God defend New Zealand (cricket)
GUEST POST BY JEREMY BROWN
"Grrr. Arrrggh." I may not share the same eloquence, international contacts or sway with the ladies, but when Holden picked up the receiver and called for backup, it was time to put up or shut up.
A previous Holden post looked into the changing landscape of the international game under influence of 2020 cricket, a shrewd observer will note his fingers firmly on the pulse. But for a game steeped in tradition, I don't think anyone could have foreseen how quickly things have moved in just two months.
The dangerous monster Holden spoke of has indeed broken its shackles and gone on a rampage, devouring all in its wretched path of destruction. Shane Warne and the Rajasthan Royals announcing this past week that they have signed a "global sport alliance", though what's sporting about it is rather unclear.
The Rajasthan Royals have "joined forces" with Hampshire, Cape Cobras, and Trinidad & Tobago, with the Victoria Bushrangers also rumoured to be ready to sign up. What this means for the teams involved is that they will all carry the "Royals" moniker and eventually even play in the same uniforms. How such a venture could play out at the Champions League should all of these teams qualify seems truly farcical.
Even at the local level in England with Hampshire no longer the Hawks, a new marketing low will be reached when they play rivals the Worcestershire Royals.
How did cricket turn a great idea into a flatliner? What made the Champions League so attractive was the colour and flavour brought from the far reaches of the cricketing world. Now we are told we only want one flavour and it's blueberry. "But I don't like blueberry," I cry. "Tough," says Manoj Badale, somehow serving it up while writhing around in a big pile of money.
And now that such a venture has broken the gate before the hired hands at the ICC had a chance to shore up the fenceline, we can expect other IPL franchises to follow suit. And we here in New Zealand will not be immune. The Rajasthan Royals announced plans to target teams in Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and God's own.
Take our mighty Central Districts Stags, winners of this year's HRV Cup. Resplendent in their traditional green uniforms (with their "oh so clever" Stag logo featuring a horn for every province they represent), CD could conceivably become the Central Kings Punjab XI. "Oh genius!" I cry before bursting into a boisterous guffaw. It may just be me, but I fail to see how the Central Kings Punjab XI effectively represents me or my district. I can't wait to hear the latest rather strange justification that gets touted when there's money to be made: "It's not a marketing nightmare, it's a fabulous opportunity!" "An opportunity to sell out our domestic identity for some magic beans."
I grumble derisively. Who needs magic beans? I've tried them, they're rubbish. Our domestic Twenty20 tournament was nothing if not a success. Big crowds, new venues, a high standard of competition. Sure I could nitpick that the competition was too long, there weren't enough international players and the coverage was sporadic, but we all know bums on seats don't lie when it comes to measuring success. And off we send our proud champions to take on the world, brilliant.
It's a shame to think that such success could be so short-lived.
If New Zealand cricket sells us out to India, it will be under the guise of preventing our best players from being headhunted as mercenaries, but in truth they would be aiming both barrels at both feet. By allowing global juggernauts to evolve, clubs will replace country as pride of place. The best players will play for cashed-up clubs and maybe return to wear their country's colours for World Cups - maybe. The power and control of world cricket will forever shift from the countries who play the game, to the clubs that profit from it.
The face of cricket worldwide is changing and unfortunately for New Zealand every outcome appears to be a bad one for us. We'll either lose our identity or lose our best players. The flow-on effects of both on our national game will be worn by our future players.
Under the global club model, a player like Kane Williamson would have been plucked and sent to India long ago. That could possibly be great for him, but a disaster for our other young players who don't get to push themselves against the best. Under the influence of a club who has paid for his cricket tuition, he may never choose to don the silver fern and represent his country - he could actually be contractually prevented from doing so.
It's a knife edge on which we sit. Cricket has never before had the opportunity to rival other major sports and reach out to new audiences on such a global level, never before have players had the opportunity to earn as much, and never before has New Zealand cricket been so threatened. Every player and supporter in this country at every level should be aware of the threat posed to us all by this rampaging beastie.
The ICC, our protector against this great monster, sits like an idle king in his castle as the lands are overrun and the villages pillaged. One servant did say they thought they heard him quietly mutter in a polite British accent: "How dare you?" before retiring for nap time, sword sheathed to prevent any scratches. But alas, I fear even our nimble king will be devoured by the insatiable appetite of this greedy goliath.
God defend New Zealand? That might be a bit of a stretch.
» Follow NZStuffBlogs on Twitter and get fast updates on all Stuff's blogs.
» Fancy yourself as a blogger? Whoever wins Blog Idol 2 will blog on contract at Stuff as well as win a new Nokia phone. Put on your blogging hat and enter!
