Collins jumps in 'racist' clothes-fight

Last updated 12:24 31/01/2014
Fairfax NZ
METIRIA TUREI: Unimpressed by National MP Anne Tolley's comment.
Fairfax NZ
ANNE TOLLEY: Has described Metiria Turei's comments as "absolute nonsense".
Fairfax NZ
JUDITH COLLINS: The justice minister has now joined the war of words.
Opinion poll

What do you think of the clothing-related stoush involving Judith Collins, Anne Tolley and Metiria Turei?

It's just politics

It's racist

It's bullying

Why do we pay these people?

Vote Result

Relevant offers


Nelson councillor Kate Fulton confirmed as Green Party West Coast-Tasman candidate Winston Peters calls for 'economic nationalism' Gary Kelliher to challenge Ella Lawton for Otago Regional Council seat 'Stop playing politics': Maori Land Reform Bill heads back to Parliament with stiff opposition Government pockets $4m windfall from fraudster's Apple shares after ten-year fight What we know, and don't know, about the SAS raid allegations from Hit and Run Most businesses see no benefit from FTAs, many prefer protection Labour amps up pressure on donors, warning campaign may be scaled back Child, Youth and Family office in Wairarapa did not meet standards Outdoors Party New Zealand founder hopes general election a watershed moment

Justice Minister Judith Collins has stepped up the war of words with Green co-leader Metiria Turei, saying she dresses badly and is a "sensitive wee sausage".

On Thursday Turei said National MPs were guilty of "pure racism" after Police Minister Anne Tolley called her a hypocrite for saying the Government was out of touch, while at the same time the Green co-leader wore expensive clothing.

Tolley said that in her East Coast electorate she worked daily with some constituents who were among the poorest in the country.

"I'm actually insulted to be lectured about how out of touch I am with average New Zealand by a list MP who has no constituents, lives in a castle, and comes to the House in $2000 designer jackets and tells me I'm out of touch," Tolley said.

It is not the first time National MPs have attacked Turei's choice of clothing.

Collins said last year on Twitter that a speech by Turei was "vile, wrong and ugly, just like her jacket today".

Turei said yesterday she was being bullied and the attacks were racist.

"I think they seem to think it is all right for them to wear perfectly good suits for their professional job but that a Maori woman from a working-class background is not entitled to do the same," she said.

"I think it is pure racism."

Today Collins dismissed the claims, saying if anything the comments were "clothes-ist" and that Tolley was giving Turei some much-needed advice.

"It would be hard to bully Metiria Turei," Collins said on the way into National's all day caucus at Premier House.
"Oh my goodness, isn't she a sensitive wee sausage?"

Collins denied there was bullying or racism behind the claims.

"I think, actually, Metiria Turei needs to - don't be so silly," she said.

"They [the comments] may be 'clothes-ist' and Anne Tolley may have been giving her some very good advice about being a hypocrite, that we believe she is.

"If she's going to stand there and talk about child poverty and how the National Party is out of touch with poverty when she is the one who spends a tremendous amount on clothes and talks to us about child poverty. I think she's a hypocrite."

Ad Feedback

She stood by her criticism of Turei's clothing, and someone had to raise it.

"Well it was a really ugly jacket. It was really bad," Collins said.

Dressing well did not preclude people from discussing child poverty.

"Well, they can, but she doesn't dress nicely."

Tolley denied her comments were racist, and that Turei was entitled to wear whatever she wanted to.

"She can wear whatever she likes," Tolley said.

"I don't have a problem, but don't come to the House and accuse someone who is an electorate MP for an electorate where there are some very poor [constituents] . . . and try to tell me I'm out of touch. That's what I'm objecting to."

Prime Minister John Key defended his female colleagues.

"Lots of members of Parliament, on both sides of the House live in actually, much better conditions than a lot of other New Zealanders, and buying much more expensive clothes, so it was a bit rich of Metiria Turei having a go at the minister," he said.

"But I don't think it's racism."

The Greens were often among the most personal in their attacks on the Government Key said, citing the number of times they called for ministers to be sacked.

"They go hard, they really go hard," Key said.

"I don't feel bullied but I'm just saying they don't hold back."

He did not know how much it was appropriate for women to spend on jackets, saying wife Bronagh did not consult him on how much she spent.

Turei said she was shocked by the comments. She stood by all of her comments yesterday about the attacks being racist, although the episode was an "awful distraction" from her job.

"I'm shocked that a Cabinet minister would organise a stand up [press conference] with the media and spend most of her time attacking the way I look," Turei said.

Collins also fielded questions about the decision to grant convicted rapist and murderer Teina Pora has been granted leave to appeal his convictions to the Privy Council.
Turei said: "Judith [Collins] and Anne [Tolley] want to talk about clothes while I'm talking about kids and family and poverty. It just proves where their priorities lay. They have no answer to the challenge put before them," she said.

"I'm shocked and it's a terrible example of how politics should be played out."
She rejected Key's criticism that the Greens were as attacking as any party in the House, saying there was no comparison between calling for a Minister to be sacked and attacking their appearance.
"If a Minister is failing in their role and causing people harm I will call them out on what they say and what they do. That is my job.''

- Stuff


Special offers
Opinion poll

Should the speed limit be raised to 110kmh on some roads?



Vote Result

Related story: 110kmh limit moves closer

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content