Come dine with me?

Last updated 13:00 02/05/2012

There are so many great food and food-related shows on television at the moment. I love Anthony Bourdain's shows. I have enjoyed shows featuring Jamie Oliver, Nigel Slater, Nigella Lawson, Heston Blumenthal. And I love Australian Masterchef, even if I am significantly less keen on the New Zealand version. But the one food show that I enjoy more than any other is not one that I find all that appetising, or inspiring, or even all that good. It is actually kind of ghastly. Quite awful, in fact.

It is the British Come Dine With Me. And, while I have no idea what time it is actually on, it almost always seems to be on. So, with all due respect to Chris Philpott's (excellent) On The Box blog, I feel the need to share with you my love for this most unlovely of television shows.

Picture this, if you will; four strangers go to each other's houses on consecutive nights, giving each other a score out of ten, with the winner receiving £1,000. They are not necessarily good cooks. At least one of them is likely to be a complete moron, one a raging egotist, one a bit kooky-loopy, and the other one, perhaps, quite nice. They are unlikely to have very much in common, which is an essential ingredient in the sort of culinary class warfare that invariably ensues. They poke around in each other's houses, they bitch about each other to the camera, sometimes they flirt, drunkenly. They cook some genuinely demented and ill-judged food. It is train-smash compelling. It is loathesome. I dig it.

Doesn't it already sound like a recipe for and from hell? It is total formula TV, but for me it is a winning formula. I love it. I find it totally compelling. And we haven't even mentioned the narrator yet...

Dave Lamb is his name. He is a British comedian and actor who has been doing voiceovers for the show since it began, in 2005. He is the omniscient, all-seeing eye who says about the contestants what they are too polite (or sober) to say to each other, and what they are too lacking in self-awareness to say about themselves. I find him absolutely hilarious. He admits that while he used to ad lib a lot in the early days, the show's writers are now very good at capturing its gris(t)ly essence. He uses the word "ruddy" a lot, as he is forbidden from swearing.  

Anyway, take the episode I watched this weekend just past - the delusional idiot fool taken by a radio DJ called Rick Vaughn, who is a bit like The Office's David Brent, only less charming. There is a woman who is desperately keen for the others to share her belief in, and love of, fairies. There is a silly old duffer who lists one of his many occupations as life coach, although I'm not sure how keen I would be on taking life coaching from a man who admits to over three hundred thousand pounds worth of debt. And there is a brassy redhead who, whilst claiming to be "an ordinary girl from Birkenhead",  has "married well" and is "comfortably off" living in a house with a lap pool, fountain and home cinema. An appealing mix of personalities and demographics, who would have had no other reason ever to meet. There is lots of prickliness, lots of snide remarks, some decent, and, mostly, some truly wretched food (the "Baked Alaska" being my pick of the bunch). And at the end of it, they all seem to have rather enjoyed the experience.

And whilst I loathe the idea of hosting strangers at my house and having to cook for them, and, perhaps worse, going to their place to eat is enough to bring me out in a cold sweat, watching it on television is peculiarly riveting. The show has been remade in South Africa and Ireland, but I reckon there is something gloriously British about the original. About Dave Lamb's hilarious commentary, about that uniquely British knack for digging it in and getting along, or, alternatively, drawing the long knives and really laying into each other.

I know that it is bad. I know that it is rotting my brain. I know I'm not learning anything from it. But blow me if I don't find it to be the most compellingly bad food show on TV.

Come Dine With Me - are you a fan? Come on, 'fess up. It's horrid, but it's great as well. Or do you just absolutely hate it? And what other spuriously food-themed shows do you love/hate?

Photograph by Peggy Greb

Join The Omnivore on Facebook

46 comments
Post a comment
aimee   #1   01:05 pm May 02 2012

i love this show. its terrible, but i love it. enjoyed best in omnibus i feel. love dave lamb- i reckon so many other narrators try and copy his style- but he is the best!

Fan!   #2   01:06 pm May 02 2012

I love Come Dine With Me. Pure television gold - and the best way to start of a saturday morning!

Sniffles   #3   01:07 pm May 02 2012

I'm ashamed to say I find it quite compelling viewing also. Yes, it's ghastly and often embarrassing and I certainly don't learn any cooking tips, but often I find myself glued to the TV on a Saturday morning (doing the ironing, of course) watching the stupid programme. I find the voice-over guy often very rude but quite hilarious. Shame on me.

Michelle   #4   01:10 pm May 02 2012

Love it!!! So glad someone else has 'fessed up! The commentary is the best part definitely. Its probably the only cooking show with people on who dont actually know how to cook - hilarious!

janet   #5   01:12 pm May 02 2012

Oh my gosh I love this show!! Although I preferred the old five people five half hour episode version because then the narrator really went for it. I made my husband who hates pretty much everything on tv watch it and he thinks its fantastic too.

There was an Austrlian version which wasn't so good- the people weren't crazy enough!

JaneE   #6   01:17 pm May 02 2012

That sounds fantastic, we have the Greek version in Australia and everyone is, on the whole, very nice and fair about everyone else. The Brit version sounds faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaar more interesting...

Clairabelle   #7   01:22 pm May 02 2012

I also love this show! I have even been known to discuss it via text conversations with a friend. It has made a decent replacement for our previous favourite show 'House Guest', which follows the Come Dine With Me format, but then one of the guests actually stays the night at the host's house! If you think dining with strangers is awkward - how about staying the night, too?!

mike   #8   01:26 pm May 02 2012

Great show, love the voice over!

Julz   #9   01:31 pm May 02 2012

haha! I watch this on saturday mornings when it plays all the eps back to back (like the home and away omnibus)--sadly I love that too! Love Dave Lamb! I love how there's always one person in the group that completely messes up their meal and is just a little to tipsy to really care!

Julz   #10   01:31 pm May 02 2012

haha! I watch this on saturday mornings when it plays all the eps back to back (like the home and away omnibus)--sadly I love that too! Love Dave Lamb! I love how there's always one person in the group that completely messes up their meal and is just a little to tipsy to really care!


Show 11-46 of 46 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content