Eating my words, with relish
In my defence I could claim that I was being ironic, or that I was flagging the possibility of being very wrong by channelling the famous Alan Hansen gaffe. I could play the new baby card and declare that I have a three-week-old and I am suffering the fog of sleep deprivation. And I could argue that by not playing Boult and Diamanti the Black Caps who swaggered out of the Perth dressing room were hardly "kids".
But I’m going to take it on the body, and rub the bruise later. Last week I gave an opinion, and it was wrong. Very wrong. We did win something with kids, and I couldn’t be happier about it.
The enormity of what happened last night hasn’t hit me yet. Nor, considering the last ball was bowled in the wee smalls, has the tiredness. But even at a first glance this was a significant victory. We beat Australia on their turf. And this was no diluted Australian Second XI – it may be missing Symonds and Lee, but it contained Hussey, Clarke, Ponting, Johnson, Bracken and Tait. This has got to bolster confidence in our camp – it is the cricketing equivalent of a double espresso, with three spoonfuls of sugar. Those callow youths who wear the Silver Fern now know they can beat Australia on their red earth.
A more detailed autopsy reveals some interesting things. The runouts of Ponting and Clarke came from moments of balletic fielding, the type of accuracy Australians are better known for. The openers were both dismissed at silly mid off. This was a field placing of enormous chutzpah by Dan Vettori, and the fact that it was the giant Peter Fulton who was standing there, like a surly bouncer at a nightclub, shows intellectual finesse. I remember years ago the All Black lock Murray Pierce standing as close as he was allowed to an Irishman about to kick a penalty. The elongated Pierce raised his arms, challenging the man in green to successfully kick over an eight foot human barrier, let alone the goalposts beyond. The placing of Peter Fulton, as massive as Pierce, was similarly disruptive.
And let’s also look at the figures. New Zealand – all tightly controlled medium pace – bowled two wides in their innings. Australia, with the white ball flung 20 kilometres faster – conceded 23 sundries.
Finally look at two shocking decisions. McCullum’s was a poor LBW decision from an umpire who is on the decline. It is one of those capricious judgments that feels like a lightning strike – a random event. But the fact that we had lost an international "superstar" did not seem to affect the rest of the top order.
Much more serious was the end of Neil Broom’s working day. Brad Haddin, in taking a ball from Michael Clarke, knocked a bail from its groove, and Broom walked off presuming he was bowled. Haddin must have known something was wrong, maybe not in specifics but in general terms. There was doubt, and Neil Broom, batting with satin smoothness at the time, should have been recalled to the crease.
That Haddin chose not to say anything shows a mental desperation. Australia had lost three in a row before last night. They need a win like Melbourne needs a cool southerly. That the keeper was willing to "take" such a dismissal suggests that the Ocker confidence is terribly fragile.
Last night’s result was enormous, and I am happy to eat my words.
I appreciate I am not the first Stuff blogger to be contrite (search for a copy of Cooking with Political Opinions by Colin Espiner in all good book stores), but here is what I propose.
IngredientsOne large onion, chopped
Two tomatoes, peeled and chopped
Chicken livers, fried
Artichoke heart, chopped
A fistful of olives, pitted
Words (to taste)
Half a teaspoon of soy sauce (not traditional but surprisingly good)
Oregano
Cracked pepper
Serve with pasta, and crusty bread.
Picture: Photosport
Sponsored links
I'm not sure how Elliot keeps getting in the team....
Really? I was sure it was Bucknor. Then again Brad Haddin would probably swear blind it was Dickie Bird.
Martusah, I think Hamish was referring to Bucknor - the square leg umpire has the power to tell the bowlers end umpire if a batman's not out in the situation we saw last night, if they've seen it or feel it warrants closer inspection (i.e third umpire). Good to see you're a man of your word there Hamish, swallowing your pride & all that. It was a close run thing though.
How many times has BB McCullum been mistakenly dismissed? Seems like a lot.
I also would say: drop Elliot. He didn't bowl.
Bring in C Cumming. THe poor chap had to watch his Otago lose the final, knowing damn well he would not be picked for the first ODi. He would have made the difference in that final methinks.
Cumming might help us cope with Shaun Tait, and would be a good partner with Otago lad McCullum at the top.
Cumming's bowling is a lot like Elliot's, btw. And he has got a good few quickets for Otago.
I think a Cumming/Broom partnership would be better. Cumming 5, Broom 6.
Broom is Otago too.
Hamish, you had better eat it like Colin! On Youtube if you don't mind :P
Love it. McCullum I can live with as it was a roughie by the umpire (as David Hussey also got) but Haddin flat out cheated.
Good to see the boys not erupt like they did against the poms when Elliot was mown down then run out. Moral high ground is always a great place to stand.
While I love Cumming (pun intended) nobody likes him as a batsman.
And the only difference he would have made in the final would been a even quicker demolishing by ND!
Guptill blasts Black Caps to victory in first T20
Quake felt across lower North Island
Hurricanes weather elements to beat Chiefs
One dead after Northland crash
New York apartment sells for NZ$105m
Police car pig painter mystery unsolved
Flights disrupted as severe thunderstorms hit Auckland
Fatal speed-gliding crash near Wanaka
O'Connor attacks Smith's stance
Protester refuses community work
Helicopter companies still owe $5 million
Blackberry jams preserve the past
Residents tell of crime concerns
Newest First
Oldest First
Hamish, Bruce Oxenford may not be a terrific umpire but you may be testing your powers of prescience to suggest he is in decline after just 5 ODIs. Bucknor was at square leg when McCullum smashed the ball into his pads