Key shoots down Australian union

Last updated 09:57 15/03/2010
Opinion poll

Should New Zealand become a state of Australia?

Yes

No

Vote Result

John Key on Australian map illustration
John Key illustration by Murray Webb. Background by AFR.
JOHN KEY: 'We would be fools to think there is some sort of illusionary goal of merging with Australia would solve problems that New Zealand faces.'

Relevant offers

Politics

Govt says asset sales will cut debt Greens: Crafar approval politically motivated Banks named as new ACT leader China 'will see Crafar ruling as racist' Govt may sell smaller slice of SOEs BSA grilled over John Key radio show TVNZ show dumps Labour leader Mallard offers ticket cash back Email hacking managed well, says Key Today In Politics: Friday, February 17

Prime Minister John Key says New Zealand needs to fix problems itself and merging with Australia is no answer.

A UMR poll conducted for Television New Zealand's Question and Answer programme yesterday showed most New Zealanders were against the idea of New Zealand becoming an Australian state.

Of those polled, 71 percent of New Zealanders were opposed, with 45 percent strongly opposed.

Australians were less strongly against the idea, with 52 percent opposed with 26 percent strongly opposed.

When asked if New Zealand would be better off if it joined with Australia, 37 percent of New Zealanders said yes, 27 percent said no and 25 percent felt it would make no difference.

Speaking on the programme former deputy prime minister Sir Don McKinnon said he believed union was "probably inevitable", but felt it would be the next generation who would look into it as links between the two countries continued to grow.

Mr Key told NewstalkZB the debate was pointless.

"It's not going to happen and I don't think we should waste any time even thinking about it. The reality is what will make New Zealand a successful country are the same things that would make it a successful state of Australia."

New Zealand needed policies to encourage investment and tackle issues around education and bureaucracy, areas the Government was tackling.

"In my view we would be fools to think there is some sort of illusionary goal of merging with Australia would solve problems that New Zealand faces."

Australian politician Peters Slipper told Question and Answer Australians were more relaxed about the prospect of union than New Zealanders but proposals such as a joint currency should be looked at instead.

Labour leader Phil Goff believed that New Zealanders would never consider submerging their identity with Australia and more work should be done on building on a single economic market.

When Australia was formed, its constitution was drawn up to allow New Zealand to join the federation of states, but New Zealand backed away from the idea then.

Ad Feedback

- NZPA

100 comments
Post a comment
matt   #100   10:39 pm Mar 16 2010

rofl@95! DUDE.. you WOULD be in Australia if this went ahead.

ian   #99   10:27 pm Mar 16 2010

ahh... completely disregard what i just said, especially if you are in the Australian defense department, nz is not planning on taking over Australia

Croatian   #98   10:15 pm Mar 16 2010

The Saint #16 said that Australia has the most beautiful women in the world. That must be a joke. He should find time to visit ex. Yugoslavia :-).

Union with Australia is way to go. NZ is too small for modern world economy.

Rob   #97   04:11 pm Mar 16 2010

Im all for it. Shifted back to nz 3 months ago and have already decided to shift back. Earn less here, lose 25% of what we send back to top up mortgages there, and pay $20 for every transaction we make between the countries, one westpac account to another. I look at people here and wonder why you are working so hard for so little. This needs to happen for the benifit of everyone in NZ. All the PROUD KIWIS just need to relise that there is not really that much to be proud of. BTW Aussie has got heaps of water, anyone who has been up to north queensland would know this.

Another Murray   #96   01:32 pm Mar 16 2010

Personally I wouldn't want to have the operation required to bvecome an Australian citizen

trueblue   #95   01:32 pm Mar 16 2010

If this happens I'm moving to Oz!

suresh   #94   12:53 pm Mar 16 2010

Dont go there!

It's all greek to me   #93   11:57 am Mar 16 2010

After seeing what's happening in Europe lately, any idea of a Union seems a little ill-timed.

Si   #92   10:39 am Mar 16 2010

add this to the lsit of pointless debates

The flag is fine No we are part of the Monarchy No we are NZ not a state of Australia

Next ?

a   #91   10:12 am Mar 16 2010

I would not agree with being a part of Australia, yeah there are probably benefits to it but Australia are the USA's BFF and will back any war that America are up for.

Would you really support a merger if it meant our troops were shipped off in higher numbers to fight America's battles???????? I know I wouldn't.


Show 41-90 of 100 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Does a $6 billion return change your view on asset sales?

Yes, I'm now against them

Yes, I'm for them

No, I'm still for them

No, I'm still against them

Undecided

Vote Result

Related story: Govt says asset sales will cut debt

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Pagani blog pointer small

John Pagani - Left leaning

Don't set Treaty back 25 years

David Farrar blog pointer small

By the Numbers: David Farrar watches the polls

Mallard's tickets: it's not a good look

The Whip blog pointer small

Andrea Vance and John Hartevelt on politics

A rough job for English's asset sales