World Cup horn ban request

Last updated 12:00 18/11/2009
Vuvuzela trumpet
Reuters
TOO LOUD: A South African soccer fan blows on a traditional "vuvuzela" horn before the start of a match between New Zealand and Iraq in June.

Related Links

Future of noisy trumpet to be discussed by Fifa

Relevant offers

Japan's football chief has joined in the chorus of protestors wanting the noisy vuvuzela trumpet to be banned from next year's World Cup in South Africa.

FIFA had previously rejected calls for a ban on the plastic instrument, but Japan have now appealed to South African officials after playing a friendly against the World Cup hosts at the weekend.

"We have requested that the South African FA cut that noise out," Japan Football Association (JFA) president Motoaki Inukai was quoted as saying in Tuesday's edition of the Sankei Sports newspaper.

"You can't hear yourself speak. I will be bringing it up (with FIFA president Sepp Blatter)," Inukai added after Japan's 0-0 draw with South Africa in Port Elizabeth.

Japan defender Tulio said: "You can't hear what your team mates are saying from two metres away. You have to go up to them to give instructions."

The vuvuzela is synonymous with South African football fans but the incessant noise from the air horns triggered complaints from players, coaches and broadcasters during this year's Confederations Cup.

Television networks complained that the sound drowned out their commentary, while top players including Spain's Xabi Alonso called for the trumpet to be banned.

Asked for his thoughts on the subject after Saturday's stalemate, Japan coach Takeshi Okada responded dryly: "Perhaps if they play good football (the fans) will be quiet and watch."

Ad Feedback

- Reuters

23 comments
Post a comment
Helen   #23   03:10 pm Jun 13 2010

Please please please BAN them - I can't bear to watch the football when all I can hear is that awful buzz!!!

LEONARD   #22   01:46 pm Jun 13 2010

BAN THESE ANNOYING ,NOISE ,IRRITATING ,GERM SPREADING, CAN'T TELL WHOS BLOWING FOR WHO OR WHAT PURE NOTHING BUT RUIN THE GAME NOISE MAKERS AND CHEER!!!! YOUR TEAM ON BY VOICE AND BANNERS.

Gordon   #21   07:50 am Dec 05 2009

"It's part of soccer culture there, banning it will go down very badly with SA soccer fans. Those wanting it banned are in for a fight if they keep pushing for it."

Who cares, they completely ruin any sort of worthwhile atmosphere. Ban them, throw them all on a fire and never speak of them again. They're an abomination. It may not go down well with SA football fans but to bad, it won't go down with any of the other teams fans inbthe tournament if all you can hear is ridiculous and completely pointless buzzing from cheap plastic horns. There is no justification of them whatsoever. If they were blown with some sort ofr relevance to what was going on on the pitch then they would be slightly more tollerable, but they aren't.

juvekid   #20   01:55 pm Nov 19 2009

Vuvuzelas themselves are not the problem.

The problem is that they are handing them out for free.

It is too late to ban them now as the authorities gave out a shed-load when South Africa hosted the Confederations Cup earlier this year.

So even if they ban them now, there are already thousands of them in circulation.

phil_style   #19   10:38 am Nov 19 2009

BANstick for these bad, awful sounding things. Use your voice.

Davidt   #18   10:11 am Nov 19 2009

Ban

ts   #17   09:52 am Nov 19 2009

Let them have them for South Africa games and the rest, BAN BAN BAN, they create the worst atmosphere ever. They just blow them with no relevance to the game.

Drac   #16   08:47 am Nov 19 2009

Just let sky know that it'll drop there viewing numbers, and they'll be banned so quick ;)

Personally I hate the things, no issues with drums or similiar, but can't stand any horn instrument.

Ryan   #15   08:21 am Nov 19 2009

Every time I hear the word culture I reach for my revolver. Who would of thought that Africa would be cheap, plastic and tackey.? Here comes the BUZZY BEE. Cant wait for Brasil 2014 then we can all see a real football culture. You all whites better make that party.

patrick   #14   07:59 am Nov 19 2009

i heard a rumour that they werent exactly authentic and wikipedia seems to back it up. check it out...

Vuvuzelas have been said to be rooted in African history, but this is disputed.[5] People would blow on a kudu horn to call villagers to a meeting.[1] Adding to the appeal is African folklore that "A baboon is killed by a lot of noise." During the last quarter of a match, supporters blow vuvuzelas frantically in an attempt to "kill off" their opponents.[6][7] While such folklore has been attached to this instrument, the fact that it only truly became widely used after Neil van Schalkwyk, the co-owner of Masincedane Sport won the SAB KickStart Award in 2001, could indicate that this link has been contrived.


Show 1-13 of 23 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Which word or phrase do you find most annoying?

Whatever

Like

You know

Just sayin'

Seriously

None of the above

Vote Result

Related story: 'Whatever' world's most annoying word: poll

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content