Class sizes irrelevant - education expert

ANDREA VANCE
Last updated 13:27 10/06/2012

Relevant offers

Education

Children escape Palmerston North daycare, investigation launched Tauranga tumuaki unfairly dismissed from kura Pt Chevalier Kindergarten has a new home Christchurch school peers of Rakaia crash victim learn mindfulness Students given timeouts at Wainuiomata High School for incorrect shoes Taranaki principals hit back out at proposed Ministry of Education changes Campbell fails in a bid to be reinstated to principal's role at Salford School Students live, think in te reo at Te Rito: where English stops at the front gate Auckland teacher barred for having sex with student First jobs hard to find for primary teachers in the Waikato

The government's education guru John Hattie says National made a ''selling mistake'' over increasing class sizes, but shouldn't have backed down.

The government was forced into a humiliating u-turn last week after public backlash over plans to cut teachers. 

Education minister Hekia Parata had argued increasing pupil-to-teacher ratios would save $174 million over four years and $60m would be used improving teacher quality.

Hattie, a former University of Auckland professor now based in Australia, said the government slipped up by putting ''class size right up front.''

''Certainly if I was advising Treasury or the government, it would be keep to the staff-student ratios
and leave the whole class size thing out of it, because that's an issue, it's a hot-button issue, as
we've certainly seen in New Zealand, and it isn't a simple necessary translation from staff-student
ratios to class size,'' he said.

''So if they'd kept to the staff-student ratio and they had been very clear what the saving was going to
be used by, because that's what principals do. They say, "I'm going to have less time with teachers
in the classroom so they can plan, rather than smaller classes."

Hattie - whose research is believed to have influenced the policy - said teachers don't change the way they teach if class sizes are reduced. '' The bottom line is it hardly makes a difference,'' he said.

The government must still find the money to boost teacher quality - ''and I'm sure it's going to come out of another part of the education budget,'' he said.

Labour's education spokeswoman Nanaia Mahuta called on Parata to ''spell out'' her plans for improving teacher quality and justify the rationale.

"What we don't want to see is this government throw the baby out with the bathwater. One bad idea shouldn't stall progress across the sector.''

Ad Feedback

- The Dominion Post

Comments

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content