Ad Feedback

PM: Harawira's white tirade 'deeply offensive'

By MICHAEL FIELD - Stuff.co.nz
Last updated 17:36 06/11/2009

PM John Key on Harawira trip

Audio: PM on Harawira's comments

John Key and Hone Harawira
COALITION PAIN: John Key and Hone Harawira.

Related Links

'Public wonder' over Harawira's holiday Paris is lovely this time of year Harawira's Paris jaunt prompts concern PM John Key on Harawira trip

Relevant offers

Politics

Sharples' stepson to be ordained in marae first Buy your furniture or we'll sell it, Crown tells ministers Harawira may not be forced out of party Consultants 'scandalous waste of money' Complaints about Harawira flood in 'Sticking points' stall ETS Parents know better than you, Children's Commissioner told Auckland Supercity structure unveiled Copenhagen negotiations on track - Groser National makes progress on ETS bill support

The Maori Party says it is "on the verge" of disciplining MP Hone Harawira over his behaviour despite him apologising for any harm he has done to the party.

The party held a teleconference this afternoon after Mr Harawira lashed out at white people over criticism that he bunked off a work trip to visit Paris.

He has apologised for any harm to his party, but not for his actions.

 

Harawira reacted to an email criticising him for bunking off a work trip to visit Paris by lashing out at white people.

In an email exchange released to Radio New Zealand, Mr Harawira accused "white motherf***ers" of "puritanical bullshit" for expecting him to follow the rules.

"Hone has a history of making intemperate and outrageous comments and this one is right up there," Mr Key told reporters a short time ago.

 

Prime Minister John Key has labelled MP Hone Harawira's email on white people "deeply offensive" and he wants action from coalition partner the Maori Party.

"Hone Harawira has made a statement that is deeply offensive to a lot of New Zealanders."

The MP was already in trouble. This morning his party co-leader Tariana Turia expressed concerns his unscheduled side trip to Paris during a taxpayer funded work trip last month would damage the party's reputation.

Mr Harawira skipped a meeting in Brussels so he and his wife Hilda could spend a day in Paris. He paid for the extra travel himself.

Buddy Mikaere of Buddy Mikaere and Associates wrote an email to Mr Harawira complaining about his actions.

"... you're no better than that w***er Rodney Hide and the white mofos you complain about," Mr Mikaere wrote, referring to Mr Hide's actions in taking his partner on an overseas ministerial trip despite the Prime Minister John Key's direction against the practice.

"And get off you moral high horse while you're at it - nobody forced you to be an MP."

Mr Harawira wrote back starting his email; "Gee Buddy, do you believe that white man bullshit too do you?

"White motherf***ers have been raping our lands and ripping us off for centuries and all of a sudden you want me to play along with their puritanical bullshit."

Mr Harawira then went on to say how much time and energy he put into fighting for Maori and what a big role his wife Hilda played in that.

"And quite frankly I don't give a shit what you or anyone else thinks about it. OK?"

Ad Feedback

Then he added a postscript saying he should feel free to go to the media.

"I answer to my people, not to them or to anybody else."

Mr Key said Mr Harawira's language was not appropriate.

But he was sent a "very provocative email and that's what he responded to but I don't think that makes it right."

He will leave the Maori Party to deal with him.

"I am going to leave that to them, ultimately he is a Maori Party MP, he is not a member of the cabinet, and not a member of the government and so in that regard it is for them to deal with."

Mr Key says Parliament always attracts "interesting personalities … who make provocative statements."

Mr Harawira was a firebrand

"He's made those statements outside parliament and has made them inside parliament."

Mr Harawira was already in considerable hot water with Speaker Lockwood Smith saying he may have to pay back some of the trip's overall cost and Mrs Turia revealing she had been led to believe the reason he skipped the meeting was illness.

"I'm very concerned, my understanding was he was ill over in Brussels but it would appear... that he went off to Paris for a trip, that it was quite a deliberate thing," she told Radio New Zealand.

