Abortions on young double in 20 years

BY REBECCA TODD
Last updated 05:00 07/07/2010
Opinion poll

Should parents be told if their young daughters are considering abortion?

Yes

No

Vote Result

Relevant offers

Health

A burning issue: When coffins get too big Teens mimic depression to get prescription drugs Promoter dismisses bike helmet harm study Plucky mother intent on recovery ACC beneficiary admits he cheated Cafe's stub-out stance a winner Doctor sceptical about boy's alternative cancer care Calls to stop the spread of fast food outlets Information withheld puts children 'at risk' Kiwi scientist urges halt to doomsday flu research

The number of children having abortions has almost doubled over the past 20 years.

The latest statistics have prompted calls for parents to be informed if their daughter is considering an abortion, but health professionals say the move would be "disastrous".

Last year, 79 girls aged from 11 to 14 had abortions. Of those, 68 were 14-year-olds and 13 aged 11 to 13.

The latest figure is nearly twice the 43 girls under 14 who had abortions in 1991. While the figures have generally been rising, the peak was in 2005, when 105 girls aged 14 and under had an abortion.

Family First director Bob McCoskrie said it was outrageous that parents had to sign a consent form for their child to go on a school trip to the zoo but could be left in the dark if their 11-year-old was having an abortion.

Family First and Prolife New Zealand have been campaigning for parents to have the legal right to be informed if their daughter is considering an abortion.

A law change that would have made it mandatory, backed by National MP Judith Collins, was voted down in 2004.

McCoskrie said a recent Family First-commissioned poll found 80 per cent of people thought parents should be told if their daughter was pregnant and considering an abortion.

He said there was support for the idea within the National Party, but no-one seemed willing to push through a law change.

"Abortion is the only procedure or event in a teenager's life where for no good reason good parents are legally excluded," he said.

Wellington teenager Jasmine Thomas said she felt pressured by staff at a youth health clinic to have an abortion from the moment she found she was pregnant.

The 17-year-old said she did not want one, but was given nearly 20 pamphlets on abortion to take home.

Questions from doctors and peer pressure from friends meant she started to consider a termination, but decided against it after her 12-week scan.

"I think heaps [of young people] get pressured into it," she said.

Thomas, who is due in nine weeks, said parents should have the right to know if their daughter was considering an abortion, but not to interfere in her decision.

Christchurch youth health physician Sue Bagshaw said any move to make informing parents mandatory would be "disastrous".

Girls would be too frightened to access health care, which would mean more unwanted babies, she said.

"I would be really concerned they would turn to back-street abortions or do it themselves."

Bagshaw said she knew a 13-year-old who had tried to terminate her own pregnancy because she was too scared to tell her parents or go to a doctor.

Ad Feedback

She said the accusation that young people were being encouraged to have abortions was wrong.

Christchurch GP and Lyndhurst operating surgeon Pippa MacKay said doctors would not want to break their patient's confidentiality by informing parents about a planned abortion, but they urged young girls to tell their parents.

Reasons for not informing parents included fear of a bad reaction or the parents trying to influence the decision. Some girls did not want to let their parents down or worry them, or wanted to tell them later in life.

MacKay said most young girls had a "responsible adult" in their life who knew about their situation.

Canterbury-West Coast Secondary Principals Association chairman Denis Pyatt said the relationship school counsellors had with pupils was based on 100 per cent confidentiality. Although parents wanted to know what was going on with their children, the laws were in place to protect young people's rights, he said.

Abortion Law Reform Association president Dame Margaret Sparrow supported the status quo whereby parents did not have to be involved when a young girl wanted an abortion.

"In good families where they have good support they are always there, but there are a few situations where parents are not helpful and it makes it really difficult," she said.

- © Fairfax NZ News

40 comments
Post a comment
glennygirl   #40   07:21 am Feb 24 2011

I could write a book on this subject from being a young girl who Was raped by a probation boy, to having a daughter who was pregnant at 16 and because of my past and the terror I felt from loosing a child I actually bonded with!! to abortion, that was commissioned to go ahead illegally by my parents. Then my daughter wanted to keep her baby Then you have a son who maybe has got a girl pregnant.. who knows.. my girls talk to me about everything regarding the topic of sex. and at the end of the day ..these days hopefully parents can't force a child to do anything they don't want to do.To wrongs don't make a right and that is a fact but nothing can seperate us from God's LOve and Grace either: <3

