Pay packets of Invercargill city councillors and directors questioned

Often the Holdco directors who were also around the council table were not able to vote on issues around Holdco, Graham ...

Often the Holdco directors who were also around the council table were not able to vote on issues around Holdco, Graham Sycamore said.

Concerns about city councillors who take pay packets from council-owned company directorships have resurfaced just in time for the local government elections. 

For weeks city council candidates have demanded the remuneration current Invercargill City Councillors receive for council-controlled organisation directorships.  

Some said councillors appointed as directors may not have the business acumen to make crucial business decisions. 

Holdco (Invercargill City Holdings), an investment company 100 per cent owned by the council on behalf of ratepayers, owned Electricity Invercargill Ltd and Invercargill City Forests Ltd, and 97 per cent of the Invercargill Airport. 

Invercargill forestry company under fire for secrecy
Invercargill mayoralty contest - the dynamic just changed

Councillors Graham Sycamore, Alan Dennis, Lindsay Thomas received $30,300 for being Holdco directors in 2016. 

Cr Graham Sycamore was also a director of Invercargill Property Ltd, for which he received $15,240. 

Sycamore said sometimes conflicts arose when councillors were also directors. 

Often the Holdco directors who were also around the council table were not able to vote on issues around Holdco, Sycamore said. 

Some cities no longer allowed elected councillors to be council organisation directors.

Ad Feedback

The Dunedin City Council had a different model, after the 2011 Larsen Report recommended Dunedin's elected councillors not be allowed to hold director positions in Dunedin City Holdings Ltd.

Sycamore said he thought the appointment of councillors as directors was fine, as long as they were appointed because they had the skills to do the job. 

If must not be forgotten that Venture Southland and the Southland Museum and Art Gallery were also council-controlled organisations, Sycamore said.  

"If you put a blanket ban on it, it would mean we have no council representation on the management at all." 

Electricity Invercargill Ltd director Cr Darren Ludlow received $27,219 in 2016.

Electricity Invercargill chairman Cr Neil Boniface received $51,080. 

Invercargill Mayor Tim Shadbolt was a director of the Invercargill Airport Ltd, for which he received $23,700. 

Invercargill City Forests Ltd had no directors who were also elected city councillors.

Council candidate Lindsay Dow said he had concerns about the appointment of city councillors to companies.

"The council-owned companies are required to have a board and that requires having directors on the boards, and they must be, in my view, the people who have the necessary business skills and acumen for the company involved." 

"While I don't like to see city councillors given directorships there may be times when somebody does have the necessary skills and businesss acumem." 

Dow did not like to see councillors given directorships to supplement their income.

In May, Cr Peter Kett said openly at a full council meeting he was concerned councillors were able to become directors in council's business and he wanted director remuneration addressed by the incoming council. 


Invercargill City Council remuneration, 2016/17: 


Mayor $117,800

Deputy Mayor $47,460

Committee Chair $42,375

Chair Audit Committee $38,165

Venture Southland Rep $38,165


Proposed remuneration:

Mayor $120,156

Deputy Mayor $53,300

Committee Chair (3) $46,300

Chair Audit Committee $40,400

Venture Southland Rep $40,400

Councillor $34,578


Directors' remuneration, 2016: 


Invercargill City Holdings 

Graham Sycamore $30,300

Alan Dennis $30,300

Lindsay Thomas $30,300


Electricity Invercargill Ltd

Neil Boniface (chairman) $51,080

Darren Ludlow $27,219 


Invercargill Airport Ltd 

Tim Shadbolt $23,700


Invercargill Property Ltd 

Graham Sycamore $15,240 



 - Stuff


Ad Feedback
special offers
Ad Feedback