Key admits 'socialist streak' comment

KATE CHAPMAN
Last updated 15:20 26/08/2011
'SOCIALIST STREAK': Prime Minister John Key told United States diplomats all New Zealanders have a
Leilani Hatch/MANAWATU STANDARD
'SOCIALIST STREAK': Prime Minister John Key told United States diplomats all New Zealanders have a "socialist streak".

Relevant offers

Politics

Click Here
Treaty obligations to stay in SOE sales law McCully email thief could be Kiwi PSA disappointed Key won't discuss cuts Delays in privatising ACC work account No background checks on Education ministry staff Labour fears for Kiwis in ministry shake-up The one-seat threshold Today In Politics: Thursday, February 23 Police complaint over election programme McCully's emails revealed

When Prime Minister John Key said all New Zealanders had a "socialist streak" it refered to their caring for others, he says.

A US diplomatic cable from mid-2007 said he met with charge d'affaire Glyn Davies and told him National could not adopt conservative policies because a "socialist streak" runs through all New Zealanders.

He reportedly said it was not as strong as in Sweden, but was there.

The cable was released publicly by the Wikileaks website this week.

Key said he could vaguely remember the meeting and said his comment was during a discussion about very right-wing policies.

"I think New Zealand is a very caring country, I think New Zealanders do have a heart."

New Zealanders did not want to see the "overt" signs of poverty here that were present overseas, he said.

Asked if he had a socialist streak he said "absolutely" and pointed to Government programmes to help people during the global recession.

"I'm a product of the welfare state."

Several US diplomatic cables from Wellington address domestic news and political issues.

A cable from mid-2008 claimed then-Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters had proved his worth in the role despite fears his hard-boiled domestic approach would spill over into the role.

Peters was perceived as being anti-immigration and protectionist, it said, and he was described as a "quick-to-anger and bombastic performer; and an enthusiastic baiter of the media".

Peters was not a details man and the cable suggested former Foreign Affairs Minister Phil Goff was behind much of the policy development.

"But ultimately it is [Helen] Clark who commands New Zealand's foreign policy."

In another cable from May 2008, Goff was described as hard-working and sharing Clark's attention to detail.

"After the ambassador's recent dinner hosted in Minister Goff's honour broke up at 10.30pm, Goff returned to his office to work."

The cables also followed Key's promotion through National's ranks. One dated May 2007 said his persona in private meetings differed little from the face he presented to the public.

The cable said Key also spoke positively about then finance minister Michael Cullen and said the only significant economic problem was the brain drain to Australia.

It said Key was a more natural politician than his predecessor. "Key can join a pickup volleyball game with a group of teenagers without looking entirely fake, while Don Brash's public events often were reminiscent of Governor Dukakis's disastrous tank-driving outing."

Ad Feedback

A number of cables also commented on New Zealand's presence in Afghanistan.

In December 2006, the Singapore Government indicated it would commit personnel to reconstruction efforts there but reportedly wanted to work with the New Zealand team.

That was because of their strong military relationship with New Zealand and past work together in East Timor, it said.

- © Fairfax NZ News

195 comments
Post a comment
The Undertaker   #195   10:33 pm Aug 26 2011

I don’t know how you can not be a socialist.

Money doesn’t make me happy, and it makes other people act strange.

John   #194   10:31 pm Aug 26 2011

@ bridge. #118 02:14 pm Aug 26 2011 "If you don't have a socialist streak then i assume you pay for all your healthcare expenses, all your children's schooling expenses, would rather the unemployed resorted to homelessness and crime, and don't support regulation of financial markets or industries at all."

If you are a top earner you do pay for all your own healthcare as 1) you are in the group that is paying the most tax & 2) you are likely to have private health cover.

Same goes for education.

Re "unemployed resorted to...crime": unemployed and low income already make up the group that commit the most crime. Your point is?

"and don't support regulation of financial markets or industries at all." And that is a bad thing because? Legislation doesn't stop bad people from doing bad things. Cause & effect dictated by ones social peers does.

@ clint #172 05:23 pm Aug 26 2011 "Fair call. Socialism has much to commend it. I would prefer to lean towards socialism than to lean towards individual greed, and I believe the same is true of most kiwis. And I vote National."

I agree. Left leanings indicate common decency. As long as this is met with same in return. Which I don't believe it is at the moment. Seems we had a government that went too far left & destroyed the foundations of our country.

JC   #193   10:23 pm Aug 26 2011

There seems to be a rather large gap in understanding what exactly socialism is and its place in Government and society.

Socialism is closely related to Communism. Ask anybody from the ex Communist states in Eastern/Central/Northern Europe about their feelings about Socialism and they will give you a negative appraisal. Socialism is about controlling wealth and freedoms concentrating it to a few people - now you could say that wealth is concentrated today under capitalism, but under Socialism there is no excape from it.

Socialism has failed in every country it has been adopted in wholesale. Key brings up Sweden but even that country is rejecting it today - not to mention the taxes over there are AWFUL.

Be very careful what you wish for, or think you know about it.

social conscience   #192   09:28 pm Aug 26 2011

Having A social conscience is very differant than being a socialist. Most people in this world fortuanately are the former. Unfortuantely too many New Zealanders are socialists are the latter and believe that the state should be their saviour. Hence that is why Australians enjoy a much higher standard of living because they are willing to look after themselves, whilst the state provides a safety net for the less fortunate.

ST   #191   09:15 pm Aug 26 2011

just came across this...can't believe 190 of you find this newsworthy.....find a freshly painted fence to stare at..

toby   #190   09:06 pm Aug 26 2011

Nelan #182 you mean that country that has higher taxes, stronger trade unions, more unemployed and more spending on indigenous restitution?

kiwi-mor   #189   08:27 pm Aug 26 2011

Egalitarian society would be a more apt description of New Zealanders. Not that socialism is bad.

Taressa   #188   08:04 pm Aug 26 2011

Nicules #121

I cant understand how some one could not be a socialist? Do you not care about your fellow kiwis? Do you not realise that $ does not buy happiness? Socialism is not about bludging it is about looking after each other. Like another poster said they happily pay there taxes knowing it helps others less fortunate. I am the same, I don't agree with someone abusing the benefit however there are plenty of people out there that genuinely need help. Have you ever stopped to consider how these bludgers would impact you if there was no benefit? Let me tell you... the crime would go up and we would be just like the states with homeless people.

Henry   #187   07:44 pm Aug 26 2011

I knew it.....

Anthony Neville   #186   07:12 pm Aug 26 2011

Socialism is and has always been about social control through the machinery of the state. It has nothing to do with caring for others, at least not through the benefactor's willing participation. Nor is it from any sense that what the beneficiary gets is earned. You don't become a successful socialist politician by promoting the voluntary act of giving towards or caring for others. It's only by promising to give people something for nothing that get socialists elected, and they will keep giving until the economy goes bust and mobs of entitlement suck puppies riot in the streets, looting, smashing and burning private property.


Show 136-185 of 195 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Rate the Government's restructuring of the public service:

Good - it's a bloated bureaucracy

Bad - they're cutting too many staff

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Pagani blog pointer small

John Pagani - Left leaning

Don't set Treaty back 25 years

The Whip blog pointer small

Andrea Vance and John Hartevelt on politics

More complex questions on Crafar