Sponsored links
Except that the Rajasthan Royals have clearly stated they intend to pursue a New Zealand province for their global venture.
The first cricketing clan! How cute. I wonder if the players all have joint sessions of World of Warcraft as well?
Let's compare cricket to rugby. Every year those who aren't quite good enough to make the All Blacks or who are nearing the end of their career head to Japan or Europe. Then there is the very rare occasion when a player at the top of his game ie Luke McAllister heads over as well. But we always maintain our core; the top guys like Muliaina, Carter and McCaw. Why? Because the NZRU pulls out all the stops. Unfortunately NZ Cricket don't have all the stops. They can't compete with the money on offer so when push comes to shove we will lose all our top players. It's quite concerning. What can the ICC do? Any suggestions?
looks like the baps are settling with average once again. ingram and taylor both getting in and bombing it. the openers, well they survived the first over so that rates as a success. dv to the rescue again. guppy, well, when will the brain explosion come?
It's Déjà vu all over again for our Test batting lineup. The top order fails and the lower order comes to the rescue. The only difference this time was that it was Guptil and not Vettori who played Saviour. Our tactics these days seem to revolve around lulling the opposition into a sense of security by giving them some cheap and easy wickets at the start of our innings, then hoping our lower order can take advantage of any relaxation in the opposition bowlers. You can see this tactic in operation by what's happened to our two best test batting prospects of recent times, Ryder and Guptil. Both come into the side batting at three and they both perform poorly. Both are moved down the order to five and have immediate success. The first three batting positions in the New Zealand Test batting lineup should be renamed Cannon fodder slot 1, Cannon fodder slot 2 and Cannon fodder slot 3.
New Zealand cricket has gone down the toilet for the last 5 years. I used to be a big Black Caps fan in the days of Astle, Cairns, Fleming, etc, etc.
Now the only decent players in the squad are Guptill, Vettori, Taylor and McCullum. The rest are utter rubbish. Grant Elliot is pathetic, but wait... Shane Bond will save the day! For the 1-2 matches he plays each year before he injures himself again.
Gone are the days when I could watch the Black Caps play for hours on end in epic test matches. For the last 5+ years I will watch the Aussie test matches or 1 dayers over a NZ game any day of the week.
In regards to our "top" players (there are really only 2 in NZ, Vettori and McCullum) going over to India to play for top dollars, then by all means go and play. Playing against a Bangladesh team, the bottom of the heap in terms of international cricket is a complete joke.
20/20's bring in the crowds, 50 over games are getting old and worn out in terms of fan interest and the die hards like me still like test cricket but not the new generation of cricket fans.
The domestic cricket scene in New Zealand is fairly average, I've watched less than 10 minutes of it this entire season and don't intend to watch any more than that just because of the lower class of entertainment on offer.
Rant over.
@ Elliott #7
Great to know you'll be watching the NZ v Aussie series!
You sold yourself short not watching the HRV Cup, there was some excellent cricket played with many of our local players outshining the foreign imports.
Odd you don't consider Taylor a top player, or that you lash a player like Grant Elliott who averages 45 in ODI's.
Which are still quite popular if that Stuff poll is to be believed. All people want to see is a good contest.
Where 2020's are weak is that they don't provide the depth of character and drama the longer forms do. The crash and bash of 2020 has it's place, but it's in domestic and emerging cricket.
Speaking of which, go Afghanistan! Shame that more associate nations couldn't go through to the world cup. To think a team like the Netherlands who beat Afghanistan in pool play and beat England in the world cup last, have to miss out, is a real shame.
For the 2020 world cup, I'd like to see 16 teams as the shorter the version, the more even the playing field.
Canada, Scotland, Kenya, UAE and Namibia are all there or there abouts. I also think it's time Ireland were added to the international touring schedule.
It may be from The Sun but....:
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/sport/football/2855068/City-in-cricket-IPL-team-bid.html
It's a long article if you've got the time, but approaches the club vs country conundrum from a different angle
http://www.cricinfo.com/magazine/content/story/447867.html
Well done Guppy and Mac. Superb.
Guptill blasts Black Caps to victory in first T20
Quake felt across lower North Island
Hurricanes weather elements to beat Chiefs
One dead after Northland crash
New York apartment sells for NZ$105m
Flights disrupted as severe thunderstorms hit Auckland
Bolivian squirrel monkeys arrive at Wellington Zoo
Fatal speed-gliding crash near Wanaka
Newest First
Oldest First
I think you are over estimating the influence that India will have on the NZ domestic scene. It's more likely that the only players that it will really effect is the NZ players who are known to the International/Indian market.