Pharmacist questions `sugar pill' claim

Last updated 15:06 31/01/2009

Relevant offers

A study that labelled most antidepressants as no more effective than sugar pills has been dismissed by a leading pharmacist, who says the research is old and narrow in its scope.

It was last week reported that selective seratonin re-uptake inhibitors, or SSRIs, had been shown in a major study to be no more effective than dummy pills for mildly depressed people and only slightly better with those who were seriously depressed.

Prozac, Aropax, Cipramil, Zoloft and Luvox are common forms of the drugs.

Motueka-based Pharmaceutical Society president Chris Budgen has laid out his concerns in a memo sent to the region's pharmacists and supplied to the Nelson Mail.

In the memo, he said the study was taken from 1990s research.

"What it did show was that whilst the effectiveness of antidepressants in mild depression was small, as the depression increased in severity so did the effectiveness of SSRI antidepressants and indeed are considered essential in severe depression by expert opinion and there has been much further positive research since 1999," he said.

He claims the study only appeared to have followed patients for four to eight weeks, which was not long enough to evaluate the effect of antidepressants, where benefits could take months to appear.

The research only evaluated antidepressants in adults and could not be applied to children or adolescents on the drugs, he said.

 

 

Ad Feedback

- © Fairfax NZ News

girls college strap
Breaking down barriers

Nelson College for Girls students break blocks of wood with their bare hands.

boutereys strap
Bouterey's to close

Richmond restaurant Bouterey's is closing and will reopen as a family-friendly cafe.

Dwight Schrute strap
Inbox: the week on the web

Try your hand at 'Newt or Schrute' in this week's web roundup.

Nicole James
Living large in less

Nelson 21-year-old Nicole James has been selected to model lingerie throughout New Zealand.

Ben chambers strap
Loving Chambers' music

Internet sensation Ben Chambers on singing, theatre and the weird world of YouTube.

Achim Bauer and Karin Schoch strap
Swiss couple buy winery

A high-powered Swiss couple are the new owners of Kina Beach Vineyard.

.
Nelson newlyweds

More of your photos from recent weddings around the region.

Readers photo gallery
Readers' daily photo gallery

Stunning scenery and slices of life from around the Top of the South.

Special offers
Opinion poll

Do you support the proposed amalgamation of Nelson and Tasman councils?

Yes

No

Don't know/Don't care

Vote Result

Related story: (See story)

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Little day out

Little Day Out

Organisers of Victory's Little Day Out may have to start looking for a new name for the annual summer gathering.

whale stranding

Farewell Spit whale stranding

Project Jonah volunteers led a rescue effort to refloat a pod of 99 beached pilot whales in Golden Bay.

golden bay A and P

Golden Bay A&P show

Perfect summer weather and a cloudless sky attracted a crowd of more than 5000 to the showgrounds outside Takaka.

Richmond Rodeo

Richmond Rodeo

Good weather, massive bulls and a record crowd saddled up for Richmond Rodeo's 50th Jubilee.

Teddy Bear's Picnic

Teddy Bear's Picnic

Local children and their teddies gathered at Isel Park for a fun-filled picnic in the sunshine

NelsonWOWpoint

Nelson designers at WOW

The awards may have moved to Wellington, but the Nelson spirit still burns strong at WOW