Dirty politics part of the job: study

AIMEE GULLIVER
Last updated 12:17 08/09/2014

Relevant offers

Politics

David Slack: 'I was holding a beer when the revolution started' Election 2017: Blood in the political waters opens the door for an upset Here are the numbers, what about the vision 'We are owed something out here' - Poto Williams in Christchurch East Government tops up Southern Response funding to $1.5b We run the ruler over the Government's family income package Budget 2017: Nine years of spending under National First home buyers question how the Budget helps them Colin Craig's tactics against Rachel MacGregor revealed 'It's not easy' says candidate who withdrew from election race in East Coast Bays

Career politicians specialising in digging dirt are at the heart of the prominence of "dirty politics" in New Zealand, according to a new study.

Almost one-third of sitting MPs have spent most of their lives in politics, even before they entered Parliament, according to the study by Geoffrey Miller, of the University of Otago.

The research was commissioned by Blackland PR director Mark Blackham, who said politics was now a professionalised game where underhanded denigration of opponents was considered part of the job description.

"Career politicians find it easier to be against something than for it – so it is essential to demonise your opponents," Blackham said.

Miller said the absence of policy differences between the two main parties made them almost interchangeable – meaning some were keen to distract voters with scandal.

"In 2014, it would be difficult to imagine National repeating its famous 2005 billboard campaign in which it directly contrasted its policies with Labour's – because there is now so little difference," he said.

The billboard campaign had highlighted different policies, including infamously comparing "iwi" with "Kiwi".

"Working for Families, KiwiSaver and subsidising first-time home buyers are all examples of policies which Labour and National now largely agree on," Miller said.

The results of the study showed a "flattening out" of differences between working histories of MPs in each party.

In the past, differences between parties were starker – with more businesspeople in National, and almost none in Labour.

Now, differences in the careers of MPs in each political party were very small, with 18 per cent of National MPs having worked in a business background, compared to 12 per cent in Labour.

"We're seeing people enter Parliament because of their own self-interest, not their life experience," Miller said.

National MPs had the most experience in agriculture and business or property development, with 12 in each category.

Labour MPs were most likely to have had no single dominant career, or to have worked for the government in some way.

Proportionately, NZ First had the most MPs with business backgrounds, while the dominant working history of Green MPs was in unions or activist agencies.

Ad Feedback

- Stuff

Special offers
Opinion poll

Should the speed limit be raised to 110kmh on some roads?

Yes

No

Vote Result

Related story: 110kmh limit moves closer

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content