Kiwis split over higher alcohol prices

BY VERNON SMALL
Last updated 05:00 03/05/2010
Opinion poll

Will increasing the price of alcohol discourage drinking?

Yes

No

I'm not sure

Vote Result

LIQUOR PRICES: A Fairfax Media survey of readers last week found they were divided over the wisdom of increasing alcohol tax.
Fairfax Media
LIQUOR PRICES: A Fairfax Media survey of readers last week found they were divided over the wisdom of increasing alcohol tax.

Relevant offers

Politics

Shake-up heading in EQC's direction Brownlee turns up heat on council over rebuild Agency mulled to run emergency 111 system MPs' travel bills leap during election Remedial work for navy's problem ship Wait for new oil law before awarding permits, Govt urged TVNZ included in police Electoral Act investigation Sea law 'an environmental risk' Govt defends 50c an hour minimum wage lift Maori queue-jumping for SOEs raised

New Zealanders are evenly divided over whether the price of alcohol should be increased to discourage drinking, a move already ruled out by the Government.

A Law Commission report last week recommended a 50 per cent rise in excise tax, to push up the price of alcohol by 10 per cent, as one of a package of measures aimed at discouraging binge-drinking and curbing anti-social behaviour.

Justice Minister Simon Power and Prime Minister John Key were quick to rule out a tax rise on alcohol, though they swiftly increased taxes on tobacco last week by 10 per cent, with two more increases of 10 per cent in the next two years.

However, a Fairfax Media survey of readers last week found they were divided over the wisdom of increasing alcohol tax. Of the 1445 people surveyed, 48 per cent agreed alcohol prices should go up by 10 per cent. The same proportion disagreed.

There was stronger support for a rise shown by readers of The Press (56 per cent) than by The Dominion Post (46 per cent). Readers of The Waikato Times were in between, with 48 per cent in favour.

Comments made with the survey showed a near-universal acceptance that there is an alcohol problem – largely youth-related – and that it is putting a big burden on society.

Sample comments by readers included:

Raising the age and tax doesn't go far enough. Alcohol is so readily available in supermarkets and will still be a loss leader for them and will still be cheap.

I think people over 20 should not be penalised for the actions of the under 20s by raising the price of alcohol.

At 18 we can marry, vote and die for our country. Can't have a beer? Ridiculous.

Alcohol awareness needs to be taught in schools ... and parents need to be taught how to talk to their kids about drinking and set a good example. Restricting the age limits will only make kids drink illegally at home ... raising prices will affect retailers more than curb drinking habits.

It is the culture of drinking we need to address, rather than taking away the right of 18-year-olds to choose.

Ad Feedback

- © Fairfax NZ News

41 comments
Post a comment
critical stimuli   #41   07:54 pm May 03 2010

I find it fascinating that so many people seem to equate civil rights with the right to drink poison. I wish I could come up with a similar scheme and fool people to believe 'that' and sell them some stuff that hooks them on to my product and make them believe they can fly or do something outrages, like 'think logically'. Whilst the real issues of democratic rights are for example the water privatization plans by Hide and his fellow corporate brown noses selling our resources off to the highest bidder and ones the whole of Canterbury is one big cow toilet sell us the 'filtered' expensive water to consume... what a scheme! Sounds just like the scheme of selling people poison and making them believe its cool, adds to their sex appeal and general well being... what a load of bullsh.t! Wake up New Zealand, freedom does not come in form of a bigger shopping mall it's the opposite... and besides if it would not endanger my kids or other people and myself and would not put financial pressure on those who are not so stupid to fall for that shit in bottles called alcohol, I would not give a toss if all those who 'love' it would kill themselves with that crap within their own four walls.

Joe   #40   05:46 pm May 03 2010

Bring on the price rise. Not really gonna effect the binge drinking. (like my self) If i'm out for a night every couple weeks price doesn't really bother me. I'm out to get drunk not pennysave. It will effect the one's who need to drink every day. The people who drink every day are the ones getting in there car cause they think they're fine after a few drinks cause they do it every day. on the other hand if i have a few drinks, it'll turn into 12-15 and i'm not driving anywhere LOL.

HL   #39   04:20 pm May 03 2010

Public intoxiaction should be made a crime. Offenders to be shot on sight.

William   #38   04:01 pm May 03 2010

Jasmine #36 01:44 pm May 03 2010 the problem is that NZ'ers don't teach their kids how to drink.

That would be because most of the parents in question have an alcohol abuse problem themselves but choose to pretend it's normal.

Andy   #37   02:49 pm May 03 2010

oh now we have the drinkers moan, im a smoker and yes the price did go up but over this weekend there has been 6 people killed on our roads, weather its booze of not, the drinking age should be raised back to 25 and be done with it, same with smoking.

Jasmine   #36   01:44 pm May 03 2010

the problem is that NZ'ers don't teach their kids how to drink. Restrictions dont solve the problem. I had the odd drink with my parents from a young age and now at 20 can handle my alcohol unlike many others of my generation. I say adopt the culture of european countries. If its not such a taboo then you wont have so many teenyboppers roaming the streets drinking or off their face in bars because they know how to drink responsibly!

Shane   #35   01:38 pm May 03 2010

I read a report which stated the social cost of drinking to be 6.9b dollars and the revenue brought in by alcohol to contribute to this cost is $900m. Surely the figures speak for themselves... Something needs to be done. I do not believe the drinking age should be raised unless they simultaneously raise the voting, marriage, enlistment etc ages. I believe off license prices should be raised and on licence prices reduced to bring the drinking to a place where it is supervised. I think that we should focus on education rather than a bottom of the cliff strategy. Offer solutions and rational argument rather than hust getting aggressive for either side of the argument.

Sarah   #34   01:23 pm May 03 2010

Banning or putting up the price of RTD's is stupid, because they actually make alot of people drink less. If you buy a 12 box of bourbon and coke then theres only 12 drinks you can drink. If you buy a bottle of bourbon and mix the drinks yourself then you can have way more than 12 drinks, and the drinks usually get stronger as the night goes on.

Nikki   #33   01:10 pm May 03 2010

Tobacco is our second biggest legal social problem so I had no problem supporting the tax hike but alchohol is our biggest social problem and I would have no problem supporting that too. What annoys me is that the party I voted for socked the tax hike into the relatively small group of smokers, but for what can only be political reasons is happy for children to be served high alchohol content drinks and will not rise tax on alchohol. I do not mind paying more for my drink. Smoking I don't do anyway. But I do mind living in a country with double standards and politicians like our PM who govern by self-interest (and that of certain lobby groups).

ian of tawa   #32   12:58 pm May 03 2010

@ Ted #18

'those who give up a little liberty to gain a little security, will gain niether, and loose both' - ben franklin.

what Nick#13 is trying to say is we dont need big brother to hold our hand or cuddle us when we trip and scratch our knee.


Show 1-31 of 41 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Do you think politicians spend too much on travel?

Yes - they should be reined in

No - travelling is part of their jobs

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Pagani blog pointer small

John Pagani - Left leaning

Don't set Treaty back 25 years

David Farrar blog pointer small

By the Numbers: David Farrar watches the polls

Mondayising Waitangi and Anzac Days

The Whip blog pointer small

Andrea Vance and John Hartevelt on politics

What to do with the Crafar Farms?