Assault charges dismissed

Last updated 07:05 22/06/2012

Relevant offers


Lawyer says Jenny McNee not racist Sevens fraudster still to pay full reparation Till breath test do we part Jury trial for accused drug smuggler Facebook row ends in work sentence Driving was malicious - judge Policewoman found guilty of racial abuse Trial of man accused of fraud adjourned Southern man admits 14 dishonesty charges Accused got into debt in business

Charges against three Wanaka men accused of assault more than a year ago were dismissed in Queenstown District Court on Wednesday.

Samuel James Brooker, 21, a builder, Jordan Leigh Byrne, 20, and Dylan Poara Cooper-Slee, 19, appeared before Judge Kevin Phillips after a hearing on Tuesday.

All three were originally charged with injuring with reckless disregard for the safety of others on April 28 last year.

Sergeant Ian Collin sought an adjournment because a police witness was unavailable.

Media were asked to leave while the judge opted for a chambers hearing after a request by lawyer Bill Dawkins.

On Tuesday, Mr Collin told the court the defendants were drinking in Wanaka and there were three "areas of conflict" that night – in a pub, Woody's bar and Ardmore St.

Judge Phillips said witnesses described incidents with a woman in a bar and another involving punches and kicks.

There was evidence from a dentist and physiotherapist regarding the victim's injuries, but he was left with no other option but dismissal of all charges.

"In relation to each of these men the charges are not made out at all," the judge said.

"The charges are dismissed."

No-one was available for comment outside the court.

Ad Feedback

- The Southland Times


Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content