A distraction Labour doesn't need

Last updated 11:00 15/11/2011

The secret tape recording has become a distraction Labour doesn't need.

Wait a second, you say, what do you mean that Labour doesn't need? Isn't this about National and ACT?

Yes the tape recording is of John Key and John Banks. And the prime minister has complained to police about the covert recording, as it is a criminal offence to intentionally record a conversation without permission of at least one party.

I suspect that many members of the public will be aghast at the tactics of the cameraman involved, especially in light of what has happened in the UK (albeit it that was far more serious and not a one-off).

Coverage of the issue has now been the major political issue for three days.

I suspect it will remain an issue for two or three more days until, probably inevitably, somehow the tape or a transcript gets out there. Then the public may learn, as TV3 hinted last night, that there may be something which could be intepreted as critical of Don Brash.

If the speculation is correct, this in fact could make the prime minister even more popular!

But back to Labour: why do I think this is an issue Labour doesn't need?

Labour's best hopes of closing the gap enough so that they can form a Labour-Green-NZ First-Maori-Mana alternative government is to keep campaigning on asset sales. It is the issue National is most vulnerable on as people are unconvinced on the merits if the mixed ownership model proposed.

So when Phil Goff was asked for comment yesterday on the tape, his response should have been "I don't care at all what John Key said to John Banks over coffee, what I care about is why National and ACT plan to sell our assets. This issue is a distraction from the real issues that matter to New Zealanders such as the increased power prices that will eventuate from selling shares in our power companies."

Every day the media are reporting on the issue of the tape, they are not giving prominence to other issues. That, I suspect, suits National just fine. National would much rather have Labour and the media obsessed with the tape, rather than talking the pros and cons of partial asset sales.

David Farrar is a centre-right blogger affiliated to the National Party. His disclosure statement is here.

» Follow NZStuffBlogs on Twitter and get fast updates on all Stuff's blogs.

75 comments
Post a comment
fred   #1   11:07 am Nov 15 2011

You're right, it's a game for publicity rather than policy.

Yelena   #2   11:10 am Nov 15 2011

God help New Zealnd if the Labour-Green-NZ First-Maori-Mana alternative government is let to rule for 3 years! I hope people have enough common sense not to allow it to happen. That is why MMP has to gob and a tail will not wag the dog any longer!

Robin   #3   11:13 am Nov 15 2011

My thoughts entirely. A low trick. Why should JK release the tape this was a private and probably strategic conversation. You'd have to be stupid to share your strategies with the enemy.

Mbossa   #4   11:20 am Nov 15 2011

I reckon this whole "secret recording" nonsense was just a huge publicity stunt from start to finish. If they really wanted to have a private conversation, surely there are better places for them to do it than in a highly-publicised meeting in busy Newmarket cafe surrounded by media. I bet the guy who planted the microphone in the first place was directed by the Nats.

Maynard J   #5   11:29 am Nov 15 2011

Wow Farrar, this is pathetic even for you. Tone the spin down, just because it's close to election time doesn't mean that transparent shameless spin like this suddenly appears lucid.

Key looks like an idiot: he invited anyone, had a conversation he shouldn't have had, pretends he's not fushed acshully about it, and then goes the the police. Blow over in a couple of days? You wish. Not unless he releases the tapes (and then we'll see how that blows over)...

The NoW comparisons will also backfire (I see you can't help to try and reinforce that National Party line, you should be paying Stuff for this advertising) - the phone hacking of a murdered school girl, which caused her parents and friends to mistakenly believe she had not been murdered is not comparable to this and it's an insult to the victims of NoW phone-hacking to make this comparison. Shame on you.

Jack   #6   11:36 am Nov 15 2011

I'm an Epsom voter and I agree: asset sales are much more important than a pantomime about another dirty trick from the predictable quarter. Mr Key, plenty of people can do the numbers and see that the main effect of selling pieces of family silver is to enrich a chosen few but to disadvantage everybody else in time. Or perhaps I'm missing something, in which case that's what I want to hear.

Peter   #7   11:40 am Nov 15 2011

I agree - I almost thought that perhaps the cameraman is a true blue supporter and that this is a national plan to distract. Goff could also have taken the moral high ground and said private conversations are private - but - of all the choices he could have made on a response he choose the worst one - showing his desperation for any old helping hand.

Observation   #8   11:42 am Nov 15 2011

Don Brash should just quit now. If he resigned I'm sure ACT's vote would improve and it would be better for everybody.

El Jorge   #9   11:43 am Nov 15 2011

@Mbossa #4

If you want to play the conspiracy theory game, I reckon Labour paid the skipper of the Rena to crash into the Astrolabe reef and then use the crash to damage Nationals image.

Jack   #10   11:50 am Nov 15 2011

@ Mbossa #4 I'm starting to have exactly the same thoughts.

I could care less about the tape it won't change my vote, what may is the text of the Trans-Pacific-Partnership deals. They will have, if rumours are correct a far bigger impact on the nation than a teaparty in Espom.

I totally agree with Mr Farrar on Goff. Talk is talk, policy is policy why does so many in the media and the public keep falling for and chasing such BS?


Show 11-60 of 75 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content