Cybercrime's cost at $523b worldwide
ELLEN NAKASHIMA AND AMANDA PETERSON
A Washington think tank has estimated the likely annual cost of cybercrime and economic espionage to the world economy at more than US$445 billion (NZ$523 billion) - or almost 1 per cent of global income.
The estimate by the Center for Strategic and International Studies is lower than the eye-popping US$1 trillion figure cited by President Barack Obama, but it nonetheless puts cybercrime in the ranks of drug trafficking in terms of worldwide economic harm.
"This is a global problem and we aren't doing enough to manage risk," said James Lewis, CSIS senior fellow and co-author of the report, released Monday.
The report, funded by the security firm McAfee, which is part of Intel Security, represents one of the first efforts to analyse the costs, drawing on a variety of data.
"Cybercrime costs are big, and they're growing," said Stewart Baker, a former Department of Homeland Security policy official and a co-author of the report. "The more that governments understand what those costs are, the more likely they are to bring their laws and policies into line with preventing those sorts of losses."
According to the report, the most advanced economies suffered the greatest losses. The United States, Germany and China together accounted for roughly US$200 billion of the total in 2013. Much of that was due to theft of intellectual property by foreign governments.
Though the report does not break out a figure for that, or name countries behind such theft, the US government has publicly named China as the major perpetrator of cyber economic espionage against the United States.
The Chinese government has accused the United States of being one of the biggest perpetrators of cyber-espionage, but the US government has always objected that it does not steal intellectual property and hand it to its own industries to give them a competitive advantage.
CSIS and McAfee estimated that the United States lost about US$100 billion. Germany was second with US$60 billion, and China followed with US$45 billion.
In both the United States and China, the losses represent about 0.6 per cent of their economies, while Germany's loss is 1.6 per cent.
Japan, the world's fourth largest economy, reported losses of US$1 billion, which researchers felt was extremely low and not credible.
Valuing intellectual property is an art form, based on estimating future revenues the intellectual property will produce or the value the market places on it, the report said. Putting a price tag on it is difficult but not impossible, it said.
Intellectual-property theft lessens companies' abilities to gain a full return on their inventions, and so they turn to other activities to make a profit, the report states. That depresses overall global rates of innovation, it said.
The report stated that countries appear to tolerate cybercrime losses as long as they stay at less than 2 per cent of their national income. If losses rise above 2 per cent, "we assume it would prompt much stronger calls for action as companies and societies find the burden unacceptable," it said.
The report breaks the harm into three categories, without giving figures. The largest, it said, is intellectual property theft. The second is financial crime, or the theft of credit card and other types of data largely by criminal rings. The third is theft of confidential business information to gain an advantage in commercial negotiations or business deals.
CSIS used several methods to arrive at a range of estimates, from US$375 billion to as much as US$575 billion. Researchers looked for published data from governments around the world. They interviewed officials in 17 major countries. And they came up with a predictive model based on a CSIS report last year that estimated the cost of cybercrime to the US economy. Their figures also included the cost of recovering from cyberattacks.
The main assumption they used was that the cost of cybercrime is a constant share of national income - at least in countries with similar levels of development. In less developed countries, that cost is about 0.2 per cent of gross domestic product, and in advanced economies it is almost 1 per cent.
In 2009, McAfee issued a news release that pegged global economic losses at more than US$1 trillion. The figure was cited by the White House and then-National Security Agency director Gen. Keith Alexander. But this year's CSIS report concluded that it was unlikely that cybercrime cost more than US$600 billion, which is the cost of the global drug trade.
The researchers said cybercrime and economic espionage require a response on par with global efforts to reduce drug trafficking. Besides better cybersecurity technologies, they said, governments need to devote resources to building defences and to commit to observing existing international commitments to protect intellectual property.