The polls this week
Three polls have been released in the latter half of this week. If you average them out (after adjusting for the sample size of each poll so a poll of 1000 counts for twice as much as a poll of 500), the projected seats on the Fairfax Research International, NZ Herald Digpoll and One News Colmar Brunton polls are:
- National 65 seats - 41 electorate, 24 list
- Labour 35 seats - 23 electorate, 12 list
- Green 14 seats - 14 list
- Maori 3 seats - 3 electorates
- ACT 2 seats - 1 electorate, 1 list
- United Future 1 seat - 1 electorate
- Mana 1 seat - 1 elctorate
The assumptions for the electorate seats are that all electorate seats will be retained by their parties, except where a public poll shows otherwise. The only seat in this category at this time is Te Tai Tonga going from Maori Party to Labour. Uncontroversially, it is also assumed Labour wins Wigram.
If National gains 65 seats, they will gain many new MPs. Highly placed candidates Jian Yang, Paul Goldsmith and Alfred Ngaro were always going to make it in, as were electorate candidates Simon O'Connor, Maggie Barry, Ian McKelvie, Mark Mitchell, Mark Sabin and Scott Simpson. Joining them would be candidates Paul Foster-Bell, Claudette Hauiti, Jo Hayes and Leonie Hapeta.
This would give National its most ethnically diverse caucus ever. They would have 11 Maori MPs, three Asian MPs and two Pacific MPs. They would also have a record 18 female MPs (but their proportion of the caucus would be unchanged).
Labour would have a mixture of gains and losses. Their new electorate MPs would be David Clark, Louisa Wall, Rino Tirikatene and Megan Woods. Their only new List MP would be Andrew Little. On the losses side, current MPs Steve Chadwick, Stuart Nash, Rick Barker, Carmel Sepuloni, Kelvin Davis and Damien O'Connor (if he does not win West Coast-Tasman) would be gone.
For the Greens, the news is only good. Seven MPs are standing again so they would get seven new MPs to join them - Eugenie Sage, Jan Logie, Steffan Browning, Denise Roche, Holly Walker, Julie Anne Genther and Mojo Mathers.
The Maori Party face losing Rahui Katene and look unlikely to pick any seats up.
ACT has no current MPs standing again on the list. At present their caucus looks to be John Banks and Don Brash.
United Future and Mana on the current polls will be one-MP parties.
In the Parliament projected above you need 61 seats to govern. Labour and Greens would have 49. Phil Goff has ruled Mana out and Winston has ruled Labour out, so that is a big gap to close in the last two weeks. However, if you assume Winston will break his word (which on past form seems a safe assumption) and that somehow Phil Goff could persuade the Maori and Mana parties to both support him in government, then a Labour-led coalition could be up to 56 seats, if NZ First made 5 per cent. That gets them closer to the line.
David Farrar is a centre-right blogger affiliated to the National Party. His disclosure statement is here.
» Follow NZStuffBlogs on Twitter and get fast updates on all Stuff's blogs.
Sponsored links
Who cares? There's only one poll that counts and that's on the 26th. Everything else is utter speculation.
Moving on.
Heard Hone saying this morning that he is expecting to have a cacus of 4. Hone, Sykes, Minto and Bradford!! Now if there was ever a reason to move to Australia that would be it.
And I believe Sam Collins for National also, since didn't one of their sitting MPs just pass away? But in the end they'll probably only get 60 or so.
It would be a shame to lose Rahui Katene. Also a big shame to lose Kelvin Davis.
@poneke - each to their own. Some people like analysis and speculation.
Going by your own distribution of seats above, why would you worry about who wants to work with Labour?
Pete trends would show Labour falling even further!
I think pictures of the PM and no shows at meeting/dissusions on Radio eg. Radio NZ no Key or Health Minister recently.
I see National going down to 42% Labour 29% Greens 17% Mana 3% Maori 2%(Not making it ACT 1.5% NZ First 3.5% Conserative and others approx 10% of votes being given to the other Parties who do make 5% Party Vote or win a seat).
Why does the NZ media not talk about a NZ$25 billion buget blow out?For news I go to rt.com (the only financial news worth watching CH 96 on SKY)
Given the tax payer gives more tax money to the big party, yet a rather smaller amount of media paid space to the smaller Party so this is not a balanced election as money can buy space.
Come on you guys, the Conservative Party is polling higher in some poles than both Mana, United Future and ACT yet you never include them. Be fair here.
Didn't finish reading, massive assumption that made me give up. I went to a candidates debate in Invercargill where the local MP Eric Roy was a complete failure. He's already given the seat to rabble rouser Leslie Soper. Your assumption is fundamentally wrong Mr Farrar. By the way the "Debate" was won by the people from the floor, but Labour will take it for sure.
You say that the poll assumes that electorate seats will be retained by their parties, except where a public poll shows otherwise. Epsom does not want John Banks and has indicated this in every survey with a large majority. Act should not be there by your own statements.
Carterton tragedy: Safety chief would refuse balloon ride
Heavy rains, wind pound country
Henry climbs into Aussie crisis
Daily trivia quiz: February 23
Reviewer: Henry star of new show
Runners strip off for Christchurch
Why I feel for the kids of ego-trippers
2 Broke Girls: the worst new show of 2012
The age of the Angry Young Man
Is the other woman always to blame?
Reviewer: Henry star of new show
Sea Shepherd ship to set sail from Wellington
Newest First
Oldest First
At this stage of the campaign where it's common for significant moves as more people make up their minds wouldn't trends be more important than averages?