No council criticism of our front yards

BY KAREN GOODGER
Last updated 13:00 01/09/2010

Relevant offers

The Nelson City Council doesn't want to offend its ratepayers by using their homes as examples for why its planning rules should be changed – so it's going to use Richmond homes instead.

The decision comes after photographs of some Nelson homes were included in documents provided to councillors to explain the reasons behind proposed new planning rules. One photograph showed a concrete block and cedar home at 204 Collingwood St, which won architecture and building awards last year.

The council document said it "provides a streetscape that is low in amenity". New controls would avoid that effect, "where the front yard is dominated by a garage, parking and manoeuvring area", it said.

The Nelson Mail approached the home owners and architect for comment.

They later relayed that the council would cease using the photograph in future publications related to the plan changes.

Nelson City Council environmental policy manager Martin Workman confirmed that neither the Collingwood St property, nor any others in Nelson, would be used as examples to demonstrate the proposed changes to the public.

"The sensitivity of commenting on someone's house was not seen as being the desired outcome."

The council would use Richmond properties as examples instead because "they're not our ratepayers" and, being so close to Nelson, it was the most "cost-effective" place to collect examples from, he said.

"The idea is to provide examples of what's said so people can understand the implications and exactly what we're getting at."

Ad Feedback

- © Fairfax NZ News

4 comments
Post a comment
s mills   #4   04:29 pm Sep 02 2010

The question to be asked is will the proposed changes to the fencing rules and the front yard rules achieve the change that the council wants? Those homeowners who want attractive properties will build attractive fences (be they high or low) and ensure that their planting enhances their house and neighbourhood. It would be entirely possible to comply with the changes, use cheap materials, plant grass (then not care for it)and still have a very unattractive, uninspiring and intimidating property. Education rather than legislation may provide an acceptable solution to all parties.

Nelsonian   #3   01:17 am Sep 02 2010

Riled I certainly concur with yr thoughts. Where are the "Hands Up posters this time? - ummm opposing camps I suggest will not meet in the middle this time around. Frankly this is stupidity in motion. I see a Tui in the Kowhai tree but hey I can also envisage a Kiwi on the ground near that tree....thats really the relevance your article brings if the facts prove themselves - very frustrating when we have those reserves up The Brook that we have to entrust others with. I say entrust because that has been what Nelson has been about for the last 30 years that I have lived here. Disappointing if reality proves otherwise.

Arnie   #2   05:30 pm Sep 01 2010

Well said #1 there goes any sort of thinking about amalgamation, if they publish a photo of my property I will publish photos of Nelson Councillors & senior staffs properties. What an idiotic idea they have come up with. Too much spare time on their hands.

Riled in Richmond   #1   01:27 pm Sep 01 2010

And I wonder why TDC residents are so reluctant for amalgamation (as clearly demonstrated by the extreme difficulty that Aldo had in obtaining a mere 10% of ratepayer signatures in Tasman) when NCC treat their neighbours with such contempt and as if they are second class citizens. What's the chances of NCC changing it's spots and to begin treating its neighbour as an equal should amalgamation occur. Nill I would say.

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Do you support the proposed amalgamation of Nelson and Tasman councils?

Yes

No

Don't know/Don't care

Vote Result

Related story: (See story)

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Little day out

Little Day Out

Organisers of Victory's Little Day Out may have to start looking for a new name for the annual summer gathering.

whale stranding

Farewell Spit whale stranding

Project Jonah volunteers led a rescue effort to refloat a pod of 99 beached pilot whales in Golden Bay.

golden bay A and P

Golden Bay A&P show

Perfect summer weather and a cloudless sky attracted a crowd of more than 5000 to the showgrounds outside Takaka.