"The worry for me is that Hone was the leader of that delegation and I guess that what we are going to be questioned about in future, in terms of any trips overseas, is that 'can we give a guarantee that this won't happen again, it happened in Australia?' And with hand over heart I don't think we can give that guarantee."

In 2007 Mr Harawira was told to pay back some flights after he left mid-way through a four-day select committee trip to Melbourne, so he could visit Aboriginal groups in Alice Springs.

Labour deputy leader Annette King yesterday said Mr Harawira's actions showed why the public wondered about MPs' perks.

"I think that really does make people wonder about parliamentary travel and taxpayers' money."

Mrs Turia was concerned about that and how Mr Harawira's actions would reflect on the party.

"All of us have to be really conscious as to the perception that's created as to how we use public funds, the public doesn't actually fund us to go on holidays and to have a look around and that's the reality."

Mr Harawira has been unrepentant about his actions, saying he missed nothing by skipping the meeting as he had already met those attending the meeting and discussed issues with them.

He did not think he should have to pay back any money and was glad he had undertaken the side trip, saying it would have been "dumb" not to visit such a wonderful city.

The other two MPs in the delegation, National MP Katrina Shanks and Labour MP Rajen Prasad, attended the meeting, which discussed relations between the EU and New Zealand, family and youth policies and multiculturalism.

- With NZPA

* Comments are now closed on this story.

250 comments
japsy   #250   02:33 pm Nov 06 2009

I'm not a "white person" but a Japanese. I feel for indigenous people who were persecuted by invaders, not necessarily white people. Yes, Maori did the same. Maori killed off Moriori. But I cannot accuse Maori of this. The human history has seen countless invasions (especially until the mid-20th century). Mr. Harawira, if you had made the same accusation 500 years ago, you'd surely have made yourself a laughing stock. The human race has been evolving not only technologically but politically, ecnonomically and ethically. The ethical viewpoint on which you base your argument was discovered/reached and is (if not perfectly) practiced mostly by "white" people. You'd never have discovered this kind of view if it had not been for the invasion by white people. Isn't it ironical? Anyway, you cannot denouce, standing on the modern ethical viewpoint, other races for what they did long time ago. What's really important is to eliminate discrimination and hostility among different races in the country (the whole world for that matter). If racial issues continue to divide the nation, there won't be a bright future for NZ.

Margaret   #249   01:20 pm Nov 06 2009

If Hone Harawira doesn't get sacked after today's verbal outburst, I am losing faith in our Prime Minister. The last few weeks Hone has showed his disregard for tax payers when he said on TV that he "didn't give a s**t about them. Then his arrogance over the Paris trip and now his comments about white people. He can not come under authority and shown this on many occasions by his speech. There should be no room given for apartheid in parliament, and it should be dealt with quick and smart. These comments only cause more division between us, as a people and as a country. "A house divided cannot stand."

Bevan   #248   01:00 pm Nov 06 2009

We need better code of conduct for MPs - on and off work. It's a bad look. They need, like, an MP-PP - a minister of parliament police person who can pull out the whip or in the style of that guy 'put a cap in da a***'. The guy needs to chill out. Anger management stuff. Orthopaedic frikken implant. His shoulder is so chipped, he's lost it completely.

Michael   #247   12:57 pm Nov 06 2009

Hone Harawira is ignorant and offensive and must be sacked. Anything less is just unacceptable. The Maori Party will never receive any vote of confidence from me while he is a part of it. And while National continue to sit on their hands about this kind of behaviour, they are rapidly losing my support also.

TonyC   #246   12:57 pm Nov 06 2009

John Key really thinks we will stay with MMP?

