Judith Collins comes clean about dinner

Last updated 14:51 12/03/2014
Fairfax NZ

Justice Minister Judith Collins says she probably should have been more upfront about a dinner with Oravida bosses in China.

Fairfax NZ
JUDITH COLLINS: The justice minister admits she dined with Oravida bosses in Beijing.

Relevant offers


Grant Robertson, Bill English square off in housing debate The 'Mad Men' budget 'Fat people' to blame for tobacco tax: Winston Peters Schools will decide how to spend targeted funding for under-achieving kids Key gets tough on Auckland with new policy forcing councils to release land TPPA, housing and child poverty protesters greet John Key on Palmerston North visit Govt thinks about compulsory warranty to protect against building flaws Jeremy Elwood & Michele A'Court: Paying the rent DHBs still being shortchanged, says Labour - unveils health map to highlight regional shortfalls Below the beltway: The week in politics

Prime Minister John Key has signalled Justice Minister Judith Collins is on her final warning after she withheld details of a dinner in China with a company linked to her husband.

The dinner was with senior members of Oravida, a company that deals with New Zealand dairy products, and a senior Chinese government official. Collins' husband David Wong-Tung is a director of the company.

Key met Collins this morning to express his disappointment that she did not come clean when questions were first raised about her visiting Oravida offices during her official visit to China last year.

Key said the cumulative effects of her interactions with Oravida could lead to a perception of a conflict of interest.

"I made clear to her in no uncertain terms how disappointed I was," he said.

"She's an outstanding minister but she's handled this situation very poorly and I've made my feelings known to her directly this morning."

Key said he had been left exposed because he had based his public defence of Collins on the incomplete information she had given him.

Collins had "misled by omission" and had a responsibility to reveal all the meetings she had in China, private or not, saying "she certainly should have made me aware of [the dinner]".

"Judith had a responsibility when she was asked the questions not just to answer the question directly but to tell me and the New Zealand public everything that had gone on," he said.

Instead, she had allowed events to accumulate, leading to the perception of a conflict of interest "and that's unacceptable".

Collins had assured him she did not discuss matters of national interest with the Chinese official and that it was just a personal dinner, and he accepted that, he said.

When asked whether this was a final warning for Collins he said "I wouldn't want to be in her shoes if there was a repeat of it".

"I just hope there wouldn't be a repeat of this," he said.

In a hastily arranged media conference this morning, Collins apologised for failing to divulge the details.


She was told to front up to the media after the prime minister's chief of staff, Wayne Eagleson, learnt last night about the dinner, apparently after Collins was summoned to go over details of her trip as controversy over dealings with Oravida widened.

Collins confirmed she was forced to give an explanation to Key this morning about the lapse but refused to confirm if she had apologised to him.

The dinner with Oravida chairman Stone Shi and managing director Julia Xu took place in Beijing when Collins was there on official government business.

Collins said this morning she had not thought to mention the dinner when questions were asked about her visit to Oravida last week because it had been a private affair.

Shi was a very close personal friend and they had spent Christmas together.

She confirmed that she met Oravida representatives on three occasions during her visit - at a lunch also attended by Fonterra, Nestle and Ministry of Foreign Affairs representatives, at the dinner in Beijing later that evening, and at the company's premises in Shanghai.

Ad Feedback

The New Zealand ambassador had also been invited to the dinner but he was unable to make it.

The reason for the senior Chinese government official being there was because he was a close friend of Shi's.

His role in government was border control but Collins said they did not discuss that issue at all.

Collins said that in hindsight it would have been better if she had not treated it like a private diner.

She said it was hard for her to admit she was wrong.

"What's probably extraordinary is I am saying 'I apologise'," she said.

"That is extraordinary for me."

There are questions over Collins' links to Oravida after a post on their website suggested she had endorsed its products while on her trip to China.

The cabinet manual makes it clear ministers should not endorse any products.

Key had previously stated that the Cabinet office backed Collins and did not find a conflict of interest.

But last night he was forced to admit that the Cabinet office had not translated the Chinese version on Oravida's website which claimed that Collins had praised its products.

- Stuff

Special offers
Opinion poll

Should the speed limit be raised to 110kmh on some roads?



Vote Result

Related story: 110kmh limit moves closer

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content