Kiwi weightlifter Richard Patterson wins Commonwealth Games gold ... Read more

Smelter to appeal decision

Last updated 05:00 05/06/2014

Relevant offers

New Zealand Aluminium Smelters bosses are appealing an Employment Court's decision that they say will cost the business millions.

In May last year, 64 Engineering Printing and Manufacturing Union (EPMU) members won an Employment Relations Authority case they took against NZ Aluminium Smelters concerning the accrual of 'lieu days' for 12-hour shift workers.

The company appealed the decision and a two-day hearing was held in December. The appeal was overturned last month.

Tiwai Pt smelter bosses will now lodge an application to the Court of Appeal before June 13.

NZAS chief executive and general manger Gretta Stephens said appealing the decision made good business sense.

"I am aware this case has not gone unnoticed by the Government and other businesses. We are a fair employer that has been challenged on an unintended technical interpretation of a single sentence in a complex contractual setting."

NZAS believed the judge made an appealable error by disregarding the circumstances accompanying the introduction of the 12-hour shifts, instead focusing his attention on a single sentence in the contracts relating to additional leave for shift workers in lieu of statutory holidays, she said.

"It was generally agreed NZAS was concerned the change should not result in any additional cost to its business. The impact of the judgement would result in more than $20 million additional cost to NZAS."

The amount had increased because of salary movements since NZAS' previous calculation of $19m at the end of 2013, Stephens said.

EPMU director of organising Alan Clarence said smelter bosses were dragging workers through the mill on the issue.

The issue was about leave entitlements and not about costs, which it seemed to be suggesting, he said.

"Yes there would be costs but not all would be paid straight away. NZAS is scaremongering."

The appeal would drag the issue out longer for disappointed workers, he said.

"Workers have rights and entitlements and this is simply a case of NZAS not upholding them."

Ad Feedback

- The Southland Times


st strap Communites
Our E-Editions

Read our free publications online.

Win with the Times

Win with us!

Stl paper logo
Subscriber services

Click here for subscriber news and information.

ST digital edition thumb
Digital edition

Read The Southland Times online with our digital edition.


Click here to subscribe to our publications

Special offers
Opinion poll

Should Southland have its own film studio?

Yes, there is huge potential

No, there are more important issues for Southland

Vote Result

Related story: Film studio a winner for region - producer

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Daily diversions
Cartoons by Chicane, aka Mark Winter


Today's puzzles


Tangled Web blog

The 'cuddle game'

Apparently there's some sports-like event happening in Brazil at the moment

The Book Chooks blog

Old ideas

Is there really anything new in the latest diet trends?

The Roar sports blog

Riddle me this

Stricter measures at odds with TAB presence

Your Family News
Birth notices and anniversaries


View marriage and birth notices from around the region

Death notices

Death Notices

View obituaries from around the region