Kiwi base 'hid CIA', Hager book claims

VERNON SMALL AND TRACY WATKINS
Last updated 10:45 01/09/2011

Relevant offers

Politics

Click Here
Treaty obligations to stay in SOE sales law McCully email thief could be Kiwi PSA disappointed Key won't discuss cuts Delays in privatising ACC work account No background checks on Education ministry staff Labour fears for Kiwis in ministry shake-up Defence staff eye leaving as morale falls No run on Kiwi farms - Key Crown account deficit soars Maori Party warns Government over SOE sales

The New Zealand army's Bamiyan camp in Afghanistan hid and supported a US Central Intelligence Agency base, a new book claims.

Investigative writer Nicky Hager has released a new book on New Zealand's involvement in Afghanistan, Iraq and "the war on terror", claiming officials and military officers misled politicians and even ignored and broke "clear instructions issued by the Prime Minister and the Government".

The book, called Other People's Wars: New Zealand in Afghanistan, Iraq and the war on terror, has been released to coincide with the 10th anniversary of the September 11 attacks.

Hager says the contingent at the main New Zealand base in Bamiyan, "had actually been sent there mainly to help the Americans".

He said there were two versions of the operation. The authorised one was fed by the Defence Force's public relations machine and was targeted at the Government and Parliament. Its key messages were that the defence personnel were not going to war, the focus of the mission was reconstruction and that the base was very much a Kiwi operation.

He said the truth was that despite media visits and hundreds of soldiers passing through, "the New Zealand military managed to keep secret the fact that they shared the Bamiyan camp with a US intelligence base" whose personnel shared meals with the Kiwis and relied on them for protection and other practical support.

He said evidence pointed to the intelligence officers being CIA. They were dressed in civilian clothes and told the New Zealand soldiers nothing about what they were doing but had free access to what the New Zealanders were doing.

"The New Zealand public was contributing to the protection and support of the CIA base," Hager said.

In the introduction to his book, Hager said access to classified internal documents provided "a view of a culture where some senior officers wanted to obey the Government only when they agreed with it and otherwise quietly undermined its policies and decisions. The same politicisation is seen with some foreign affairs officials".

He suggested the decision by some military and officials to cross the line and involve themselves in politics dated back to their unwillingness to accept New Zealand's anti-nuclear policy of the mid 1980s.

"For these people, the September 11 attacks became an opportunity to achieve their political goals in spite of, and directly in opposition to, the policies and instructions of their civilian leaders."

Hager's book on the so-called "corngate" affair, claiming a cover-up of imported genetically-modified seed, threatened to derail the 2002 election campaign.

Ad Feedback

In 2006, his book The Hollow Men, helped topple former National Party leader Don Brash.

- © Fairfax NZ News

128 comments
Post a comment
willem   #128   12:53 pm Sep 03 2011

Hager's book timely reminds us how ineffective and gullible Clark and Goff really were. Without the book we might be tempted to vote - at least one of them - back into office; as PM no less! Oh, horror. Thanks Nicky!

George   #127   09:43 am Sep 02 2011

All these experts, yet how many of them have had the GUTS to go there?

JD   #126   09:02 am Sep 02 2011

The great thing is; no matter what fantasy Hager writes, or how much his devout followers jump up and down claiming conspiracies and secret right-wing agendas, you will never change a single thing, nothing.

You can stage all the protests you like, write whatever you like, sit around hating those that have the power; but at the end of the day, all you will ever achieve is to raise your blood pressure. Wake up and get with the program.

Ron   #125   08:22 am Sep 02 2011

Nicky Hager is driven by his own commercial interests. If his books were not full of shock horror stories they would not sell. He is a total fraud.

JB   #124   12:29 am Sep 02 2011

To bobo #82

"I have no respect for anyone that joins the armed forces of any country..." Wow, way to go, showing great tolerance and modelling what you believe in there eh bobo. Basically you're saying anyone who doesn't agree with me I don't like, or that does something I don't value or understand is wrong. I suppose if we let people like you run the world with that attitude it would be a better place? Not!

Stuart   #123   12:11 am Sep 02 2011

A few replies... "NZ Aardvark" Comment 81 - you make a comment about the capability of the Defence force when really you should be commenting on the low levels of funding which lead to the security lapse that allowed teh mdeals to be stolen.

"Matt Russell #78" and "Justice 80" - People won't remember Nicky Hager in history because he's generally considered an imbalanced, highly imaginative conspiracy theorist. They don't 'engage' with Nicky Hager because he lacks objectivity and credibility. Are yours by chance the supportive opinions of liberal Arts students or recent graduates? Start with the first obvious question, how exactly would Nicky Hager get access to classified documents. Does he make his own security clearances? Do OIA's now give out supposed classified documents willy-nilly (the answer is no)?

Oh and "Ivor #77... stop watching so many movies. They're clouding your perception of reality.

David Leigh   #122   11:10 pm Sep 01 2011

Access to 'classified documents', eh?

Try googling 'wikileaks unredacted cables guardian'

Garbage Collector   #121   10:55 pm Sep 01 2011

justice #80, to say that Guys like Hager are the REAL patriots of this country is an insult to the rest of heroes this country has or ever had. We have patriots all over hour short history, Maori and Pakeha alike, so please keep things in perspective.

jason c   #120   10:47 pm Sep 01 2011

Hager usually has strains of truth in his books but connects dots that aren't connected or makes leaps that take it too far. This is where he lets down the public, but no doubt builds his traditional constituency. The missteps are why Lange was 'surprised' at some of the 'revelations' in Nicky's book 'Secret Power'. The surprises were the bits that weren't actually true but the product of misjoined dots. Of course Lange was surprised! It is a shame because Nicky could produce much better and authoritative work. His biggest weakness is that he has no firsthand experience working for the military, the agencies he thinks he knows, or the wider government. I also suspect that many of his 'sources' may not actually have the authority or knowledge he imbues them with (or he selectively interprets them). Those who have worked in government (at a decent level) despair at the way he characterises the relationships, motives and actions of their colleagues. Sadly, if people only know about these things from the myths portrayed in movies, television and dubious internet material, it is natural for Nicky's work to seem authoritative, think they are better informed, and believe he is right.

Many people would actually be reassured by the truth, or, in some cases, disappointed to have invested so much of their time and worry into chasing conspiracies that don't exist. Those who do understand the bigger and more complex international picture will understand that the 'truth' (as boring as it REALLY is) is obscured for more sophisticated reasons than Nicky and others portray.

I WILL read his book. I believe his views and motives are honestly held. And, afterall, why let the truth get in the way of a good conspiracy

sunoftzu   #119   10:34 pm Sep 01 2011

Wow, have read a number of comments from (so-called) ex-servicemen, and parents of such, etc. Amazing how many of them missed the point that high level officers have been caught red-handed DISOBEYING ORDERS and misleading their superiors.

As an ex-territorial myself, it really is hard to imagine how they could miss something like that.

It could be that misleading your own nation is 'patriotic' in their minds.....but patriotic to whom I wonder.

In my mind, someone who betrays or misleads their country can only be considered a traitor (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traitor_%28disambiguation%29), and there is certainly nothing patriotic about looking the other way when you know of somebody doing this.


Show 69-118 of 128 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Rate the Government's restructuring of the public service:

Good - it's a bloated bureaucracy

Bad - they're cutting too many staff

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Pagani blog pointer small

John Pagani - Left leaning

Don't set Treaty back 25 years

The Whip blog pointer small

Andrea Vance and John Hartevelt on politics

More complex questions on Crafar