Outdoor dining area in Mapua opposed

BY ALICE COWDREY ALICEC@NELSONMAIL.CO.NZ
Last updated 13:21 09/09/2010

Relevant offers

Tasman district councillor Trevor Norriss opposes a 10-year licence for an outside dining area at Mapua and wants the waterfront site used by the public instead.

A new licence for the council-owned area, once used by Smokehouse Cafe customers who dined outdoors, has already been granted to Tom and Vivienne Fox.

They lease the former Smokehouse Cafe building from the council, but subleased the premises to cafe owners David Endersby and Julina Ismail until July.

Mr Norriss brought up his concerns during a meeting when the council was asked to rubber-stamp the licence.

A condition of the area's licence is that whoever is occupying the former Smokehouse also has that licence. Councillors have resolved that the matter be discussed further during a private council enterprise meeting.

Mr Norriss said a 10-year licence was far too long. "There's a lot of discontent with what's been happening out there."

He said the development of the former Fruitgrowers Chemical Company site waterfront park and the national cycleway meant the area should be open to the public and not used by a business.

Council property manager Jim Frater was called into the council chamber to clarify the matter. He said the licence could be terminated by the council if there was an alternative use for the area or if the council was unhappy with its use.

Mr Norriss said use of the whole wharf area needed to be reviewed. He was a "wee bit more satisfied" after learning the licence could be pulled at any time.

Councillor Jack Inglis said he believed the council should consider the situation "very, very carefully".

Councillor Glenys Glover said that at the last council enterprise committee meeting she was told the whole area was subject to a report.

The Foxes have 10 years left on their lease of the former Smokehouse Cafe building and are renovating its interior. Mr Frater said that the discussion was confidential and he could not comment.

He would not specify what it cost for the licence but said it was "reasonably significant".

Mr Endersby said he had paid about $4500 each year for the outside dining area and it was a critical part of the business because it seated about 80 people.

He agreed the area should be used by the public instead of a restaurant. Getting rid of the seating area would mean there were uninterrupted views of the sea and it would flow nicely with the waterfront park development.

Mr Fox told The Nelson Mail it was too early to comment on what he had planned for the building.

Ad Feedback

- © Fairfax NZ News

1 comment
Post a comment
John B   #1   07:32 am Sep 13 2010

Is Councillor Norriss representing the best interests of TDC ratepayers when he says "there's a lot of discontent with what's been happening out there" and being a "wee bit more satisfied" at the news that the lease of the former Smokehouse restaurant can be unilaterally terminated by council at any time?

Council granted the current leaseholders of the restaurant a 10 year lease, including a lease for an 80 seat outside dining area.

The most recent operators of the restaurant state that the outside seating area is "a critical part of the business" . Now - having closed the business - they say "that the area should be used by the public instead of a restaurant"

What's wrong with this picture?

Anyone who's been to the Mapua wharf knows that the current seating area has limited attraction for the general public compared with the seaward side of the wharf.

Anyone with a commercial background knows that ROI doesn't happen overnight, knows that any business needs a secure planning timeframe and recognises that terminating the lease for the outside seating area probably removes the commercial viability of the business.

It sounds suspiciously as if council's decision making processes are being driven by personal agendas.

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Do you support the proposed amalgamation of Nelson and Tasman councils?

Yes

No

Don't know/Don't care

Vote Result

Related story: (See story)

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Little day out

Little Day Out

Organisers of Victory's Little Day Out may have to start looking for a new name for the annual summer gathering.

whale stranding

Farewell Spit whale stranding

Project Jonah volunteers led a rescue effort to refloat a pod of 99 beached pilot whales in Golden Bay.

golden bay A and P

Golden Bay A&P show

Perfect summer weather and a cloudless sky attracted a crowd of more than 5000 to the showgrounds outside Takaka.