K-dog   #245   12:56 pm Nov 06 2009

Fact - Maori civilisation was changed and dominated forever when Europeans arrived on these shores but it's something that was 100% part of the European culture (culture is used by Maori as a excuse all to often) but this also happened within Maori culture towards other Maori and don't forget the Moriori. My point being culture isn't an excuse for wrong doings. I think Harawira's actions are hypocritical and destrutive towards relations between New Zealanders (perhaps the objective). Maori need to be more realistic with their goals and these sort of rebellious acts benifit Maori no way and won't inspire Maori youth to succeed in the world they live. Mr Harawira might want to remember that if it wasn't for the "white man" there wouldn't be opportunity for a Maori to visit Paris, hell they wouldn't even know it existed. Anyone else find this hypocritical?

DS1   #244   12:49 pm Nov 06 2009

This guy is a fool. Crazy that he can make such remarks as a member of parliament. He has to go, if not by the hand of his party, then parliament itself must do something. I'd personally have no problem filing a personal greivance against him for corruption (he's fruadulently spending my hard earned dollars) and racisim... if someone dosen't file, I will!

The irony is that he has set us back about 30 years in terms of our bicultural relationships in this country - the Maori party must act on this - cultural inclusion is the only reason they can justify having a seat in parliament and now they are openly destroying it...

Aahhh... nobody give me a gun!

Bruce Clement   #243   12:45 pm Nov 06 2009

MMP isn't fully proportional and Harawira represents a first past the post (FPP) seat so 97% of New Zealanders can't sack him, only the people on the roll for his electorate can.

The FPP seats are supposed to allow communities of interest to be represented in the parliament and from what I can see, just as Dr Sharples represents well educated and affluent maori, Harawira most adequetly represents a minority we unfortunately do have in this society.

His presence in parliament is just a part of ensuring that minorities are represented there

Raymond   #242   12:42 pm Nov 06 2009

Harawira is racist, and apparently proud of the fact. He should not be in parliament. And what a lazy man he is, bunking off work (AT OUR EXPENSE) so he and his wife (WHO PAID HER AIRFARE?) could go sightseeing. And he apparently paid for this day's outing himself, big flashy deal. What is it now, 25 Euro for the train from Brussels down to Paris and back?

Embarrassed Kiwi   #241   12:38 pm Nov 06 2009

As a Kiwi living overseas but keeping track of what`s going on back home, I have to say that I used to be proud of the fact that the NZ government took a very proactive role in trying to right the wrongs of many years ago. However, when I see such carrying-ons as this so-called "MP", I am very much ashamed to say I am a Kiwi. I mean, after all that the government has tried to do in order to make ammends for some of the shocking things 150 odd years ago, there are still some people who, surprisingly have been elected to a MP post, harbor strong resentment towards the so-called "white man". Would this MP like to return to the days when there were no modern conveniences, like airplanes to take him and his wife halfway around the world, or education, health care, etc? I am sure he would be the first person to scream blue murder if these advancements in technology, and conveniences were taken away. Further, and I am not trying to justify anything that has happened in the past, if it wasn`t the British who colonized NZ, then who would it have been? The Spanish, or perhaps even worse the arrogant Americans? Just ask the Hawaiins about what happened to them!! What I would like readers of my comment to realise is that I don`t wish to see NZ`s image tarnished by one person`s idiotic behaviour. I feel that NZ has made big headway into righting the wrongs and now is not the time to ruin all that hard work!! Everyone, just forget this MP`s stupid escapade, let him shoot himself down in flames, forget about him and continue to move on in the positive fight of bringing all Kiwi`s closer as one nation. If you want a reminder of perhaps how fortunate you are, take a quick look across the ditch and see how the Aborignes have been and still are treated. For sure life has been tough for our native people at times, and I`m not trying to detract from that, but isn`t NZ about building a strong country of ONE people? i.e. Kiwi`s not "white men vs Maori" stop and think about it for a moment!! Is it worth getting your "ni__ers in a knot" over one person`s ridiculous actions? I think not. Have a great day NZ and keep up the good fight!! I would like to continue to say I am proud to be a Kiwi. (but currently feeling a bit embarrassed when reading this of article.)


Show 191-240 of 250 comments
Ad Feedback
Special offers

Featured Promotions