Key denies bowing to China on Dalai Lama

By MARTIN KAY - The Dominion Post
Last updated 05:00 19/11/2009

Relevant offers

Politics

$4b in tax cuts coming Outrage as Key signals national park mining Plan to claw back $1.7b by axing depreciation tax breaks PM on knife edge finding the cash to pay for changes Careful words leave little wriggle room Goff has a bob each way on Tiptoe Tuesday Alliance election broadcasting complaint upheld Anti mining talk of 'war' ACC admits sending confidential info in error Key signals mining on conservation land

Prime Minister John Key has been accused of caving to pressure from China after saying he will not meet the Dalai Lama.

Mr Key denied China had leaned on him, but conceded its well-known disapproval of world leaders who meet the exiled Tibetan spiritual leader was a factor in his decision.

"I had some discussions with the Foreign Minister [Murray McCully] about it. I think we would understand the way the Chinese would deal with these things, but on the other side of the coin, that wasn't the over-riding factor. There were a number of factors involved."

The Dalai Lama is in Auckland for two days next month. He will meet Labour leader Phil Goff, who also met him when he was foreign affairs minister.

Mr Key said he told Chinese President Hu Jintao of his decision when they spoke at the Apec summit in Singapore last weekend, but Mr Hu had not raised the issue.

The decision is contrary to Mr Key's previous position that he would meet the Dalai Lama if his diary allowed.

Dalai Lama Visit Trust spokesman Neil Cameron said China may not have overtly influenced Mr Key, but it did not need to. "The decision was inevitable given the reluctance of New Zealand governments to meet with the Dalai Lama in recent years. There can be only one reason for that, and that reason is China's political and economic influence in New Zealand."

Mr Goff declined to comment on Mr Key's decision.

United States President Barack Obama and Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd are among leaders who have recently declined to meet the Dalai Lama.

Ad Feedback
39 comments
Post a comment
glowbug   #39   04:11 am Nov 21 2009

@ Jonathan #36 - That's a well phrased and thought out response. However, New Zealanders Have a history of standing up for what we believe to be morally right, even if our views are contrary to whoever the current world power or powers be . A more recent example of this would have been our anti-nuclear stance , which angered the United States greatly . There may have been repercussions from this , but they have all been bearable. In a similar way , If Mr Key had chosen to meet the Dalai Lama, it would've been a subtle message to the Chinese Government that New Zealanders do not agree with the invasion and occupation of Tibet. If there was a economic reaction from China to this , I doubt it would have been too severe. Diplomatically speaking , it is a step down from Mr Key openly denouncing the invasion, which I believe would bring on a more serious political and economic response , but it would still send a message that New Zealand does not approve of international Bullies.

Justice   #38   05:47 pm Nov 20 2009

claire #34 02:29 am Nov 20 2009

"John Key has better things to do with his time - things which will have a positive impact on NZ. John Key is a Great PM."

JK is fast becoming a "sell-out". Does he have no respect for OUR sovereignty? Then prove it John.

Jason   #37   04:31 pm Nov 20 2009

It is Key’s own discretion to meet Dalai Lama or not. He doesn’t have to be told by neither Chinese government nor the Greenies here. We shouldn’t give any credit to what the Chinese Communism have done. But bear in mind, under Dalai Lama’s regime, Tibet was a slavery society, where human were treated like animal. It is such an irony for him to talk about human rights! He should be trialed in International Justice Court!

Jonathan   #36   02:14 pm Nov 20 2009

Oh get off your high horses people, politics isnt about doing what is morally right 100% of the time, but doing what is best for the country, sometimes you have to do things that fly in the face of what you believe in the that world. Key is probably dissapointed that he cannot meet the Dalai Lama due to political tension from China, but to do so in the face of the consequences would ruin us, it would be a poor choice. I personally am dissapointed that he cannot meet him, but will not flick mud at him for making the "right choice" politically even if it sucks moraly

james   #35   10:26 am Nov 20 2009

Um, hello people what do you think NZ is? A superpower? The fact is that even the USA is bowing to China these days... How can NZ go against China if even the USA is afraid to? Also, don't compare Helen Clarke meeting with him to now. Things have changed since then. The Chinese government recently upgraded the consequences for any government meeting with the Dalai Lama, so it wasn't as serious back then.

claire   #34   02:29 am Nov 20 2009

John Key has better things to do with his time - things which will have a positive impact on NZ. John Key is a Great PM.

Les   #33   10:49 pm Nov 19 2009

China has an unelected dictatorship,and has invaded Tibet,I think the Dali Lama should get as much moral support as we can give,especially from our P M

giovanni   #32   10:40 pm Nov 19 2009

To be a leader you need a lot of people dumb enough to follow.

Craig   #31   09:40 pm Nov 19 2009

This just shows that Keys is not fit to lead our great country. He should be forced to resign, he is an embarrassment to all Kiwis

Jeremy   #30   09:04 pm Nov 19 2009

The Primeminister can choose not to meet the Dalai Lama if he wishes.

The Dalai Lama is Buddhist, he needs not defend the teachings and neither does anyone else. The Buddha defends himself!

"Never argue with a fool, onlookers may not be able to tell the difference." -attributed to Mark Twain & The Bible (But it's quite Zen...)


Show 1-29 of 39 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you sign in, you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions