National plan for life to mean life

Last updated 01:26 06/10/2008
NATALIE SLADE/Dominion Post
GETTING HARD: National leader John Key is expected to announce today his two-pronged plan for dealing with the worst violent offenders.

Relevant offers

Politics

Peters demands apology over Whanau Ora row Student loan bill 'a disaster' Gardiner's hui appointment 'inappropriate' Give us a share of SOEs, say Maori Call for McElrea to resign from NZ On Air Defence Force staff stick to Fiji holiday policy Minimum wage rises - by 50 cents Protest at Rotorua SOE sale talk ACT banks on charter schools Outrage over Government's bill tactics

National is poised to drive a stake in the ground over law and order with a plan to put the worst murderers behind bars for life.

It is also planning a "two strikes" policy denying parole to repeat violent offenders.

The moves ratchet up the law-and- order debate after a string of high- profile violent crimes.

The most recent was the killing of 44-year-old office worker Austin Hemmings as he tried to protect a stranger as she was attacked on an Auckland street.

National leader John Key is expected to announce today his two-pronged plan for dealing with the worst violent offenders.

The first part of the plan will be to scrap parole for criminals convicted a second time of any violent offence attracting a prison sentence of five or more years. After their release, they will be monitored for a fixed term.

The types of violent crime targeted include attempted murder, kidnapping, sexual violence, manslaughter, serious assaults, aggravated burglary and robbery.

But the most controversial move will be National's plan to put some murderers behind bars for life. Anyone convicted of murder who has previously received a prison sentence of five years or more for violence will be denied any opportunity for parole, meaning they will spend the rest of their life in prison.

Mr Key will say that 10 murderers sentenced since 2002 would have spent the rest of their life in prison under National's plan - including Graeme Burton, Liam Ashley's killer George Baker, RSA triple killer William Bell and tourist Birgit Brauer's killer, Michael Wallace.

The Government argues that it has already stiffened sentencing and parole laws and, as a consequence, the prison muster has risen by 71 per cent, or 3300 prisoners - a result of prisoners serving longer sentences.

Cabinet minister Phil Goff told TV One's Agenda programme yesterday that New Zealand had one of the highest prison populations in the Western world.

Some of the longest minimum non-parole sentences recently handed down include:

33 years for William Bell.

28 years for Bruce Howse, who killed his stepdaughters Saliel Aplin and Olympia Jetson.

26 years' preventive detention for Graeme Burton, who went on a shooting rampage while on parole for an earlier murder.

But National expects its plans to boost prison populations by 572 inmates, costing an extra $314 million for a new prison and $43 million more a year in operating costs.

Ad Feedback

It is the first of two big-ticket items expected to be revealed by National this week - its tax cut package on Wednesday is expected to surpass Labour's $10.9 billion package of tax cuts, which are being phased in from this month.

In contrast to the past few elections, when politicians have been able to make big-ticket promises because of bulging government surpluses, parties will be constrained by the state of the Government's books.

The Treasury is due to release its pre-election fiscal update today and it is expected to make grim reading, as growth and revenue forecasts are slashed and fiscal deficits and rising government debt are revealed.

- © Fairfax NZ News

29 comments
Conor   #29   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

My god. So you can pick a number and build the prison space to fill it? Is this a gamble? 572? 314 million? Why not round it up to 600 convicts? Plan ahead, build for 800, invest in the future.

John   #28   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

The only reform camp suitable for criminals is a tented camp under the shadows of Mt Ruapehu with barbed wire fences and armed guards. These casmps were good enough for our soldiers during the war and the had no TV either.

Laura   #27   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Could the Dom perhaps do a comparison for our public on the fiscal cost of life in prison vs the death penalty? I'd be interested to see if, as in the United States, the cost of executing someone is greater than life imprisonment.

Grant   #26   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Get rid of parole full stop. If a judge sentences someone to five years then they should do that, not a day more not a day less - the end. This is what I expect from the justice system. If we have to build new prisons - so be it. National is moving in the right direction.

Neale   #25   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

About time a politician has said what most of us believe.. Maybe we should bring back the cane for juvenile offenders and the rope for repeat murderers.

Bob Bell   #24   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

What happened to all the other posts supporting this??? Before the story was moved to the politics section there were over 100 mainly supporting this???

Imbugloo   #23   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

You people are cruel and hard hearted. Death penalty? I now know why NZ'ers and Afrikaaners were so similar. Beneath all that political speak you are a nasty lot.

Nicki   #22   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Well I think that putting people behind bars for murder and the like is a good thing. But we need to stop throwing people in jail for lesser things and teenagers should go to specialist havens away from their mates and from older hardened criminals. If you put a young person in jail with hardened crims then won't they just learn from them and come out of jail more determined to do bad. Let our schools show the way and get kids more involved in sport and music. Give the schools more resources. Let schools be schools with top notch teachers that are paid well and have the backing to teach real skills and not namby pamby their way through niceites so not to hurt anyones feelings. We need positive role models for our kids so they don't want to become the next jail stat.....Why can't we stop the criminals from becoming criminals in the first instance instead of just using a band aid when they are too far gone to change their ways!

Kelly   #21   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

It maybe just me but surely the problem isn't just prison sentence lengths. We have a judicial penalty system, under either National or Labour, places criminals in an institution with other criminals.

This isn't punishment. This is an education system for criminals - how to commit more crimes, different crimes, more "profitable" crimes.

Addressing the issue by making life sentences mean life, is like solving Auckland's traffic congestion by building more roads.

Tony Wood   #20   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

It's not enough. Life should mean life, no parole, solitary confinement, no visitors, no books, no TV, and one meal per day.

This would breed the problem out in one generation - you can't commit any more crime locked in a 6 x 6 cell. And if they go insane? Who cares? They were violent antisocial scum anyway.


Show 1-19 of 29 comments
Special offers
Opinion poll

Do you understand Whanau Ora's purpose?

Yes

No

Vote Result

Related story: Peters demands apology over Whanau Ora row

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Pagani blog pointer small

John Pagani - Left leaning

Don't set Treaty back 25 years

David Farrar blog pointer small

By the Numbers: David Farrar watches the polls

Mondayising Waitangi and Anzac Days

The Whip blog pointer small

Andrea Vance and John Hartevelt on politics

What to do with the Crafar Farms?