Concern at 21pc rise of care babies

By JOHN HARTEVELT
Last updated 05:00 21/12/2009
Opinion poll

What do you think of babies under 1 being in daycare?

It's shameful - they should be with a parent

Parents should be given more support so they can care for their babies

It's a financial reality that both parents are forced to work

I don't see why someone should suspend their career to be a parent

Relevant offers

Health

Radiographers' union in talks with DHB Healthy eating hard for poor - research Children most at risk of harm 'fall under radar' Ticketek cuts prices for wheelchair users Radiographer talks fail to avert strike Doctor suspended over child sex images Family fed up with waiting on health system Defence Force to keep track of asbestos hazards Dads beware of lawnmowers and kitchens Calls to PlunketLine up 40 percent

Nearly 8000 babies yet to reach their first birthdays are in daycare as parents rush back to work.

The number of under-ones in the care of strangers – 7972 – has been revealed in official figures made public. It represents a 21.2 per cent increase on four years ago.

The figures also showed 23,917 one-year-olds and 35,293 two-year-olds are in daycare – increases of 18.4 per cent and 15 per cent respectively on four years ago.

Children's Commissioner John Angus says the figures indicate a rapid change in the care of babies. He is halfway through an inquiry into the care of under-twos.

"This is a change in how young children in New Zealand are being cared for," Dr Angus said.

"For very young children, it's a change that is occurring quite rapidly and we might just be at risk of moving into a pattern of care that isn't in the best interests of the youngest children."

The new figures were in an Education Ministry report, which said there had been an increase in fulltime enrolments (more than 27 hours per week) of all children aged up to five. Though part-time enrolments were up a relatively modest 6.3 per cent, fulltime enrolments were up by 37.1 per cent.

Services offering all-day, flexible programmes which required little parental involvement were increasingly popular, the report said.

Dr Angus said that, though parents thought hard about the care of their children and most centres were doing their best by them, there had been little thought about government policies on the issue.

"Getting more kids into childcare is in the interests of providers and in the interests of government advisers who think it will increase productivity in New Zealand to have skilled women return to the workforce quite early on," he said.

"I just don't think the interests of children are being given equal weight."

Thousands of parents were debating when to go back to work after having a child, and many were deciding to return earlier.

"They see that as an economic necessity," Dr Angus said. "It's been seen as economically good for the household."

The commissioner's inquiry includes a reference group of international and local experts.

It has carried out a literature review and met ministry officials. Next year, it will move into childcare centres and meet parents.

Findings are expected in the middle of the year.

Academic opinion is divided on the effect of childcare on babies, but Dr Angus said there was enough evidence to be concerned. Some studies showed very young children were over-anxious for long periods, or became anti-social and aggressive.

Ad Feedback

A report by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development on the welfare of children warned this year that childcare for babies may limit breast-feeding and attachment to a parent.

"It can expose children to stressful interactions with other children at a time when they are not well-equipped to deal with it," the report said. "For very young children, centre-based care might expose them to higher amounts of infection than does the average home environment."

Education Minister Anne Tolley said she would consider the findings of Dr Angus' inquiry. She added, however: "We trust parents to make the right decisions for their children."

116 comments
Post a comment
Perfect_mum   #116   11:38 pm Dec 21 2009

Annoyed at #104 and others Hey - guess what - you can do arts and craft acitivities for no money at home - but no, you probably don't want to get paint on your 20,000 new white carpet eh? Looking after your own kids can be very cheap and easy if yo umake your own activities and food.

Aaron #101 - if you and your wife have worked so hard for 16+ years, including in the forces (where you have few expenses) - how come you have no money?

To ALL the parents trying to make themselves feel less guilty by saying "yes, my kids love daycare" how exactly does a baby or child under 2 tell you this? Just because they don't cry when you leave them does not mean they are terrified, lost and confused.

Oh yes - and how can anyone be stupid enough to have a small house in a crappy suburb in Christchurch and be paying 400+ a week?? It's not about the economic climate - it's about greed and poor financial planning

MadMatt   #115   11:21 pm Dec 21 2009

What a beat up, is this newspaper going tabloid? Both of our children started day care at approx. 7 months old doing 3 days per week (weaned themselves of breastfeeding about a month earlier). They are in high quality care with good child to carer ratios, and they are passing all of their milestones. Our 3 y.o. is doing really well having just completed a year of 3 y.o. kindergarten offered by the day care centre. Better that they be in a stimulating environment with qualified carers vs. parked in front of the TV at home. I am not suggesting that everyone at home does this, but if this is the situation in some homes, then why make blanket statements about how bad all child care is.

