Trend in babycare 'scary'

BY LAURA BASHAM
Last updated 13:00 22/12/2009

Related Links

Editorial - Guilt trips don't help in the childcare debate Demand cited for baby care centres

Relevant offers

A big increase in the number of under-ones in childcare is due to the fact it has become socially acceptable, says the head of a home-based childcare organisation.

New figures in an Education Ministry report show a 21 per cent increase in four years to nearly 8000 under-ones in daycare.

Porse managing director Jenny Yule said the increase was because childcare centres had become visible.

"People see them like McDonald's; there's one on every corner.

"It's become the norm and it's socially acceptable. It's OK to have your baby in childcare."

However, she believes the trend has lost sight of what is best for the baby.

Porse's in-home childcare was about a baby needing an attachment relationship and was an alternative to large group-based childcare centres, she said.

In Nelson, 53 families with 70 children use Porse home-based care, with 46 over-twos and 24 under-twos.

Ms Yule said the increase in the demand for childcare was not just because of economic necessity as working parents put their children in care; mothers were also using centres for time out for themselves.

There was also a pressure that children would "miss out" if they did not go to a centre.

"Even stay-at-home mums are being asked `why are you not putting your child into daycare?'

"I would never stop women from going to work but we need to look at the physical and psychological needs of babies and bring childcare centres back to smaller groups," Ms Yule said.

"They have become very large, with corporates buying up the boutique centres. It used to be two carers and four babies; now it's 40 babies and rostered staff and it just scares me."

The increase in babies in daycare centres was also because the government paid more.

"It's an incentive to have more childcare places – you get double the money for a baby than a three or four-year-old.

"It's an incentive for business, but bigger is not better for babies."

She said it could be stressful for babies being in noisy big groups, and likened it to an adult having to go daily to a new dinner party with 20 people.

"You look for the one person you know.

"A little baby's environment needs to be one on one in a settled routine."

Future Positive Beginnings at Richmond, which takes babies from six months, has eight under-twos.

Supervisor Pauline Pukowski said it was a small group because the quality of teachers and the environment was critical to the relationships that were formed.

The centre opened in April and filled up straight away, with demand generally from working parents.

Ad Feedback

Mrs Pukowski said society had changed from when children were brought up in communities. "Now children are brought up in isolation, and if you don't have family around, it can be a place to get advice and see role modelling. "For the child, it's about social interaction ... Relationships are really important and if they learn to trust, that's part of development."

Babyspace Ltd at Richmond assistant supervisor Rebecca Poulter said while the centre could take under-ones, it did not have any, and children more commonly started at 13 or 14 months.

"There are advantages and disadvantages for under-ones; it's all about the place that suits them. "If it works well for you and the child, there aren't many disadvantages," she said.

- © Fairfax NZ News

18 comments
Post a comment
Kevin   #18   11:21 am Dec 24 2009

The big increase in childcare relates to the increase in births over the last few years, percentage wise the number of children in childcare is the same. You would think that the Porse managing director would know that there would be a relation between the number of births and the number of kids in childcare.

Lance   #17   08:54 am Dec 24 2009

What a great article. well done to it's author.

I have my child in PORSE care and know many PORSE carers and don’t have any problems with recommending them to my friends with children of their own.

To all of those knockers - know me before you judge me. Just like I do to you. I hope you teach your children to be slightly less judgmental than you display.

gertrude   #16   10:54 pm Dec 23 2009

How many of these comments are from the same person? The article didn't JUST quote Porse.

Lee   #15   10:45 pm Dec 23 2009

There is 0 evidence that staying at home to raise your kid leads to a better adjusted kid in the future, its up to the parents what their preference is and what they think is better for their kid.

As it turns out, the friends of a kid have far more effect on a childs development than their parents.

Pete   #14   10:01 pm Dec 23 2009

My wife cares for my son during the day most of the time. When she can't, I do. Our decision was that our child should be raised by us. Not by a babysitter while we ignore him and then wonder why he ignores us later in his life. If we couldn't afford to survive on one income, we wouldn't have had children. It's easy to back yourself into a corner and then make excuses for the conditions in that corner.

Lynda   #13   09:29 pm Dec 23 2009

I was really disappointed to see this incredibly biased article. It read as a private ad for PORSE. I have nothing against home based care, parents need choice, they need accurate information and access to quality care. There are many good centres in the Nelson region, Parents should look for small group size, qualified teachers, a stable teaching team and a interesting challenging environment. There has been an increased focus in the specialised care that Infants and Toddlers require, this has lead to many beneficial changes to the quality of practice and environments. I hope in future the Nelson Mail will give a more balanced view and more appropriate headlines that are not scaremongering.

jenny   #12   07:29 pm Dec 23 2009

Judging by the comments on here, there are a lot of parents feeling a bit guilty for neglecting their kids and leaving their upbringing to daycare centres and taking it out on the Nelson Mail for basically telling them what they don't want to hear.

There's nothing wrong with having children AND a career but its about balance. Kids need parents, not teachers and nannys in these early years. When they hit their teenage years and start acting up because they didnt form parental bonds in those crucial first years - good luck!

Steve   #11   04:48 pm Dec 23 2009

Is this article a paid advert or just biased reporting?

Tony   #10   01:37 pm Dec 23 2009

Completely agree with James #7. Really Nelson Mail, how do you expect any future income in advertising from early education providers after this type of slander article on the front page of your newspaper? I also agree with teacher #6, The Education Review Office gives an accurate description of a centre's performance, not brash comments from a competitor promoting her own service. If you want opinion, Porse offers very little early childhood education. It is a government funded babysitting service in residential houses by unqualified and mostly unsupervised caregivers. Compare that to trained and qualified teachers providing a caring, nurturing environment for children in early childhood centres licensed by the Ministry of Education. The Editor of the Nelson Mail needs to seriously consider the motivation behind writing such a slanderous article attacking families, teachers and early education providers, it’s a real slap in the face.

Working full-time mum   #9   01:27 pm Dec 23 2009

I agree, Jenny Yule knows nothing about quality childcare and the government funding for under twos. My son is fulltime in a childcare centre and with their philosophies and primary caregiving, they more than meet the physicl and pyschological needs for him. This article is just a dig at childcare to boost her own business, which is very disappointing. People should get their facts straight first!


Show 1-8 of 18 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Do you support the proposed amalgamation of Nelson and Tasman councils?

Yes

No

Don't know/Don't care

Vote Result

Related story: (See story)

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Little day out

Little Day Out

Organisers of Victory's Little Day Out may have to start looking for a new name for the annual summer gathering.

whale stranding

Farewell Spit whale stranding

Project Jonah volunteers led a rescue effort to refloat a pod of 99 beached pilot whales in Golden Bay.

golden bay A and P

Golden Bay A&P show

Perfect summer weather and a cloudless sky attracted a crowd of more than 5000 to the showgrounds outside Takaka.