PM sounds death knell for phone, laptop tax

VERNON SMALL
Last updated 14:38 19/03/2013
Opinion poll

IRD plans to tax personal use of work cellphones and laptops is:

Fair enough

A bad idea

Vote Result

Peter Dunne
PETER DUNNE: The Government would look carefully at the reaction and look at how it works in practice.

Can you fix the NZ economy?

Share your stories, photos and videos.
tdn cun stand
DAVID CUNLIFFE: Described the move as ''more akin to the actions of a vulture picking over a carcass for every last morsel than it is to sensible fiscal management''.

Related Links

Govt blames Dunne for car park tax mess Teachers caught up in car park tax wrangle CTU joins car park tax fight Government ditches controversial car park tax plan

Relevant offers

Politics

'Fat people' to blame for tobacco tax: Winston Peters Schools will decide how to spend targeted funding for under-achieving kids Key gets tough on Auckland with new policy forcing councils to release land Below the beltway: The week in politics Budget 2016: Changing super will be super hard, which is why John Key should do it Govt thinks about compulsory warranty to protect against building flaws DHBs still being shortchanged, says Labour - unveils health map to highlight regional shortfalls Polluters have to pay full cost of emissions after bill passes final hurdle Sole buyer of Invercargill state houses pulls out, stalling Government plans Five charts that explain the Budget

Prime Minister John Key has sounded the death knell for a proposed tax on employer-provided laptops and cellphones just a day after Cabinet scrapped the tax on perk car parks.

"There is virtually no chance of it going ahead," Key said of the laptop and cellphone tax on his way into Parliament today.

"At the end of the day they are a nice idea when it comes to tax policy and a pain in the neck for everyone who has to put up with it."

He said it was not as it was often painted, because if an employer gave you a phone it was not subject to fringe benefit tax, it was "about money".

"It all gets lost in translation and I don't think it will go ahead."

Revenue Minister Peter Dunne had read the submissions "and he doesn't look very optimistic to me and neither am I".

Key said the Government would weigh up the impact on consumers and taxpayers against the compliance costs.

Dunne said he would answer questions in the House today and did not want to pre-empt his comments there, where it was more appropriate to make them.

Dunne had today conceded the laptop and cellphone tax was potentially even more controversial than the car-park tax.

The Government would look carefully at the reaction - which had been "stronger" than the car-park tax - and look at how it works in practice, he said.

The Employers and Manufacturers Association, which joined with unions to fight the car-park tax, has signalled that was just the start of a longer campaign to overturn the other planned taxes, including the laptop and cellphone tax.

But there is also mounting concern over plans to tax accommodation provided for workers who relocate long-term to help with the Christchurch rebuild.

The IRD has indicated that a employees of a firm based in Auckland who worked fulltime in Christchurch and have their accommodation paid for by their employer would be deemed to have relocated and therefore the market value of that accommodation would be taxable.

Labour revenue spokesman David Cunliffe has described the move as "more akin to the actions of a vulture picking over a carcass for every last morsel than it is to sensible fiscal management".

Ad Feedback

The ruling seemingly ignores how little remuneration benefit there is to a worker, who must still maintain a family home even though the worker can't use it, he said.

- Stuff

Comments

Special offers
Opinion poll

Should the speed limit be raised to 110kmh on some roads?

Yes

No

Vote Result

Related story: 110kmh limit moves closer

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content