Denise Nielsen   #39   10:44 pm Aug 10 2010

Yes parents do need to know if their child is having an abortion. I have previously been a Counsellor for Pregnancy Counselling Services and have counselled women who have had abortions sometimes up to 20years after the event. Abortion changes people, they are never the same again. The intentional killing of your own child is right up their at the top of the list of traumas that can cause Post Taumatic Stress disorder and if a parent does not know what has happened to their child they cannot be looking for the signs and be getting the right kind of help for their child. Drs use the mental health loop hole in the law to approve abortions but the women may be healthy though stressed when finding out they are pregnant and going through with the normal birthing process but abortion creates mental illness. I think an excellent statistic to be kept, would be, how many people who enter our mental health wards or go on depression or anxiety medication have previously had an abortion.

Rebekah   #38   04:01 pm Jul 13 2010

Abortion is murder, and it needs to be stopped. From the time of conception, it is a human being, a child, a girl or boy. My husband and I would gladly adopt any unwanted babies. I definitely agree with Bob McCroskie that underaged girls wanting abortions, need their parents consent. You do actually need parental consent at highschool for taking a panadol!!! Wake up NZ and stop the tide of child sacrifice.

Lillipie_81   #37   11:19 pm Jul 08 2010

If a girl goes to a doctor for an abortion and they are under age doesn't it make sense that they should recieve assistance from both family and a support worker of some kind before a decision is made? It is true that many young girls have become pregnant due to rape and likely within the family if so, but that doesn't mean that the family know about the abuse. I can see why it would be considered appropriate to abort a product of incest but that is not going to fix the problem, if family are involved it makes available a situation to see abusers prosectuted and families to rebuild and support each other. If things are done secretly how can one be sure that other members of the family are not also being abused or at risk in some way?.

nurseV   #36   07:31 pm Jul 08 2010

for those with an opinion put yourself in the situation of being the pregnant girl. Not everyone gets pregnant by choice, contraception can fail. Those who quote statistics, where are your figures from? "infections post termination etc" this would be credible if it was from a source oher than a small mind with probably no medical knowledge

Andrew Stevenson   #35   01:03 pm Jul 08 2010

Interesting.

As a statistician I find this article frustrating. Given population growth of 2 or 3 per cent per year, then in 20 years I would expect ANY statistic to almost double.

Combine that with, say, an changing age distribution in the population and you could easily get to "almost double" without anything else being a factor.

So... medical, moral and ethical issues aside, it's a shame the article didn't spend an extra half an hour doing some more research on statistics.govt.nz.

Teresa of A Caring Place   #34   12:33 am Jul 08 2010

What is both sickening and at the same time astounding is that at no time has the issue been addressed of the fact that these young girls are UNDER AGE. It is statistically true that the YOUNGER the girl, the OLDER the male - usually young girls of 14 and under are being sexually abused - yes abused - by males in the 20+ age group. So that is the FIRST issue that should be addressed and these males should be taken to court for CARNAL KNOWLEDGE.

And the dramatic language used by the pro-abortion lobby saying it would be 'disasterous' if parents were told their daughters were considering an abortion is ridiculous!!! Parents have a RIGHT to know what is happening in their under-age daughters life - that is GOOD PARENTING.

By the usual convoluted logic obvious today, parents have to sign permission forms for appendicts to be removed, for their child to have a panadol, and yes, to go to the zoo but currently NOT to have their young daughter secreted away to have her unborn baby torn from her womb. Sick logic!

jake   #33   11:12 pm Jul 07 2010

The reason for the law stating parents are not legally required to be informed was made to STOP parents insisting on their daughters having abortions.

Funny how the worm turns.

steve   #32   07:26 pm Jul 07 2010

The sad thing about this is that the person who has the most to lose from an abortion has no say in the matter. That is the baby. If the baby did have a say I bet it would say "don't kill me" There is no such thing as an unwanted baby. There are thousands of people wishing to adopt and love a baby.

PB   #31   04:04 pm Jul 07 2010

David #13 "Let's put all questions of morality aside. If my 11 year old daughter was going to be undergoing surgery of _any_ kind, I would want to know about it."

Sure let's put morality aside, but what about responsibility? Where were you when your 11-year-old daughter was having sex and getting pregnant? Why did you not give her the talk about consequences of having unprotected sex? If you had a good relationship and supported her choices, she'd probably tell you. I don't think you have an automatic right to know.


Show 1-30 of 40 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content