Ming   #114   11:05 pm Dec 21 2009

There are countless different ways to raise a happy and healthy child. There doesn't have to be just one right way. I say focus on those children that aren't being raised healthy and happy.

a mother   #113   08:19 pm Dec 21 2009

Glenn #73 - W T F ? Yes - a mortgage - ie a roof over our (and our children's) head. What are you suggesting ? that we live in cardboard boxes on the street ? I really hope you were taking the p!ss with that comment . . .

Caring   #112   08:05 pm Dec 21 2009

Im a caregiver to two children under one myself. they are both from different families and the families and I have a fantastic relationship, we communicate and trust each other to bring up the little ones to be fantastic, happy and secure people. They are never distressed and obviously feel comfortable and bonded to all of us, even each other. Whats wrong with having more people to care for your child as you would if necessary?

Elyse   #111   07:02 pm Dec 21 2009

It has nothing to do with parents who dont WANT to parent their kids - These daycare centres arent cheap espically when it is more than one child. My 4 kids ALL attend daycare part time during the day - i work only in evenings, Why - Because i have a 2yo son and 1yo triplets, I would like to see anyone go pay bills and do groceries with 4 under 2s. Also its godo for them a few hours a week to be out of the house interacting with other children playing with things like playdo and paint and getting it everywhere and having a sandpit and donig what kids do best - PLAY. I love all my children and i cant help the fact i had triplets ( with no additional medical help i might add) I do it for a few hours a week sanity to fold the washing without someone climbing on it, to have a coffee alone , I think the people on here who claim that mothers HAVE to stay home and HAVE to do everything are clearly living in the dark ages - Or they dont actually have their own kids. What about people who cant downsize houses - I cant downsize my van - as my children wont fit, Its not easy to sell a house these days anyway. And im positive there are other mothers out there that have children who attend daycare just to get that tiny bit of ME time that mothers never get - and i refuse to feel guilty for it

Poppy   #110   06:43 pm Dec 21 2009

I consider my self extremely fortunate to be able to stay home and care for our son. We are not rich but I'm able to do this and my hubby supports this stance. If I had to go to work it would break me...really. I take my hat off to all the mummys and dads out there doing the hard yrads to keep their heads above water. Most of the talk about mortgage being more important than kids and feminism sounds like crap to a good old fashioned kiwi like myself. And to most people with commonsense we know that one has to work to eat and sleep under a roof. Good on you working parrents, its not bloody easy!!!

Rex   #109   05:42 pm Dec 21 2009

It makes me sad that I share the world with so many judgemental people - particularly when you consider that those judgements are being made without knowing anything about other people's individual circumstances.

To all you "if you can't stay at home, you can't afford kids" brigade. Get over yourselves.

Have you heard the expression "It takes a village to raise a child"? Parents haven't always raised children. That was left to the people who were good at it while the parents went out hunting, gathering, sewing, cleaning, etc.

Every caring adult your child comes into contact with does your child good. A much bigger problem than this is the parents who don't teach their kids to read and write.

Justice   #108   05:37 pm Dec 21 2009

Jezz, if you have children then be prepared to pay for the cost of care for them EVEN before the cost of your mortgage! Don't look for a benefits or someone to blame!. You made a commitment to that child, so if you cant afford the child and your lavish mortgages aswell then the choice is simple! Dump the mortgage. Life is becoming more expensive everyday only due to our own unrealistic expectations of material wealth which pushes inflation through the roof. This pushes the cost of living up and forces both parents into work even straight after birth in most cases now. Funny that no one complained about these foreseen issues when house prices skyrocketed

Annoyed   #107   05:08 pm Dec 21 2009

My nieces have been going to day care since they were at least 6 months old. They are both Confidient well rounded young ladies, who can hold perfect conversations, know how to interact with other children and are not socially awkward. They love day care and are sad when the are sick and aren't able to go because that means they miss out on playing with their friends and all the arts and crafts and learning activities they do. I can't believe some people are so stuck up their own a***'s and feel they have the right to tell other people how to raise their children.


Show 57-106 of 116 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you sign in, you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content