulk funding and privatisation policies it was working on before the election but didn't tell voters about.

Education spokeswoman Sue Moroney said the move would come as a shock to most parents.

"The charter school proposal is bulk funding in drag. It is a model that has been blamed for the decline in educational achievement in Sweden.

"The ink is barely dry on the voting papers and National is already trying to hoodwink New Zealanders."

Moroney said there was "no way" ACT's one per cent of the party vote and single MP could have forced National to "substantially" change the New Zealand education system.

Ad Feedback

"That is simply a nonsense.

"Once again National is implementing failed education policies, copied from overseas.

"But then that's all we can expect from a National government that has no ideas of its own."

Under the support agreements, Dunne retained his revenue and associate health portfolios and picked up associate conservation.

Banks became the minister of regulatory reform, small business, and associate education and commerce.

Both were ministers outside Cabinet.

Key today backed the deals, saying they were not disproportionate to the two votes the two parties guaranteed National.

"We like to work very constructively with our partners."

The ministerial warrants reflected the "areas of interests or the underlying fundamental beliefs of the parties", he said.

- © Fairfax NZ News

156 comments
Post a comment
james   #156   03:49 pm Dec 09 2011

What, we gave him a mandate to do what he likes

Grant   #155   07:45 pm Dec 08 2011

A key issue here, if you'll pardon the pun, is John Key's integrity. His lack of an moral/ethical filter through which most people conduct their dealings with others reminds me of Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg. Where there should be compassion, consideration, and an awareness of the needs of others there is a vacuum. Nothing. Just a shrug of the shoulders and a 'don't blame me' dismissal.

The quotes attributed to Key in this piece are particularly revealing. He demonstrates a callous disregard for the welfare of any individual or small/disenfranchised/non-aligned group who happen to oppose his views, as he believes that the interests of his own stakeholders trump those of any individual or group that gets in his way. All this and he, like Zuckerberg, has climbed to the top of his tree with 'our' (certainly not my) help. What mugs we are, and how dearly we are about to pay for our foolish endorsement.

pp   #154   07:34 pm Dec 08 2011

Selling schools will be the next step. JOhn KEy is a danger to us all.

Too funny   #153   01:37 pm Dec 08 2011

@ Sigh #150

It isn't MMP at work. National did a deal before the election to get ACT in. National would have had the Epsom seat had it not been for the deal but then they wouldn't have had ACT to pin the blame on for the idea. Saying it is MMP at work is disengenuous at best.

JGM   #152   01:27 pm Dec 08 2011

@ Richard #148

National should be ashamed for using special needs kids in their statistics, kids who whatever the interventions wouldn't leave school with adequate reading and writing skills, to discredit a system that is working for the vast majority.

Are you aware that schools can only get ORR's funding for SN kids if they can be proven to be 5 years behind in their schooling? (Which usually means forget it until you can prove it if they are less than in year 5).Literally thousands of kids, the kids you talk about, don't get the extra support because there is simply no funding available to help. Schools cannot afford TA support.

You see Richard, you and yours have the blinkers well and truly on. International studies, people who know what they are saying defending the current system, they mean nothing to you. You are a sheep who blindly follows. You are an 'expert' on education because you've been through it.

And as to your comments: we don't do well by "some" children. We do well by most.

If you think that NS and Charter schools are going to magically fix the minority of failing students you are delusional. They aren't aimed at them. They are aimed at promoting high decile schools and are opening the door to allow grouos such as the Exclusive Brethren state funding - a deal they probably made with National for funding, etc.

Doh!   #151   12:27 pm Dec 08 2011

No wonder they cried so much when the media crashed their tea party. Coulda shaved a good 5% votes off had we known this. but hey thaaaats MMP!

@ Richard #148 11:21am

Take your medicine and go to bed

Sigh   #150   12:20 pm Dec 08 2011

Thats MMP for you - Translation - So long suckers!

happyfeet   #149   11:44 am Dec 08 2011

you just dont get it. there needs to be a low wage underclass so the rich can get richer off the under classes back. figure it out.

Richard   #148   11:21 am Dec 08 2011

JGM #144 'It is a blatant lie from National's PR machine that NZ's education system is failing.' Yes we may do well for most children but there are a significant number of children doing extremely badly. The left seem quite happy to let these children fail in life so National is at least trying something different for these children to see if it helps. You (and other people objecting) should be ashamed of yourselves for ignoring the plight of the children who leave school unable to read and write.

brenda   #147   09:46 am Dec 08 2011

Teachers are objecting because they think they might lose their jobs, principals are afraid their schools might lose pupils and be seen as "failing", the teachers unions are always against the National Govt by default. Parents who can't afford private schools will at last have some choice. Bring it on.


Show 97-146 of 156 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content