Labour takes aims at GCSB's legal advice

Last updated 13:19 21/03/2013
Kim Dotcom
KIM DOTCOM: The spy agency that looked into his case is under review.

Relevant offers


Prison operator Serco goes to High Court over fight club report Twyford slams Auckland's Special Housing Areas Backlash over Christine Rankin's intention to run for mayoralty Runway extension: Mayors excited but Joyce not ready to loosen purse strings Australian Labor supportive of improved rights for Kiwi expats - Andrew Little Explainer: What is the Government doing about child abuse? Dr Patrick Kelly: The health system can help on child abuse 'No eureka moment' from Australian govt on deportation rules - Andrew Little Greenpeace protesters charged over boat boarding Philippa Howden-Chapman highlights NZ's increasingly embarrassing housing crisis

Labour has accused Government spies of casting around for a legal opinion that suited them in the Kim Dotcom case.

Prime Minister John Key confirmed yesterday that a review of the Government Communications Security Bureau (GCSB) had been ordered in the wake of revelations it spied on the German millionaire, and could lead to significant change.

The report was expected soon.

The agency also confirmed recently that it was increasing the capacity of its legal department.

Former GCSB legal adviser Hugh Wolfensohn had left the agency since the Dotcom scandal broke.

Today, Labour deputy leader Grant Robertson released documentation showing legal advice provided to the GCSB changed five times in a week.

"That suggests the GCSB was desperately casting around for a legal opinion that suited it - one that meant it could pretend the illegal spying was lawful," he said.

Robertson said it could not be interpreted as anything other than a cover-up.

The court would not release the legal documents that GCSB held, but it had given Labour affidavits which showed that between February 20 and 27 last year there were five different versions of legal advice on Operation Debut.

Robertson said GCSB knew on February 22 that Dotcom was a New Zealand resident, and therefore spying on him was illegal.

"Yet by the end of that week, magically a justification had been found," he said.

"But because we cannot get access to that advice it is impossible to know how the GCSB justified their actions."

He called on Key to released the legal advice.

Ad Feedback

- Stuff

Special offers
Opinion poll

Should the speed limit be raised to 110kmh on some roads?



Vote Result

Related story: 110kmh limit moves closer

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content